Skip to content

Comparative Fault and Shared Liability · Grand Rapids and Kent County

Grand Rapids Comparative Fault Lawyer

I represent injured people in Michigan, and when a defendant blames the plaintiff or someone else, I work out where the fault belongs and what it does to the claim.

Curved black tire skid marks across gray pavement

The other side says it was partly your fault. Here is how Michigan counts that

I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids personal injury lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. This page explains comparative fault in a Michigan injury case: how a jury splits responsibility among the people involved, what a percentage of fault does to damages, how a defendant puts the blame on someone who is not even in the lawsuit, and which statutes and court rules control. I represent injured people. When a defendant points at my client, or at a stranger to the case, I look at what the defendant has to plead and prove and what the evidence supports. I do not promise outcomes.

The short answer. In Michigan, an injured person’s own fault does not bar a claim for damages, but it reduces them by the injured person’s percentage of fault. If the injured person’s share is greater than the combined fault of everyone else, whether or not they are parties, economic damages are still reduced and noneconomic damages are not awarded. Each defendant generally pays only its own share. A defendant that wants the jury to count a nonparty’s fault has to give notice under the court rules, and the person who asserts fault carries the burden of proving it. Nothing here predicts how your case will end.

Most people hear about comparative fault from an insurance adjuster, not from a lawyer. The adjuster says the other driver told a different story, or that the photos show you were not paying attention, or that the property owner is not the only one who could have prevented the fall. Sometimes the point is fair and sometimes it is a way to lower a number. Either way, it matters, because in Michigan fault is not an all or nothing question. The statutes ask a jury to put a percentage on every person whose conduct caused the injury, and the money follows the percentages. MCL 600.2958; MCL 600.2959; MCL 600.6304.

How fault is counted in a Michigan injury case

The statute says that, subject to the cutoff described below, “a plaintiff’s contributory fault does not bar that plaintiff’s recovery of damages.” MCL 600.2958. The reduction comes from the next section, which directs the court to “reduce the damages by the percentage of comparative fault of the person upon whose injury or death the damages are based.” MCL 600.2959.

That same section contains the threshold that matters most in practice. If the injured person’s percentage of fault “is greater than the aggregate fault of the other person or persons, whether or not parties to the action,” the court reduces economic damages by that percentage and “noneconomic damages shall not be awarded.” MCL 600.2959. Two details deserve attention. The comparison is against the combined fault of all others, not against the largest single defendant. And the others include nonparties, so a defendant who succeeds in putting fault on an absent person can push the plaintiff’s share closer to the line.

The jury decides the percentages through special interrogatories. When more than one person is at fault, “including third-party defendants and nonparties,” the court asks the jury for two findings: the total amount of each plaintiff’s damages, and the percentage of the total fault of all persons that contributed to the death or injury, “including each plaintiff and each person released from liability under section 2925d, regardless of whether the person was or could have been named as a party to the action.” MCL 600.6304(1). In setting those percentages, the trier of fact considers “both the nature of the conduct of each person at fault and the extent of the causal relation between the conduct and the damages claimed.” MCL 600.6304(2).

“Fault” has a statutory definition. It “includes an act, an omission, conduct, including intentional conduct, a breach of warranty, or a breach of a legal duty, or any conduct that could give rise to the imposition of strict liability, that is a proximate cause of damage sustained by a party.” MCL 600.6304(8). The last words are the limit. Conduct that did not cause the harm does not receive a percentage, however careless it looks.

Key rules at a glance

Rule What the statute or rule says Source
Plaintiff’s fault does not bar recovery In an action seeking damages for personal injury, property damage or wrongful death, a plaintiff’s contributory fault does not bar recovery, subject to MCL 600.2959 MCL 600.2958
Reduction and the cutoff Damages are reduced by the injured person’s percentage of fault; if that percentage is greater than the aggregate fault of the others, noneconomic damages are barred MCL 600.2959
Motor vehicle cases Noneconomic damages are assessed on the basis of comparative fault, and not in favor of a party who is more than 50% at fault MCL 500.3135(2)(b)
Several liability Liability is several only and not joint, subject to exceptions; a person is not required to pay more than his or her percentage of fault MCL 600.2956; MCL 600.6304(4)
Nonparty at fault notice The fault of a nonparty is not assessed unless notice is given, generally within 91 days after the party files its first responsive pleading MCR 2.112(K)
Burden of proof The person seeking to establish fault has the burden of alleging and proving it MCL 600.2960(1)
Intoxication An absolute defense if the injured person was impaired by liquor or a controlled substance and, as a result, was 50% or more the cause; otherwise damages are reduced by that percentage MCL 600.2955a(1)
Safety belt Failure to wear one may be considered evidence of negligence, but may not reduce recovery by more than 5% MCL 257.710e(8)

