These are general answers about Michigan law, not advice about your situation. Each answer links to the statute, court rule or case it rests on. Last reviewed October 2026.
By Mitchell S. Bisson, Michigan attorney (P79807). Reviewed October 2026.
Quick answers
The short version
Is a 17-year-old charged as a juvenile or an adult in Michigan?
Since October 1, 2021, a juvenile in Michigan is a person under 18, so 17-year-olds are handled in the family division of circuit court (juvenile court) in most cases. Before that date the cutoff was under 17. The main exception is that a prosecutor may charge a 14-, 15-, 16- or 17-year-old with a listed serious offense in adult court.
Only the prosecutor can file a delinquency petition for a crime-type charge. The court decides whether to authorize it, the juvenile may be detained or released while the case is pending, and the case then goes to a plea or a trial. At trial the rules of evidence and the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard apply, and a jury of 6 can be demanded. If the juvenile is found responsible, the court enters a disposition after a risk and needs assessment.
Does a juvenile have a right to a lawyer, and can a juvenile give that right up?
Yes. In a delinquency case the court must advise the juvenile of the right to an attorney at each stage of the formal calendar and must appoint one in listed situations, including when the family cannot afford one. A juvenile may waive a lawyer only in open court, with a finding that the waiver was voluntary and understanding, and not if a parent or guardian objects. At disposition the court cannot order the juvenile or parents to pay for a court-appointed lawyer, although the judge at a waiver hearing may assess the cost of appointed counsel against the juvenile or others responsible who are able to pay.
Michigan law, reviewed October 2026. General information, not advice about your situation. Select a question for the full answer and the authority behind it.
Michigan · 15 questions
Questions on this page
- Is a 17-year-old charged as a juvenile or an adult in Michigan?
- How does a juvenile delinquency case move through Michigan's family division, from petition to disposition?
- Does a juvenile have a right to a lawyer, and can a juvenile give that right up?
- Is a juvenile adjudication the same as a criminal conviction?
- What is a waiver hearing, and how does a judge decide whether to send a juvenile to adult court?
- What is a "specified juvenile violation," and is the move to adult court really automatic?
- What is a "designated" juvenile case, and what changes when a juvenile is tried like an adult?
- If a juvenile is convicted in adult court or in a designated case, can the sentence still be a juvenile one?
- What can a juvenile court do at disposition if a juvenile is found responsible?
- Is there a way to resolve a juvenile case without a formal court case, such as diversion or the consent calendar?
- Can a juvenile adjudication be set aside or expunged?
- Are juvenile court records public?
- Can a juvenile's statement to police be used in court, and does a parent have to be present?
- Can a juvenile be held in detention before trial?
- What happens to a juvenile case if the young person turns 18 before it ends?
Is a 17-year-old charged as a juvenile or an adult in Michigan?
Since October 1, 2021, a juvenile in Michigan is a person under 18, so 17-year-olds are handled in the family division of circuit court (juvenile court) in most cases. Before that date the cutoff was under 17. The main exception is that a prosecutor may charge a 14-, 15-, 16- or 17-year-old with a listed serious offense in adult court.
Michigan's "Raise the Age" legislation changed the definition of "juvenile" in the juvenile code. Until September 30, 2021, a juvenile was a person under 17 who is the subject of a delinquency petition; beginning October 1, 2021, it is a person under 18 (MCL 712A.1(1)(i)). The family division of circuit court has exclusive original jurisdiction over a juvenile under 18 who has violated a state law or municipal ordinance (MCL 712A.2(a)(1)). An arrested child under 18 is to be taken immediately before the family division, and a petition is filed there; if a criminal case against a child is pending in another court and it turns out the child is under 18, the case is transferred to the family division (MCL 764.27).
The exceptions are for "specified juvenile violations," a list of serious offenses. For a person 14 years of age or older but under 18, the prosecutor may authorize a complaint and warrant in adult court (MCL 764.1f), and the circuit court has jurisdiction over those offenses (MCL 600.606). The family division also acquires jurisdiction over a 14-or-older juvenile charged with a specified juvenile violation only if the prosecutor files a petition in that court instead of authorizing a complaint and warrant (MCL 712A.2(a)(1)).
