
Facing a Michigan felony trial or sentencing? Know the rules before the judge applies them
I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. This page covers what comes after a not guilty plea in a Michigan felony case: the jury trial, the speedy trial rules, sentencing under the guidelines, and the habitual offender statutes that can raise the maximum sentence. I treat the trial and the sentencing as two separate fights and prepare for both from the start. I do not promise outcomes.
The short answer. You have the right to be tried by a jury of 12, and the verdict must be unanimous. You can give up the jury only with the prosecutor’s consent and the court’s approval. MCR 6.401; MCR 6.410. If you are convicted, the judge must use the sentencing guidelines, but the guidelines are advisory and a departure must be reasonable and explained on the record. MCL 769.34(3); MCR 6.425(C), (D)(1). If you have prior felonies, the prosecutor can seek a higher maximum sentence under the habitual offender statutes, but only by filing a written notice within 21 days after the arraignment on the information. MCL 769.13(1). Nothing here predicts how a case will end.
A felony case that is not resolved by a plea goes to a trial date, and the date is only the start. Before then there are speedy trial and release issues, jury selection, and the question of whether a jury or a judge should decide the facts. After a conviction there is a presentence report, a guidelines score, a possible habitual offender enhancement, and a sentencing hearing where every number in the file can be argued. Each of these has its own rule and its own deadline, and some of them are lost if nobody raises them at the right time.
From jury selection to appeal: the steps after a not guilty plea
| Step | What happens | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Jury selection | Prospective jurors are questioned. Challenges for cause are decided by the court, and each side has a set number of peremptory challenges | MCR 6.412 |
| Directed verdict motion | After the prosecutor rests or after all the evidence, the court must direct an acquittal on any charge where the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction | MCR 6.419(A) |
| Verdict | A jury verdict must be unanimous and is returned in open court. Either side may ask that each juror be polled | MCR 6.410(B); MCR 6.420(A), (D) |
| New trial motion | The court may order a new trial on any ground that would support reversal on appeal or because the verdict resulted in a miscarriage of justice | MCR 6.431(B) |
| Presentence report | The probation officer investigates and reports in writing. Copies go to both sides at least two business days before sentencing | MCR 6.425(A), (B) |
| Sentencing | The court hears from the lawyers, the defendant and any victim, states the sentence and credit, explains any departure and orders restitution | MCR 6.425(D)(1) |
| Appeal advice | After a trial conviction the court must advise you of appellate review and that a request for a lawyer must be filed within 42 days of the judgment to appeal by right | MCR 6.425(F)(1) |
Jury trial, bench trial and the unanimous verdict
The defendant has the right to a jury. With the prosecutor’s consent and the court’s approval, a defendant may waive it and be tried by the judge alone. MCR 6.401. The court cannot accept a waiver until you have been arraigned on the information, or have waived arraignment, and have been offered a chance to consult with a lawyer. Before accepting it, the court must advise you in open court of your right to a jury trial and ask you personally whether you understand the right and voluntarily give it up, and a word-for-word record of that exchange must be made. MCR 6.402.
If the case is tried to the judge, the judge must find the facts specially, state conclusions of law separately, and put the findings on the record or in a written opinion. MCR 6.403.
A jury that decides a case must have 12 jurors. Before a verdict is returned, the parties may stipulate, with the court’s consent, to fewer than 12. The court must personally advise the defendant of the right to 12 jurors and confirm that the defendant voluntarily gives it up, and the court may refuse the stipulation in the interest of justice. MCR 6.410(A). The verdict must be unanimous. MCR 6.410(B). I decide with you whether a jury or a judge is the better fact-finder for your facts. That depends on the charge, the evidence and the judge, and it is your decision to make after we talk it through.
How jury selection works
Jury selection follows MCR 2.510 and 2.511 except where chapter 6 says otherwise. MCR 6.412(A). Questioning of prospective jurors has two purposes: to find grounds for challenges for cause and to give the lawyers the knowledge to use peremptory challenges intelligently. The court may question the jurors itself or let the lawyers do it, and if the court does it, the lawyers may ask follow-up questions or submit questions for the judge to ask. MCR 6.412(C).
