Skip to content

Pleas and plea deals in Michigan

Michigan law: Pleas and plea deals. Short and full answers with the statutes, court rules and cases behind them, by attorney Mitchell S. Bisson.

These are general answers about Michigan law, not advice about your situation. Each answer links to the statute, court rule or case it rests on. Last reviewed October 27, 2026.

By Mitchell S. Bisson, Michigan attorney (P79807). Reviewed October 27, 2026.

Quick answers

The short version

What kinds of pleas can I enter in a Michigan criminal case?

Under MCR 6.301(A), you may plead not guilty, guilty, nolo contendere (no contest), guilty but mentally ill, or not guilty by reason of insanity. No contest needs the court's consent. A conditional plea needs the consent of both the court and the prosecutor, as does guilty but mentally ill or not guilty by reason of insanity after an insanity defense. If you refuse to plead or stand mute, the court enters not guilty.

What is a no contest plea in Michigan, and is it different from pleading guilty?

A no contest plea (nolo contendere) generally results in a conviction, just as a guilty plea does. It needs the court's consent under MCR 6.301(B). Under MCR 6.302(D)(2) the judge may not question you about your participation in the crime, but must state why a no contest plea is appropriate and hold a hearing, unless one already occurred, that supports a finding of guilt.

Can a no contest plea be used against me in a civil lawsuit in Michigan?

Generally not. Under MRE 410, in a civil or criminal case, evidence of a nolo contendere plea is not admissible against the defendant who made it. There is a narrow exception: to the extent evidence of a guilty plea would be admissible, a no contest plea to a criminal charge may be admitted in a civil proceeding to defend against a claim asserted by the person who entered the plea.

Michigan law, reviewed October 27, 2026. General information, not advice about your situation. Select a question for the full answer and the authority behind it.

What kinds of pleas can I enter in a Michigan criminal case?

Under MCR 6.301(A), you may plead not guilty, guilty, nolo contendere (no contest), guilty but mentally ill, or not guilty by reason of insanity. No contest needs the court's consent. A conditional plea needs the consent of both the court and the prosecutor, as does guilty but mentally ill or not guilty by reason of insanity after an insanity defense. If you refuse to plead or stand mute, the court enters not guilty.

A plea of not guilty puts every material allegation in the information in issue and lets you raise any defense that has not been waived. A conditional plea lets you plead guilty or no contest while preserving a specified pretrial ruling for appeal, and you may withdraw the plea if that ruling is overturned. A plea to an offense other than the one charged requires the prosecutor's consent under MCR 6.301(D). Before accepting a guilty or no contest plea the court has to be convinced under MCR 6.302 that the plea is understanding, voluntary, and accurate, and the judge puts you under oath and personally goes through your rights and the terms of any agreement. A plea is a decision to give up a trial. Before you decide, you should have the police report, the discovery, and a clear picture of the sentencing range.

Authority: MCR 6.301; MCR 6.302. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

What is a no contest plea in Michigan, and is it different from pleading guilty?

A no contest plea (nolo contendere) generally results in a conviction, just as a guilty plea does. It needs the court's consent under MCR 6.301(B). Under MCR 6.302(D)(2) the judge may not question you about your participation in the crime, but must state why a no contest plea is appropriate and hold a hearing, unless one already occurred, that supports a finding of guilt.

For a guilty plea the court questions you to establish support for a finding that you are guilty. For no contest, the factual support comes from a hearing instead, either an earlier hearing or a separate hearing. The judge still must advise you of your rights, the maximum sentence, and any mandatory minimum, and must find the plea understanding and voluntary. The difference shows up mostly in what the record contains and in later civil cases. MRE 410 makes a no contest plea generally inadmissible against you, with a narrow exception, discussed in a separate answer. Since the judge decides whether to accept it, ask your lawyer early whether the judge in your court takes no contest pleas and why one would be appropriate in your case.

Authority: MCR 6.301; MCR 6.302; MRE 410. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

Can a no contest plea be used against me in a civil lawsuit in Michigan?

Generally not. Under MRE 410, in a civil or criminal case, evidence of a nolo contendere plea is not admissible against the defendant who made it. There is a narrow exception: to the extent evidence of a guilty plea would be admissible, a no contest plea to a criminal charge may be admitted in a civil proceeding to defend against a claim asserted by the person who entered the plea.

That exception is limited to a civil claim that you, the person who pleaded, brought. A guilty plea is treated differently. MRE 410 protects a guilty plea only if it was later withdrawn or vacated, so a guilty plea that stands is not covered by that protection. The rule also protects statements made during a proceeding under MCR 6.302 or 6.310 on a no contest plea or on a guilty plea that was later withdrawn or vacated, and statements in plea discussions with the prosecutor that did not result in a guilty plea or that resulted in a guilty plea later withdrawn or vacated, with exceptions such as a perjury prosecution. The rule is about evidence, not about every consequence of a conviction. Other laws, such as licensing rules, insurance terms, or immigration law, can attach consequences to a conviction whatever the plea was called. If a civil case is possible, tell your lawyer before you plead so the plea can be structured with that in mind.