The definition of juvenile changes on October 1, 2021 (MCL 712A.1(1)(i)). Separately from the juvenile code, a person 18 through 25 who pleads guilty to a covered offense may be considered for youthful trainee status in adult court (MCL 762.11(2)).
How does a juvenile delinquency case move through Michigan's family division, from petition to disposition?
Only the prosecutor can file a delinquency petition for a crime-type charge. The court decides whether to authorize it, the juvenile may be detained or released while the case is pending, and the case then goes to a plea or a trial. At trial the rules of evidence and the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard apply, and a jury of 6 can be demanded. If the juvenile is found responsible, the court enters a disposition after a risk and needs assessment.
A delinquency case based on a law violation begins when the prosecuting attorney files a petition, and the court decides whether formal jurisdiction should be acquired and the petition authorized (MCL 712A.11(2)). Before trial the court may detain the juvenile or release him or her to a parent, but detention is limited to listed circumstances such as offenses so serious that release would endanger public safety, and a detention screening tool must be used before a juvenile is held in a secure facility (MCL 712A.15). A case can also be handled outside the formal calendar through diversion (MCL 722.823) or the consent calendar (MCL 712A.2f).
On the formal calendar, trial is to be held within 6 months of authorizing the petition unless adjourned for good cause, and a detained juvenile whose trial has not started within 63 days of being taken into custody, for reasons not attributable to the defense, must be released pending trial (MCR 3.942(A)). The Michigan Rules of Evidence and proof beyond a reasonable doubt apply (MCR 3.942(C)). In a trial without a jury, the court must state its findings of fact and conclusions of law on the record or in a written opinion, and the juvenile may move for a directed verdict at the close of the prosecutor’s case (MCR 3.942(D), (E)). A person interested in the hearing may demand a jury of 6 (MCL 712A.17(2)). The verdict is guilty or not guilty of the offense charged or a lesser included offense (MCR 3.942(E)).
If the court finds the juvenile within the juvenile code, it enters an order of disposition. A designated individual or agency must conduct a risk and needs assessment before disposition and share the results and a dispositional recommendation with the court, the juvenile, counsel and the prosecutor (MCL 712A.18(9)). The proceedings are not criminal proceedings unless the code says otherwise (MCL 712A.1(2)).
Does a juvenile have a right to a lawyer, and can a juvenile give that right up?
Yes. In a delinquency case the court must advise the juvenile of the right to an attorney at each stage of the formal calendar and must appoint one in listed situations, including when the family cannot afford one. A juvenile may waive a lawyer only in open court, with a finding that the waiver was voluntary and understanding, and not if a parent or guardian objects. At disposition the court cannot order the juvenile or parents to pay for a court-appointed lawyer, although the judge at a waiver hearing may assess the cost of appointed counsel against the juvenile or others responsible who are able to pay.
MCR 3.915(A) governs delinquency proceedings. If the juvenile is not represented, the court must advise the juvenile of the right to an attorney at each stage on the formal calendar, including trial, plea of admission and disposition (MCR 3.915(A)(1)). The court must appoint an attorney if the parent, guardian or legal custodian refuses or fails to appear, is the complainant or victim, or the juvenile and those responsible for support are found financially unable to retain an attorney and the juvenile does not waive; or if those responsible for support refuse or neglect to retain one; or if the court decides that the interests of the juvenile or the public require appointment (MCR 3.915(A)(2)).
A juvenile may waive the right to an attorney except where a parent, guardian, legal custodian or guardian ad litem objects, or when the appointment rests on the court's own determination that appointment is required. The waiver must be made in open court to the judge or referee, who must find and put on the record that it was made voluntarily and understandingly (MCR 3.915(A)(3)). At trial, a juvenile who asks to proceed without a lawyer must be told of the dangers and disadvantages of self-representation, and the court must make sure the juvenile is literate and competent to conduct the defense (MCR 3.942(B)(3)).