A juror is subject to challenge for cause on any ground listed in MCR 2.511(E) or any other reason recognized by law, and if the court finds a ground present it must excuse the juror on a party’s motion. MCR 6.412(D). Each defendant gets 5 peremptory challenges, unless an offense charged is punishable by life imprisonment, in which case a defendant tried alone gets 12, and defendants tried together get fewer each as the number of defendants grows. The prosecutor gets the same number as a defendant tried alone or, when defendants are tried jointly, the total number to which all the defendants are entitled. On a showing of good cause, the court may grant a party more. MCR 6.412(E).
Speedy trial, the 180-day release rule and the prison inmate rule
The defendant and the prosecution are both entitled to a speedy trial, and if the constitutional right is violated, the defendant is entitled to dismissal of the charge with prejudice. MCR 6.004(A). There is no fixed number of days. Courts balance four factors: the length of the delay, the reason for it, the defendant’s assertion of the right, and the prejudice to the defendant. Barker v. Wingo, 407 U.S. 514, 530 (1972); People v. Williams, 475 Mich. 245, 261-64 (2006).
Michigan measures the delay from the date of arrest. Williams, 475 Mich. at 261. The Michigan Supreme Court has said that after a delay of eighteen months or more, prejudice is presumed and the burden shifts to the prosecution to show that there was no injury. Williams, 475 Mich. at 262. In Williams itself the delay was over nineteen months and presumptively prejudicial, yet the Court found no violation, because the defendant did not object to the delays, agreed to the trial date, did not assert the right until the day before trial, and did not show prejudice to the defense. Williams, 475 Mich. at 264. Prejudice can be to the person or to the defense, and prejudice to the defense, meaning the defendant’s ability to prepare the case, is the more serious concern. Williams, 475 Mich. at 264. Because the factors include whether you asserted the right, I put a demand for a speedy trial in writing early and keep a record of each adjournment and who asked for it.
Release after 180 days in jail. Separately, in a felony case where the defendant has been incarcerated 180 days or more for the same crime or conduct, or 28 days or more in a misdemeanor case, the defendant must be released on personal recognizance, unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is likely to fail to appear or to present a danger to another person or the community. MCR 6.004(C). In counting those days the court excludes, among other things, delay from pretrial motions and defense adjournments. MCR 6.004(C)(1)-(6).
The 180-day rule for prison inmates. If you are in a Michigan prison and have an untried charge pending in the state, you must be brought to trial within 180 days after the Department of Corrections delivers to the county prosecutor written notice of where you are imprisoned and a request for final disposition. MCL 780.131(1); MCR 6.004(D)(1). If action is not commenced within the time, the court loses jurisdiction and must dismiss the charge with prejudice. MCL 780.133.
Directed verdict and new trial motions
At the close of the prosecutor’s case, I move for a directed verdict. The court must direct an acquittal on any charged offense for which the evidence is insufficient to sustain a conviction, and the motion can be renewed after all the evidence. MCR 6.419(A). The court may reserve its decision and decide the motion after the verdict, and I can also file the motion after a jury verdict. MCR 6.419(B), (C).
A motion for a new trial may be filed before a timely claim of appeal is filed. MCR 6.431(A)(1). On the defendant’s motion, the court may order a new trial on any ground that would support appellate reversal of the conviction or because it believes the verdict has resulted in a miscarriage of justice, and it must state its reasons. MCR 6.431(B).
The presentence report
Before sentencing, the probation officer must investigate your background and character, verify material information, and report in writing. The report includes a description of your prior convictions, a complete description of the offense, your work and social history, medical and substance abuse history, the harm to any victim and the restitution needs, any statement you wish to make, and a specific recommendation for disposition. MCR 6.425(A)(1). On request, the probation officer must give your lawyer notice and a reasonable opportunity to attend the presentence interview. MCR 6.425(A)(2).
The court must give copies of the report to the prosecutor and to your lawyer at a reasonable time, and not less than two business days, before sentencing. If that does not happen, either side is entitled on oral motion to an adjournment to review the report and prepare corrections, additions or deletions. MCR 6.425(B). At sentencing the court must determine that you, your lawyer and the prosecutor have had a chance to read and discuss the report, and must give each party an opportunity to explain or challenge the accuracy or relevancy of anything in it. MCR 6.425(D)(1)(a), (b).