What has to be shown on each side

A comparative fault dispute has two sides to prove. The plaintiff still has the ordinary burden in a negligence case: a duty, a breach, causation and damages. The Michigan Supreme Court has described negligence actions, including those based on premises liability, as requiring those four elements. Kandil-Elsayed v F & E Oil, Inc, 512 Mich 95 (2023). In addition, a defendant who says the injured person or someone else shares the blame has its own burden. The statute puts it plainly: “The person seeking to establish fault under sections 2957 to 2959 has the burden of alleging and proving that fault.” MCL 600.2960(1).

That burden has practical consequences. A defendant cannot simply suggest in closing argument that the plaintiff should have been more careful. The fault has to be pleaded, usually as an affirmative defense, and then supported by testimony, records or physical evidence. Under the court rules, affirmative defenses such as contributory negligence and assumption of risk are stated in the responsive pleading under a separate heading, with the facts that support them. MCR 2.111(F)(3). When a defense is missing from the pleading or thinly supported, I raise that early.

The same section also says what comparative fault is not. Sections 2957 to 2959 “do not create a cause of action.” MCL 600.2960(2). Assigning a percentage to a nonparty gives the injured person no claim against that nonparty by itself, and it gives the nonparty no liability in the case.

Arguments defendants make about fault

Defendants and insurers return to the same handful of arguments. I read each one against the statute and the evidence, not against the adjuster’s tone.

  • The injured person was careless too. This is the ordinary comparative fault defense. It reduces damages by a percentage and, past the line in MCL 600.2959, removes noneconomic damages. It has to be proved with evidence, not asserted.
  • Someone else is to blame. A defendant can ask the jury to assign fault to a person who is not in the case. That person may be another driver who left the scene, a contractor, a property manager, an employer, a product maker or a family member. The notice rule and the duty requirement discussed below apply.
  • The condition was open and obvious. In premises cases the Michigan Supreme Court has held that “the fact-finder may consider, among other things, whether the condition was open and obvious” as part of the breach inquiry. Kandil-Elsayed. The injured person’s own care is then a fault question for the jury rather than a reason to end the case before it starts.
  • The injured person was not wearing a safety belt. The statute allows the failure to be considered as evidence of negligence, but “that negligence must not reduce the recovery for damages by more than 5%.” MCL 257.710e(8).
  • The injured person was impaired. Under MCL 600.2955a, impairment from liquor or a controlled substance is an absolute defense only if, because of the impairment, the person was 50 percent or more the cause of the accident. If the person was less than 50 percent the cause, the damages are reduced by that percentage. The statute also creates a presumption of impairment where a presumption would arise under the vehicle code standard. MCL 600.2955a.

Damages and what a percentage does to them

Damages are measured first and reduced second. The jury finds the total amount of the plaintiff’s damages, then finds the percentages of fault, and the court determines the damages to each plaintiff “in accordance with the findings.” MCL 600.6304(3). If the jury puts 20 percent of the fault on the injured person, damages are reduced by 20 percent. The injured person is not penalized beyond that percentage, unless the 50 percent line is crossed.

The line itself has two different forms, and mixing them up is a common mistake. The general statute, MCL 600.2959, cuts off noneconomic damages when the injured person’s fault is greater than the aggregate fault of the others, and it does so for personal injury, property damage and wrongful death actions. The motor vehicle statute, MCL 500.3135(2)(b), separately says that damages “must not be assessed in favor of a party who is more than 50% at fault.” Both are written as “greater than” or “more than,” which means exactly 50 percent does not cross either line.