Cost is addressed in the statute. MCL 712A.18(3) says the court shall not order a juvenile or the juvenile's parent, guardian or legal custodian to pay the costs of care, services, court-appointed attorney representation, or other costs or assessments related to the juvenile's court proceeding. At a waiver hearing, however, the judge may assess the cost of providing legal counsel against the juvenile or those responsible for the juvenile who are financially able (MCL 712A.4(6)).
Is a juvenile adjudication the same as a criminal conviction?
Usually no. Delinquency proceedings in the family division are not criminal proceedings unless the code says otherwise, and the result is an adjudication and a disposition, not a conviction. The big exceptions are designated cases and cases waived to adult court, which are criminal proceedings that end in a conviction with the same effect as an adult conviction.
Under MCL 712A.1(2), proceedings under the juvenile code "are not criminal proceedings" except as otherwise provided. A juvenile found within the code receives an order of disposition under MCL 712A.18, not a judgment of conviction. Two routes lead to a real conviction. If a case is designated for trial in the same manner as an adult under MCL 712A.2d, the proceedings are criminal proceedings with all the protections of adult court, and a guilty plea, no contest plea or guilty verdict "must result in entry of a judgment of conviction" with the same effect as one obtained in a court of general criminal jurisdiction (MCL 712A.2d(7)). If the family division waives jurisdiction under MCL 712A.4, the juvenile is tried in the court having general criminal jurisdiction.
An adjudication still leaves a record. The court reports final dispositions to the State Police (MCL 712A.18(16)), and the court must see that biometric data and fingerprints were collected before entering a disposition (MCL 712A.18(8)). Even after an adjudication is set aside, the State Police keep a nonpublic record that can be used for limited purposes, including a court's consideration of sentence after a later felony conviction (MCL 712A.18e(13)). Whether a particular juvenile adjudication counts for other purposes, such as employment, licensing, immigration or sex offender registration, depends on the specific law involved.
What is a waiver hearing, and how does a judge decide whether to send a juvenile to adult court?
A traditional waiver is a motion by the prosecutor asking the family division judge to give up jurisdiction so the juvenile can be tried as an adult. It is available when the juvenile is 14 or older and accused of a felony. The judge first finds probable cause, then holds a hearing on whether waiver serves the interests of the juvenile and the public, weighing nine listed factors with extra weight on the seriousness of the offense and the prior record.
Under MCL 712A.4(1), if a juvenile 14 or older is accused of an act that would be a felony if committed by an adult, the family division judge may waive jurisdiction on the prosecutor's motion, after which the juvenile may be tried in the court having general criminal jurisdiction. The court must give notice of the hearing to the juvenile, the prosecutor and, if addresses are known, the parents or guardians, with notice stating that waiver would allow prosecution as though the juvenile were an adult (MCL 712A.4(2)). The court first determines on the record whether there is probable cause to believe a felony was committed and that the juvenile committed it; that finding takes the place of the preliminary examination (MCL 712A.4(3), (10)).
If probable cause is found, the court holds a hearing on whether the interests of the juvenile and the public would be served by waiver. It must consider the seriousness of the offense, the juvenile's culpability, prior delinquency record, programming history, adequacy of juvenile programming and amenability to treatment, dispositional options, developmental maturity and emotional and mental health, tribal values if the juvenile is a member of a federally recognized tribe, and the impact on any victim, giving greater weight to the seriousness of the offense and the prior record (MCL 712A.4(4)). The court must waive jurisdiction if the juvenile has previously been subject to the jurisdiction of the circuit court under MCL 712A.4 or MCL 600.606 (MCL 712A.4(5)).
The juvenile has the right to counsel, who must have access to the records or reports the judge relies on and may request a continuance if new information is introduced (MCL 712A.4(6), (7)). The judge must enter a written order and state findings of fact and conclusions of law (MCL 712A.4(8)). The statute was amended effective October 1, 2024 (2023 PA 291) to revise the factors.