If information is challenged, the court must hear the parties and either make a finding or decide that a finding is unnecessary because it will not take the information into account. If the challenge has merit, the court must order the report corrected. MCR 6.425(D)(2)(a). I go through the report line by line with you.
Sentencing guidelines, departures and credit for jail time
To find the recommended minimum range, the court finds the offense category and scores the offense variables to reach an offense variable level, scores the prior record variables to reach a prior record variable level, finds the offense class, and reads the range from the grid where the two levels meet. MCL 777.21(1). The court must use the guidelines, and the proposed scoring must accompany the presentence report. MCR 6.425(C). A minimum sentence may be within the appropriate range, and the court may not impose a minimum, including a departure, that exceeds two-thirds of the statutory maximum. MCL 769.34(2).
The guidelines are not mandatory. The Michigan Supreme Court held that the scheme violated the Sixth Amendment to the extent that judicial fact-finding mandatorily raised the minimum range, and made the guidelines advisory, with departures reviewed for reasonableness. People v. Lockridge, 498 Mich. 358, 365 (2015). A court may depart if the departure is reasonable and the court states its reasons on the record. It may not base a departure on a characteristic already counted in the range unless the record shows it was given inadequate or disproportionate weight. MCL 769.34(3); MCR 6.425(D)(1)(e). A scoring error changes the range, so I check each variable against the record.
If the upper limit of the recommended minimum range is 18 months or less, the court must impose an intermediate sanction unless it states reasonable grounds on the record for jail or prison. MCL 769.34(4)(a).
Credit, allocution and restitution. If you served jail time before sentencing because you were denied bond or could not furnish it, the court must specifically grant credit for that time. MCL 769.11b. Before imposing sentence, the court must give your lawyer a chance to speak, address you personally so that you can speak or present information to lessen the sentence, give the prosecutor an equal chance to speak, and hear from any victim present. MCR 6.425(D)(1)(c). The court must also state the minimum and maximum and the credit for time served and order the amount of restitution. MCR 6.425(D)(1)(d), (f).
Habitual offender enhancement
A habitual offender statute raises the maximum sentence for a new felony committed in Michigan when you have prior felony convictions. A prior can be a conviction from another state if it would have been a felony or an attempted felony in Michigan. MCL 769.10(1). The court must still set both a minimum and a maximum within the limits, and it may not set a maximum lower than the maximum for a first conviction. MCL 769.10(2).
| Prior felonies | What the statute allows for the new felony | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| One | If a first conviction carries less than life, a maximum of not more than 1-1/2 times the longest first-conviction term, or a lesser term. If it carries life, life or a lesser term | MCL 769.10(1)(a), (b) |
| Two or more | If a first conviction carries less than life, a maximum of not more than twice the longest first-conviction term, or a lesser term. If it carries life, life or a lesser term | MCL 769.11(1)(a), (b) |
| Three or more | If the maximum on a first conviction is 5 years or more, or life, life or a lesser term. If the maximum is under 5 years, a maximum of not more than 15 years | MCL 769.12(1)(b), (c) |
| Three or more, serious crime, listed prior felony | A minimum of not less than 25 years | MCL 769.12(1)(a) |
A major controlled substance offense is punished under part 74 of the public health code instead. MCL 769.10(1)(c). For a sentence under section 10, 11 or 12 for an offense other than a major controlled substance offense, you are not eligible for parole until the minimum term fixed by the judge has been served, unless the sentencing judge gives written approval for earlier parole where the law allows it. MCL 769.12(4).
The notice. The prosecutor must file a written notice of intent to seek an enhanced sentence within 21 days after arraignment on the information, or within 21 days after the information is filed if arraignment is waived. The notice must list the prior convictions that may be relied on, be filed with the court and be served on you or your lawyer, with written proof of service. MCL 769.13(1), (2); MCR 6.112(F). I calendar the 21 days from the day of the arraignment and check the notice against the date and the listed priors.
Challenging a prior. A defendant who has been given notice may challenge the accuracy or constitutional validity of one or more of the listed priors by written motion served on the prosecutor. MCL 769.13(4). The court decides whether the priors exist, without a jury, at sentencing or at a separate hearing, and the prosecutor may use a judgment of conviction, a transcript, a register of actions, information in the presentence report or your own statement. MCL 769.13(5). You must make a prima facie showing that a prior is inaccurate or constitutionally invalid. If you do, the prosecutor must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that it is accurate or valid. MCL 769.13(6). I need your old case files early for that reason.