There is one more consequence that people overlook. A person who was driving his or her own vehicle without the required insurance in effect cannot recover noneconomic damages from another driver at all, because damages “must not be assessed in favor of a party who was operating his or her own vehicle at the time the injury occurred and did not have in effect for that motor vehicle the security required by section 3101(1).” MCL 500.3135(2)(c). That rule applies regardless of percentage. Fault in a claim against another driver does not change what the injured person’s own insurer owes in personal protection benefits, which “are due under this chapter without regard to fault.” MCL 500.3105(2).

Nonparties at fault, several liability and settlements

Putting fault on someone who is not in the case

The statute tells the jury to consider the fault of each person “regardless of whether the person is, or could have been, named as a party to the action.” MCL 600.2957(1). The court rule adds a notice requirement: the trier of fact “shall not assess the fault of a nonparty unless notice has been given as provided in this subrule.” The notice must name the nonparty, give the last known address or the closest identification possible, and include a brief statement of the basis for believing the nonparty is at fault. It must be filed within 91 days after the party files its first responsive pleading, and the court allows a later filing only on a showing that the facts were not and could not with reasonable diligence have been known earlier, provided the late filing does not cause unfair prejudice. MCR 2.112(K)(2), (3).

That notice does two things for me. It tells me who the defendant is blaming and why, so I can investigate that person. And it opens a short window. A party served with the notice may file an amended pleading against the nonparty within 91 days of service of the first notice identifying that nonparty. MCR 2.112(K)(4). The statute gives the same 91 days from identification of a nonparty and says a claim added then “is not barred by a period of limitation unless the cause of action would have been barred by a period of limitation at the time of the filing of the original action.” MCL 600.2957(2).

A nonparty must have owed the injured person a duty

A defendant cannot name just anyone. In Romain v Frankenmuth Mutual Insurance Co, 483 Mich 18 (2009), the Michigan Supreme Court held that “proof of a duty is required ‘before fault can be apportioned and liability allocated’ under the comparative fault statutes, MCL 600.2957 and MCL 600.6304.” The nonparty named in that case owed the plaintiffs no duty, so the court affirmed the order striking the notice. If a defendant names someone who had no legal obligation to the injured person, I move to strike the notice.

An immune person can still receive a percentage. In Estate of Goodwin v Northwest Michigan Fair Ass’n, 325 Mich App 129 (2018), a wrongful death case, the Court of Appeals considered whether parental immunity prevents a jury from allocating fault to a child’s parent as a nonparty. The court held that parental immunity does not preclude that allocation where the parent owed the child a duty, and it vacated the judgment and remanded for a new trial. The practical point is that a nonparty’s immunity from suit does not by itself keep that person off the verdict form.

What a finding against a nonparty does not do is create liability. The statute says “If fault is assessed against a nonparty, a finding of fault does not subject the nonparty to liability in that action and shall not be introduced as evidence of liability in another action.” MCL 600.2957(3). The percentage exists only “to accurately determine the fault of named parties.”

Several liability and its exceptions

Michigan generally does not make one defendant pay for another’s share. In an action for personal injury, property damage or wrongful death, “the liability of each defendant for damages is several only and is not joint,” and the section “does not abolish an employer’s vicarious liability for an act or omission of the employer’s employee.” MCL 600.2956. The companion rule in the verdict statute is that a person “shall not be required to pay damages in an amount greater than his or her percentage of fault.” MCL 600.6304(4).

The exceptions are specific. A defendant is jointly and severally liable if the defendant’s act or omission is a crime of which gross negligence is an element, for which the defendant is convicted, or a listed alcohol or controlled-substance crime, including the vehicle code offense under MCL 257.625, for which the defendant is convicted. MCL 600.6312. Medical malpractice has its own rules. If the plaintiff is found without fault, each defendant’s liability is joint and several, and if the plaintiff has fault, an uncollectible share can be reallocated on motion within six months after final judgment. A governmental agency, other than a governmental hospital or medical care facility, does not pay an uncollectible amount beyond its own percentage. MCL 600.6304(6), (7).