What is a "specified juvenile violation," and is the move to adult court really automatic?
No. Michigan's list of "specified juvenile violations" lets the prosecutor choose to charge a 14- to 17-year-old in adult court, or to file in the family division and designate the case to be tried as an adult. It is sometimes called an automatic waiver, but the statutes give the prosecutor discretion and do not require adult charging. Diversion is not available for these offenses.
The list appears in several places with the same content: MCL 712A.2(a)(1), MCL 712A.2d(9), MCL 764.1f(2) and MCL 600.606(2). It includes arson in the first degree (MCL 750.72), assault with intent to commit murder (750.83), assault with intent to maim (750.86), attempted murder (750.91), first- and second-degree murder (750.316, 750.317), kidnapping (750.349), first-degree criminal sexual conduct (750.520b), assault with intent to rob while armed (750.89), bank, safe or vault robbery (750.531), armed robbery (750.529) and carjacking (750.529a), along with MCL 750.84 and MCL 750.110a(2) if the juvenile is armed with a dangerous weapon, certain escapes from juvenile facilities, major controlled substance offenses under MCL 333.7401(2)(a)(i) and 333.7403(2)(a)(i), attempts, conspiracies and solicitations, lesser included offenses, and other offenses arising from the same transaction if the juvenile is charged with one of the listed offenses.
If the prosecutor has reason to believe a juvenile 14 or older but under 18 committed a specified juvenile violation, the prosecutor "may" authorize the filing of a complaint and warrant with a magistrate (MCL 764.1f(1)), and the circuit court has jurisdiction to hear the case (MCL 600.606(1)). The alternative is to file a petition in the family division and designate the case as one in which the juvenile is to be tried in the same manner as an adult (MCL 712A.2d(1)). The family division has jurisdiction over a 14-or-older juvenile charged with a specified juvenile violation only if the prosecutor files the petition there instead of authorizing a complaint and warrant (MCL 712A.2(a)(1)).
A juvenile accused or charged with a specified juvenile violation "must not be diverted" under the juvenile diversion act (MCL 722.823(3)). Even if the case begins in adult court, the sentencing rules for juveniles in MCL 769.1 and the limits on life without parole for people under 18 under MCL 769.25 still apply.
What is a "designated" juvenile case, and what changes when a juvenile is tried like an adult?
In a designated case the juvenile stays in the family division's petition process but is tried in the same manner as an adult, with all adult procedural protections. For a specified juvenile violation, the prosecutor can designate the case. For any other offense, the prosecutor must ask and the court decides after a hearing. A guilty plea or verdict results in a conviction with the same effect as an adult conviction.
Designation is governed by MCL 712A.2d. For a specified juvenile violation, the prosecutor may designate the case as one in which the juvenile is to be tried in the same manner as an adult (MCL 712A.2d(1)). For any other offense, the prosecutor may request designation, and the court may designate only after a hearing and a finding that the interests of the juvenile and the public would be served, considering the same nine factors used in waiver hearings, with greater weight on the seriousness of the offense and the juvenile's prior delinquency record (MCL 712A.2d(2)).
If the designated petition alleges a felony or an offense punishable by more than 1 year, the court must hold a probable cause hearing within 14 days after designation. That hearing is the equivalent of a preliminary examination and must be conducted by a judge other than the one who will try the case if the juvenile is tried as an adult (MCL 712A.2d(4)). If probable cause is found, the case is set for trial as an adult would be; if not, the petition is dismissed (MCL 712A.2d(5), (6)).
Once a case is designated, the proceedings are criminal proceedings and "must afford all procedural protections and guarantees" of adult court. A plea of guilty or no contest, or a guilty verdict, results in a judgment of conviction with the same effect as one obtained in a court of general criminal jurisdiction (MCL 712A.2d(7)). After conviction, the court enters a disposition or imposes a sentence under MCL 712A.18(1)(o) (MCL 712A.2d(8)).
If a juvenile is convicted in adult court or in a designated case, can the sentence still be a juvenile one?