Effect on the guidelines. For a sentence under section 10, 11 or 12, the court scores the underlying offense as usual, then raises the upper limit of the recommended minimum range by 25 percent for a second felony, 50 percent for a third felony and 100 percent for a fourth or later felony. MCL 777.21(3). The lower limit stays the same.
Correcting a sentence and appeal deadlines
The court may correct an invalid sentence on its own initiative or on a motion by either party. MCR 6.429(A), (B)(1). A party may not raise on appeal a guidelines scoring issue, or a challenge to the accuracy of information used for a sentence within the guidelines range, unless it was raised at sentencing, in a proper motion for resentencing, or in a proper motion to remand filed in the Court of Appeals. MCR 6.429(C). For that reason I raise every scoring objection at the sentencing hearing, on the record.
After a trial conviction, the court must advise you right after sentencing that you are entitled to appellate review, that the court will appoint a lawyer if you cannot afford one, and that the request for a lawyer must be filed within 42 days after entry of the judgment of sentence if you want to appeal by right. MCR 6.425(F)(1). If the court imposes a minimum longer than the guidelines range, it must also advise you on the record and in writing that you may seek review on that ground. MCR 6.425(F)(5); MCL 769.34(7). Call me as soon as the verdict comes in.
Problems I look for and what I can ask the court to do
| Problem | What I can ask the court to do | Authority |
|---|---|---|
| Delay that violates the speedy trial right | Dismiss the charge with prejudice | MCR 6.004(A) |
| 180 days or more in jail on a felony | Release on personal recognizance, subject to excluded delay and the court’s findings | MCR 6.004(C) |
| Insufficient evidence | Direct a verdict of acquittal | MCR 6.419(A) |
| A verdict that is a miscarriage of justice, or any ground that would support reversal | Order a new trial | MCR 6.431(B) |
| Errors in the presentence report | Make a finding, disregard the information and order the report corrected | MCR 6.425(D)(2)(a) |
| A wrong guidelines score | Correct it at sentencing, or by motion to correct an invalid sentence | MCR 6.429(A), (C) |
| A habitual offender notice outside the 21 days, or missing the listed priors | Object to the enhancement | MCL 769.13(1), (2) |
| An inaccurate or invalid prior conviction | Hold a hearing on a written motion, with the prosecutor bearing the burden once I make a prima facie showing | MCL 769.13(4), (6) |
How I handle a felony trial and sentencing
- Read the charging papers. I check the information, the habitual offender notice, the dates and the list of prior convictions against the court file.
- Track the clock. I record your arrest date, your jail days and every adjournment, who asked for it, and I put speedy trial and release demands in writing.
- Decide jury or judge with you. I explain what each choice means for your facts, and I do not waive a jury without your informed decision.
- Prepare the trial. I plan jury questions, challenges, cross-examination, the directed verdict motion and the record I will need if there is an appeal.
- Prepare for sentencing before the verdict. I gather work, family, treatment and community information so it is ready if the presentence interview comes.
- Audit the report and the score. I check the presentence report, every offense and prior record variable, the jail credit, the restitution request and the listed priors.
- Preserve the record. I raise each objection when it comes up, so it can be reviewed later.
- Keep you informed. I tell you what each hearing is for, what the judge said and what the next deadline is.
Ways a felony case may end without a trial
Many felony cases do not reach a verdict. Depending on the facts, the case may end or change in one of these ways.
- Dismissal for delay. A violation of the constitutional speedy trial right requires dismissal with prejudice. MCR 6.004(A)
- Dismissal under the 180-day rule. For an untried charge against a prison inmate, failure to act within the time requires dismissal with prejudice. MCL 780.133
- A plea agreement. What the agreement covers, including how any habitual offender notice is handled, is part of the negotiation, and the decision to accept is yours.
- A deferral program. For some drug possession and domestic assault charges, the court may defer proceedings and dismiss on completion. MCL 333.7411(1); MCL 769.4a(1)
What I need from you
Bring the information, the bond conditions and every notice you have received, especially anything that says the prosecutor intends to seek an enhanced sentence. List every prior conviction you can remember with the court, the year and what happened, and bring the paperwork if you have it. Tell me the day you were arrested and every day you spent in jail, and keep a list of every court date and who asked to move it. If a presentence interview is scheduled, call me before it, because what you say to the probation officer goes into the report the judge reads.