Settling with one defendant

A settlement with one party changes the case without ending it. A release or covenant not to sue given in good faith to one of two or more persons for the same injury “does not discharge 1 or more of the other persons from liability for the injury or wrongful death unless its terms so provide,” and it discharges the person who received it “from all liability for contribution to any other person.” MCL 600.2925d. The released person’s fault still counts in the percentages, because the verdict statute includes “each person released from liability under section 2925d,” and judgment is not entered against that person. MCL 600.6304(1)(b), (3). Before I recommend any partial settlement I check how the released person’s share will appear on the verdict form, because a low settlement from a defendant who may be assigned a high percentage can cost the plaintiff later.

Fault in motor vehicle cases

Car, truck and motorcycle cases carry the most comparative fault arguments, because the insurers are experienced and the facts are often contested. Three statutory points come up repeatedly. First, the noneconomic damages line in MCL 500.3135(2)(b) applies to the claim against the other driver. Second, the uninsured-driver bar in subsection (2)(c) applies to a person who was operating his or her own vehicle without the required security. Third, the property damage claim for a vehicle, often called the mini-tort claim, has its own comparative fault rule and a cap of $3,000 for accidents after July 1, 2020, and damages cannot be assessed for a vehicle operated without the required security. MCL 500.3135(3)(e), (4).

How I handle a comparative fault case

  1. I get the facts from you first: what happened, who was there, what each person did, and what you remember about the minutes before and after.
  2. I collect the records that fix the scene in time, such as police reports, photographs, video, vehicle data, 911 audio and witness names, and I send preservation letters where evidence could be lost.
  3. I read the answer and affirmative defenses to see what fault the defendants allege against you, and I check whether the defense has been pleaded with facts as the court rule requires.
  4. I watch for notices of nonparty fault from the first responsive pleading forward, calendar the 91 day periods, and decide with you whether to add the named person as a defendant.
  5. I test each nonparty for a duty to you and a causal link to the injury, and I move to strike a notice when the person had no legal obligation to you.
  6. I develop the evidence on each person’s conduct and its causal relation to your damages, through discovery, records and, when needed, an accident reconstruction or other consulting witness.
  7. I plan the verdict form and the jury instructions early, because the percentage lines and the several liability rules decide how a result is collected.
  8. I talk through settlement positions with you with the fault percentages in mind, so that a decision on one defendant is made with its effect on the others in view.

Ways a comparative fault dispute may end without a trial

Most injury disputes do not end in a jury verdict. A comparative fault question can settle in mediation, in direct negotiation, or after a motion narrows the case, for example by striking a notice of nonparty fault or by resolving a legal question about a duty. I explain the options and their trade offs, and the decision is yours. I do not promise outcomes.

What I need from you

  • The date, time and place of the injury, and a short written account while it is fresh.
  • Photographs and video of the scene, the vehicles or the condition, plus anything you saved from your phone.
  • Names and contact information for witnesses, and for anyone you think may share the blame.
  • The police or incident report number, and the insurance information for every party.
  • Medical records and bills, including the first visit, and a list of providers you have seen.
  • Any letter, email or call from an insurance company, and any statement you have already given.

Do not give a recorded statement to the other side’s insurer before we speak, and do not sign a release or medical authorization you have not had read to you.

Where your Kent County comparative fault case will be heard

I represent clients in Grand Rapids, Kentwood, Grandville, Wyoming and across Kent County. Under MCL 600.8301(1), the district court has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions when the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000. Kent County district courts include the 61st District Court in Grand Rapids, the 59th in Walker and Grandville, the 62A in Wyoming, the 62B in Kentwood and the 63rd for Rockford, Lowell, Cedar Springs, East Grand Rapids and the surrounding townships. Larger claims are filed in the Kent County Circuit Court, the 17th Judicial Circuit.

Why people hire me for a Michigan comparative fault matter

You work directly with me, the lawyer handling your case. I give you the strengths and weaknesses of your position straight, including the points the other side will press on fault. I represent injured people, so I am looking at the claim from your side of the table.

Fees depend on the type of case, its complexity and whether it is likely to go to trial. I explain my fee arrangement at the consultation, before you decide whether to hire me.