Often yes, but not for every offense. For a short list of serious crimes, including murder, armed robbery and first-degree criminal sexual conduct, the court must sentence a juvenile as an adult. For other offenses, the judge holds a hearing at sentencing and decides between juvenile probation with commitment to youth rehabilitation services and an adult sentence. In a designated case the court may also enter a juvenile disposition or an adult sentence under the juvenile code.
Under MCL 769.1(1), a court must sentence a juvenile convicted of any of twelve listed crimes in the same manner as an adult: first-degree arson, assault with intent to commit murder, assault with intent to maim, attempted murder, conspiracy and solicitation to commit murder, first- and second-degree murder, kidnapping, first-degree criminal sexual conduct, armed robbery and carjacking. For other offenses, MCL 769.1(3) requires a hearing at sentencing to decide whether the interests of the public would be served by placing the juvenile on probation and committing the juvenile to an institution or agency under the youth rehabilitation services act, or by imposing any other sentence an adult could receive. The factors include the seriousness of the offense, culpability, prior delinquency record, programming history, adequacy of juvenile programming, and dispositional options, with greater weight on seriousness and prior record. The statute states that the court sentences the juvenile in the same manner as an adult unless it determines by a preponderance of the evidence that the public's interests would be served better by the juvenile probation and commitment option. With the prosecutor's and defendant's consent, the hearing may be waived, but then only the juvenile option is available (MCL 769.1(4)). In a hearing under MCL 769.1(3), the court must state its findings on the record (MCL 769.1(6)).
For cases designated under MCL 712A.2d, MCL 712A.18(1)(o) lets the court enter any juvenile disposition or, if it determines that the interests of the public would be served, impose any sentence an adult could receive for that offense. The court may delay imposing sentence, and the juvenile receives credit for time served. Separate rules limit life without parole for anyone under 18 at the time of the offense; the prosecutor must file a motion and the court must hold a hearing considering the Miller factors (MCL 769.25).
What can a juvenile court do at disposition if a juvenile is found responsible?
The judge can warn and dismiss, place the juvenile on probation at home, order community service, order treatment, place the juvenile with a licensed agency, or commit the juvenile to a public or private institution, among other options. The court must first consider a risk and needs assessment and look to the least restrictive setting that protects public safety. The court cannot charge the juvenile or parents for costs, fees or court-appointed counsel.
MCL 712A.18(1) first requires the court to return the juvenile to a parent if doing so would not cause a substantial risk of harm to the juvenile or society. The court may also enter any of the listed dispositions that are appropriate for the welfare of the juvenile and society in view of the facts proven. The options include warning the juvenile and dismissing; probation or supervision at home or with a related adult, with conditions, including juvenile drug treatment court; foster care placement; placement with or commitment to a private institution or agency; commitment to a public institution or county facility; medical or other health care; orders to parents to stop conduct contributing to the problem; community service; parental participation in treatment; and juvenile boot camp in qualifying cases (MCL 712A.18(1)(a) to (n)).
A designated individual or agency must conduct a research-based, validated risk and needs assessment before disposition, and the court must consider the results in deciding whether to place the juvenile under supervision, on probation, or in out-of-home care. The assessment is to be used to inform the least restrictive setting possible, public safety, victim interests, rehabilitation, and improved outcomes such as educational advancement. A new assessment is required if 6 months have passed since the last one, the juvenile experiences a major life event, or there is a major change in the proceedings (MCL 712A.18(9) to (12)). Statements made in the assessment are not admissible in an adjudicatory hearing (MCL 712A.18(15)).
The court may not order a juvenile or the juvenile's parent, guardian or legal custodian to pay the costs of care, services, court-appointed attorney representation, or other costs or assessments related to the proceeding, and may not order fines if another disposition has been ordered (MCL 712A.18(1)(j), (3)). Restitution remains available, and a juvenile cannot be placed outside the home solely for nonpayment of restitution or inability to perform community service (MCL 712A.18(5) to (7)).