Where your Kent County felony trial and sentencing will be heard
I represent clients charged in Grand Rapids, Kentwood, Grandville, Wyoming and across Kent County. A felony begins in district court with an arraignment and, if the case continues, a preliminary examination. MCL 600.8311(c), (e). Michigan law sets the Kent County district courts by municipality. The 61st District Court serves the city of Grand Rapids, the 59th serves the cities of Grandville and Walker, the 62A serves the city of Wyoming and the 62B serves the city of Kentwood. MCL 600.8128a; MCL 600.8130(1)-(3). The 63rd District Court serves the rest of Kent County, which includes the cities of Rockford, Lowell, Cedar Springs and East Grand Rapids and the surrounding townships. MCL 600.8130(4). If the magistrate binds the case over, the felony is arraigned in the circuit court, which for Kent County is the 17th Judicial Circuit. MCL 766.13; MCL 600.8311(f); MCL 600.518. Sentencing, and any hearing on the priors in a habitual offender notice, take place before the circuit judge. MCL 769.13(5).
Why people hire me for a Michigan felony trial or sentencing
You work directly with me, the lawyer handling your case, from the first court date to the sentencing hearing. I explain each deadline, each score and each choice in plain terms. I do not promise outcomes. I prepare for trial and for sentencing from the beginning, because both depend on work done early.
My fee depends on the charges, how complicated the case is and how far it is likely to go. We talk about the fee at the consultation, before you decide whether to hire me.
Questions I hear from people facing a Michigan felony trial or sentencing
Can I choose a bench trial instead of a jury in Michigan, and does the jury have to be unanimous?
You have the right to a jury, and you may waive it and be tried by the judge only with the prosecutor’s consent and the court’s approval (MCR 6.401). A felony jury has 12 jurors unless the parties stipulate to fewer with the court’s consent, a misdemeanor jury in district court has 6 jurors (MCL 600.8355 and MCR 6.620(A)), and under MCR 6.410(B) a jury verdict must be unanimous.
Is there a deadline for my trial in Michigan? What is my speedy trial right?
There is no single day count for the constitutional right. MCR 6.004(A) gives you and the prosecution a right to a speedy trial and requires dismissal with prejudice if your constitutional right is violated. Courts weigh the length of delay, the reason for it, your assertion of the right, and prejudice to you. Delay is measured from arrest, and prejudice is presumed after eighteen months.
How are Michigan sentencing guidelines calculated?
Under MCL 777.21, the court finds the offense category and the offense variables that apply, scores them, and totals the points for an offense variable level. It scores the prior record variables for a prior record variable level. It then finds the offense class and uses the grid where the two levels meet to read the recommended minimum sentence range in months or life.
What is habitual offender status in Michigan, and how much can it increase my sentence?
It raises the maximum penalty for a felony when you have prior felony convictions. With one prior felony, MCL 769.10 allows a maximum up to 1-1/2 times the longest first-offense term. With two or more priors, MCL 769.11 allows up to twice the longest term. With three or more priors, MCL 769.12 allows up to life or up to 15 years, depending on the offense’s maximum, and has a 25-year minimum in some serious-crime cases.
How long does the prosecutor have to file a habitual offender notice in Michigan?
The prosecutor must file a written notice of intent to seek an enhanced sentence within 21 days after your arraignment on the information, or within 21 days after the information is filed if arraignment is waived or eliminated. The notice must list the prior convictions to be relied on and any mandatory minimum that results, and must be filed with the court and served on you or your lawyer.
Can I challenge a prior conviction the prosecutor is using to enhance my sentence?
Yes, in writing. Under MCL 769.13(4), a defendant who has been given notice may challenge the accuracy or constitutional validity of one or more listed prior convictions by written motion served on the prosecutor. The defendant has the burden of making a prima facie showing that a prior conviction is inaccurate or constitutionally invalid. The judge decides without a jury.
Related Michigan pages
- Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer
- Pleas and plea deals
- Felony defense
- Fines, restitution and court costs
- Criminal appeals
- Post-conviction relief
I represent people facing felony trials and sentencing in Kent County and West Michigan. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.