Questions I hear from people whose fault is disputed

What happens to my damages in Michigan if the jury says I was exactly 50 percent at fault, or 51 percent?

Damages are reduced by the injured person’s percentage of fault. Noneconomic damages are cut off only if that percentage is greater than the aggregate fault of the others, whether or not parties. Because all percentages are assigned out of 100 percent of the total fault, exactly 50 percent is not greater than the others’ 50, and 51 percent is. At 51 percent economic damages are still reduced, but noneconomic damages are not awarded. The 2012 amendment of MCL 600.2959 applies to causes of action that arose on or after Mar. 28, 2013.

Authority: MCL 600.2958; MCL 600.2959; MCL 600.6304(1)(b). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

How does a Michigan jury decide what percentage of fault each person gets?

In a case involving the fault of more than one person, the court instructs the jury to answer special interrogatories on the plaintiff’s total damages and the percentage of the total fault of all persons. In setting the percentages, the jury considers both the nature of each person’s conduct and the extent of the causal relation between the conduct and the damages claimed. Fault includes acts, omissions, intentional conduct, breach of warranty, breach of a legal duty and conduct giving rise to strict liability, if it is a proximate cause.

Authority: MCL 600.6304(1), (2), (3) and (8); MCL 600.2957(1). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

If the jury puts some of the fault on a person who is not a party, does that person become liable?

No. Under MCL 600.2957(3), assessments of fault for nonparties are used only to accurately determine the fault of the named parties. A finding of fault against a nonparty does not subject that nonparty to liability in the action and may not be introduced as evidence of liability in another action. A party who learns of a nonparty through a notice can move to add that person as a defendant within 91 days.

Authority: MCL 600.2957(2) and (3); MCR 2.112(K)(2), (3) and (4); MCL 600.2956 and MCL 600.6304(4). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

In a Michigan injury case, is each defendant responsible for the whole judgment, or only its own share?

Generally only its own share. In personal injury, property damage and wrongful death actions, liability is several only and not joint, and a person is not required to pay more than his or her percentage of fault, except as the statute provides. A defendant convicted of certain crimes (gross negligence or alcohol or controlled-substance offenses) is jointly and severally liable, and medical malpractice cases have separate rules. An employer’s vicarious liability for an employee remains.

Authority: MCL 600.2956; MCL 600.6304(4), (6) and (7); MCL 600.6312. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

If I settle with one defendant in a Michigan injury case, does that release the others, and does that person’s fault still count?

A good-faith release or covenant not to sue given to one of two or more persons for the same injury does not discharge the others unless its terms so provide, and it discharges the person who received it from contribution liability to others. The released person’s fault is still included in the fault percentages, and judgment is not entered against that person.

Authority: MCL 600.2925d; MCL 600.6304(1)(b), (3) and (4); MCL 600.2959. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

If I had been drinking or using a controlled substance when I was injured, does Michigan bar my claim?

It can. Under MCL 600.2955a it is an absolute defense that the injured person had an impaired ability to function due to the influence of intoxicating liquor or a controlled substance and, as a result of that impairment, was 50 percent or more the cause of the accident or event. If the person was less than 50 percent the cause, the award is reduced by that percentage. Note that this line is 50 percent or more, not more than 50.

Authority: MCL 600.2955a(1) and (2)(b). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

How does the 50 percent fault rule work in a Michigan car accident claim?

For a noneconomic damages claim against another driver, MCL 500.3135(2)(b) says damages are assessed on the basis of comparative fault, but must not be assessed in favor of a party who is more than 50 percent at fault. A party operating an uninsured vehicle cannot recover those damages at all. The property damage mini-tort claim has its own rule, with the same more-than-50-percent bar and a limit of $3,000 for accidents after July 1, 2020.

Authority: MCL 500.3135(1), (2)(b) and (2)(c); MCL 500.3135(3)(c), (3)(e) and (4); MCL 600.2958 and 600.2959; MCL 500.3105(2). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

I represent injured people in Michigan injury and wrongful death cases. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.

Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.

Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.

MBisson@BissonLegal.com

This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.

Do not wait. Call me.

The sooner I am involved, the more I can do. I keep what you tell me private. Please share only the basics until we have spoken.