Is there a way to resolve a juvenile case without a formal court case, such as diversion or the consent calendar?
Yes in many cases. Before a petition is filed, police or a court intake worker may release the juvenile or divert the matter through a written agreement, usually for no more than 3 months. The court may handle a case on the consent calendar with a case plan, usually for no more than 6 months, if the court determines formal jurisdiction should not be acquired and the juvenile, parent or guardian, and prosecutor agree. A case on the formal calendar may be moved to the consent calendar at any time before disposition. Diversion is not available for specified juvenile violations.
Diversion is governed by the Juvenile Diversion Act, MCL 722.821 to 722.831. If no petition has been filed or authorized, a law enforcement official or court intake worker may release the minor to a parent and end the investigation, divert the matter by an agreement with the minor and parent to refer the minor to an appropriate organization, or file a petition (MCL 722.823(1)). A minor accused of a specified juvenile violation must not be diverted (MCL 722.823(3)), and diversion requires screening results from a research-based risk screening tool and a mental health screening tool (MCL 722.823(5)). The conference must be voluntary, an attorney may attend, and information the minor gives at the conference cannot be used against the minor before a petition is filed. A diversion agreement must be in writing and generally cannot run longer than 3 months, with a longer period allowed for a documented treatment program, and it cannot require reimbursement of diversion costs (MCL 722.825).
On the court side, the consent calendar under MCL 712A.2f is an informal track. A case may be placed on it only if the juvenile, the parent or guardian and the prosecutor all agree, the court has considered risk and mental health screening results, and the court determines the case should proceed that way. The court holds a consent calendar conference and issues a written case plan, which must include restitution but cannot remove the juvenile from the parent's custody or charge fees. The plan period generally cannot exceed 6 months. The court enters no disposition while the case is on the consent calendar, statements made during it cannot be used at a later formal trial on the same charge, and on successful completion the court closes the case and destroys the records, though the State Police keep a nonpublic record (MCL 712A.2f(2), (7) to (14)).
If the juvenile does not comply, the case can be returned to the formal calendar. MCL 712A.2f was amended by 2023 PA 289, 291 and 301 (effective October 1, 2024) and by 2024 PA 123 (effective October 3, 2024); MCL 722.823 was amended by 2023 PA 287 and MCL 722.825 by 2023 PA 288 (both effective October 1, 2024). The terms stated here are those of the current statutes.
Can a juvenile adjudication be set aside or expunged?
Yes, often. Many juvenile adjudications are set aside automatically 2 years after court supervision ends or when the person turns 18, whichever is later, but a list of serious offenses is excluded. Others can be set aside on application after 1 year, with limits of one felony-level adjudication and a small number of misdemeanor-level adjudications, and no felony convictions. Life-maximum offenses and designated-case convictions cannot be set aside under the juvenile statute.
Two statutes apply. MCL 712A.18t provides that an adjudication is set aside without an application 2 years after the termination of court supervision or when the person turns 18, whichever is later. That automatic process does not apply to specified juvenile violations listed in MCL 712A.2(a)(1), to adjudications barred from set-aside under MCL 712A.18e(2), or to adjudications for violations of MCL 750.81a, 750.82, 750.90, 750.136b, 750.321, 750.322, 750.397, 750.411h, 750.411i, 750.520d, 750.520g or 750.543k. The prosecutor may not contest an automatic set-aside. Once an adjudication is set aside, the person is considered not previously adjudicated, but the State Police keep a nonpublic record available only to courts, law enforcement, prosecutors, the attorney general and the governor for listed purposes (MCL 712A.18t(4), (6)).
MCL 712A.18e lets a person apply to set aside adjudications if he or she has no felony convictions and has been adjudicated of not more than one juvenile offense that would be a felony for an adult and not more than three juvenile offenses total, of which no more than one may be a felony-level offense. The application cannot be filed until 1 year after the termination of jurisdiction. Adjudications for offenses carrying a maximum of life, and convictions under MCL 712A.2d (designated cases), cannot be set aside under this section, though a designated-case conviction may be set aside as otherwise provided by law (MCL 712A.18e(2)). The court weighs the applicant's circumstances and behavior and whether setting aside is consistent with the public welfare, and the prosecutor and attorney general may contest (MCL 712A.18e(7), (9)).
A set-aside record becomes nonpublic, and the State Police maintain it as a nonpublic record available to the courts and law enforcement for the purposes the statute lists (MCL 712A.18e(13)).
Are juvenile court records public?
Not since 2021. Juvenile case records were open to the general public until December 31, 2020. Beginning January 1, 2021, they are open only to persons with a legitimate interest, such as the juvenile, parents, counsel, law enforcement and prosecutors. Diversion records are open only as the juvenile diversion act allows.
MCL 712A.28 governs access to records of cases brought before the family division. For records of cases in the period from June 1, 1988 through December 31, 2020, the statute says records of a case brought before the court were open to the general public, with exceptions for diversion records and closed hearings. Beginning January 1, 2021, records of a case brought before the court are not open to the general public and are open only to persons having a legitimate interest (MCL 712A.28(2), (3)).
"Persons having a legitimate interest" is defined to include, but is not limited to, the juvenile, the juvenile's parent, guardian or legal custodian, the guardian ad litem, counsel for the juvenile, the department or a licensed child caring institution in certain investigations, law enforcement personnel, a prosecutor, certain foster care review board members, the Indian child's tribe if applicable, and a court of this state (MCL 712A.28(5)(d)). Consent calendar case records are maintained in a nonpublic manner and are not disclosed to federal agencies or military recruiters (MCL 712A.2f(7)). Divulging information about a set-aside adjudication is a misdemeanor for a person who knows or should have known of the set-aside, with exceptions (MCL 712A.18e(16)).
The 2021 change interacts with sex offender registration, which treats certain juvenile dispositions as convictions only if the order of disposition is "open to the general public" under MCL 712A.28 (MCL 28.722(a)(iii)). Public court files are separate from State Police records, which exist for adjudications and are reported under MCL 712A.18(16).
Can a juvenile's statement to police be used in court, and does a parent have to be present?
A juvenile's statement can be used only if it was voluntary under the totality of the circumstances, with extra safeguards for juveniles. Michigan courts consider nine factors, including whether Miranda warnings were given and understood, compliance with the statute on arrested children, whether a parent was present, age, education, intelligence, prior police experience, length of detention, repeated questioning, and physical condition. A parent's presence is one factor, not a requirement.
Michigan courts evaluate the voluntariness of a juvenile's Miranda waiver under a totality-of-the-circumstances test that includes additional safeguards for juveniles. In People v Eliason, 300 Mich App 293; 833 NW2d 357 (2013), the Court of Appeals quoted the factors from People v Givans, 227 Mich App 113, 121; 575 NW2d 84 (1997): (1) whether the requirements of Miranda were met and the juvenile clearly understood and waived the rights, (2) the degree of police compliance with MCL 764.27 and the juvenile court rules, (3) the presence of an adult parent, custodian or guardian, (4) the juvenile's personal background, (5) the juvenile's age, education and intelligence, (6) prior experience with the police, (7) the length of detention before the statement, (8) the repeated and prolonged nature of the questioning, and (9) whether the juvenile was injured, intoxicated, ill, abused or threatened, or deprived of food, sleep or medical attention.
In Eliason, the court applied those factors to a 14-year-old and held the waivers voluntary. The father was present for one interview, and was absent from another at the juvenile's request. The decision treats the absence of a parent as one factor, not as an automatic bar. MCL 764.27 itself requires that an arrested child under 18 be taken immediately before the family division of circuit court, with a petition filed there, except as provided for specified juvenile violations under MCL 600.606.
The weight given to each factor is decided case by case, and a challenge is usually raised by a motion to suppress.
Can a juvenile be held in detention before trial?
Yes, but only in limited situations. The court may detain a juvenile pending hearing if the home conditions require immediate removal, the juvenile has a record of unexcused failures to appear, the juvenile left a placement against a court order, or the offense is so serious that release would endanger public safety. A detention screening tool must be used first. If trial has not begun within 63 days of being taken into custody, for reasons not attributable to the defense, the juvenile must be released.
MCL 712A.15(1) lets the court order a juvenile, pending hearing, detained in a facility the court designates, or released to a parent, guardian or custodian to be brought to court at the designated time. Detention pending hearing is limited to children whose home conditions make immediate removal necessary, who have a record of unexcused failures to appear, who failed to remain in a detention or nonsecure placement in violation of a court order, whose offenses are so serious that release would endanger public safety, who allegedly violated a personal protection order with a substantial likelihood of retaliation or continued violation, or who allegedly violated certain status-offense court orders (MCL 712A.15(2)).
Before a juvenile may be detained in a secure facility pending hearing, a court-designated individual or agency must use a detention screening tool, and the court must consult the results, share them with the parties before the detention hearing, and follow any Michigan Supreme Court rules. Statements made in the course of a detention screening cannot be used in an adjudicatory hearing (MCL 712A.15(3)). A parent, guardian or custodian has the right to give bond or other security for the juvenile's appearance (MCL 712A.17(3)).
MCR 3.942(A) sets time limits. If the juvenile is detained, the trial has not started within 63 days after the juvenile is taken into custody, and the delay is not attributable to the defense, the court must immediately order release pending trial without requiring bail, unless the juvenile is being held on another matter. Rules on where a juvenile may be held, including limits on holding certain juveniles in cells designed to incarcerate adults, are in MCL 712A.15(5) and (6).
What happens to a juvenile case if the young person turns 18 before it ends?
A case filed before the 18th birthday stays in the family division. The court's jurisdiction continues for 2 years beyond the maximum age of jurisdiction unless the juvenile is released sooner, and can continue until age 21 for a list of serious offenses. If the juvenile is sentenced to the Department of Corrections, that extension does not apply.
MCL 712A.11(4) says that if the juvenile reaches 18 after the petition is filed, the court's jurisdiction continues beyond the 18th birthday and the court may hear and dispose of the petition. MCL 712A.2a(1) adds that once the court has exercised jurisdiction over a juvenile under section 2(a), jurisdiction continues for 2 years beyond the maximum age of jurisdiction conferred under section 2, unless the juvenile is released sooner by court order. Because the juvenile code now covers a person under 18, that works out to the juvenile's 20th birthday as an outer limit in ordinary cases.
For offenses that would be violations of a list of sections (including first-degree arson, assault with intent to commit murder, murder, kidnapping, criminal sexual conduct in the first, second, third degrees and assault with intent to commit CSC, armed robbery, carjacking, certain controlled substance offenses, and others), jurisdiction may be continued under MCL 712A.18d until the juvenile is 21 (MCL 712A.2a(5)). Under MCL 712A.18d, for a juvenile committed under MCL 712A.18(1)(e) for one of those offenses, the court holds a review hearing before the juvenile's 19th birthday. The juvenile has the burden of showing by a preponderance of the evidence that the juvenile should be released; if the showing is not made, jurisdiction continues until age 21. The section does not apply to a juvenile who was convicted of a crime. MCL 712A.2a(7) states that the section does not apply if the juvenile is sentenced to the jurisdiction of the Department of Corrections. For purposes of the juvenile code, terms such as "child" and "juvenile" continue to apply to a person 18 or older over whom the court has continuing jurisdiction (MCL 712A.2a(8), (9)).
Related
More questions and pages
- Criminal court process: what happens after a charge, from arrest and bond to pleas and sentencing
- Arrest, arraignment and bond
- Expungement and set-asides
- Holmes Youthful Trainee Act (HYTA)
- All criminal charges questions in Michigan
- Holmes Youthful Trainee Act
- Grand Rapids expungement lawyer
- Grand Rapids felony lawyer
- Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer
- Michigan civil rights questions
- Michigan appeals questions
Questions about a Michigan matter?
Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.