Authority: MRE 410. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

What is a Cobbs agreement in a Michigan plea?

A Cobbs evaluation is the judge's preliminary statement, on the record and at a party's request, of the sentence that appears appropriate on the information then available. If you plead in reliance on it and the judge later decides the sentence must exceed it, you have a right to withdraw your plea, which Cobbs called absolute, though you can lose it by committing misconduct before sentencing, such as absconding or violating bond (MCR 6.310(B)(3)). It comes from People v Cobbs, 443 Mich 276.

The judge may not initiate the evaluation, and the evaluation does not bind the judge's sentencing discretion, because new facts can emerge in the presentence report, from the prosecutor, from a victim, or elsewhere. What the case provides is the right to withdraw if the sentence will exceed the evaluation. MCR 6.302(C)(2) now requires that when a court states it will sentence to a specified term or range, the term must be numerically quantifiable, and the court must say whether a guidelines range discussed at the plea is part of the plea. If the court says it is part of the plea, you have a right to withdraw under MCR 6.310(B) if the final range differs. Under MCR 6.310(B)(2)(b), if the court cannot sentence as stated, it gives you the chance to affirm or withdraw the plea, but does not state the sentence it intends to impose. That right can be lost if you commit misconduct after the plea and before sentencing, such as absconding, failing to appear for sentencing, or violating bond, unless the court allows withdrawal for good cause (MCR 6.310(B)(3)). Get the terms read onto the record before you enter the plea.

Authority: People v Cobbs, 443 Mich 276 (1993); MCR 6.302; MCR 6.310. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

What is a Killebrew agreement, and what if the judge will not follow it?

A Killebrew agreement is a plea deal between you and the prosecutor that includes a sentence recommendation or agreement, such as a specific term or range. If the judge rejects the bargain or will not follow a sentence agreement, you must be allowed to withdraw your plea. Under MCR 6.302(C)(4), a judge's decision not to follow a mere sentence recommendation does not by itself allow withdrawal, even though Killebrew originally allowed it. The right to withdraw can be lost if you commit misconduct before sentencing (MCR 6.310(B)(3)).

The rule comes from People v Killebrew, 416 Mich 189, which limits the judge's role in plea negotiations to considering the bargain between you and the prosecutor. MCR 6.302(C) now governs the procedure. If the agreement is for a sentence to a specified term or within a specified range, the court may reject the agreement, accept it after considering the presentence report, accept it without the report, or take it under advisement. If it takes the agreement under advisement or accepts without the report, it must explain that it is not bound, and that if it chooses not to follow an agreement for a specified term or range, you will be allowed to withdraw. Under MCR 6.310(B)(2)(a), the court must then state the sentence it intends to impose and give you the chance to affirm or withdraw. You can lose that right if you commit misconduct after the plea and before sentencing, such as absconding or violating bond, unless the court allows withdrawal for good cause (MCR 6.310(B)(3)). Read the written agreement and confirm each term is stated on the record.

Authority: People v Killebrew, 416 Mich 189 (1982); MCR 6.302; MCR 6.310. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

If a judge mentions a guidelines range at my plea, can I withdraw if the range turns out higher?

Generally only if the judge says the range is part of the plea. Under MCR 6.302(C)(2), if the plea involves a statement by the court that it will sentence to a specified term or range, the court must say any guidelines range discussed is a preliminary estimate, advise whether it is part of the plea so you can withdraw under MCR 6.310(B) if the final range differs, and give a numerically quantifiable term or range.

That makes the wording at the plea hearing important. A quantifiable range includes language such as the lower or upper half, or the lower or upper quarter, of the range. If the judge says the guidelines range is only a preliminary estimate and not part of the plea, a different final range, standing alone, does not give you the withdrawal right that the rule describes when the range is part of the plea. The final guidelines range is determined at sentencing after the presentence report and any scoring challenges. Before pleading, ask your lawyer to review the scoring of the offense variables and prior record variables, since errors or disputes there can change the range. The court also asks whether anyone has promised you anything beyond the plea agreement, so disclose every promise you were told about.

Authority: MCR 6.302; MCR 6.310. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

What rights do I give up if I plead guilty or no contest in Michigan?

Under MCR 6.302(B)(3), you give up a trial of any kind, including the right to a jury, to be presumed innocent, to have the prosecutor prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, to have witnesses appear and be questioned, to have the court order your witnesses to appear, to remain silent and not have it used against you, and to testify if you choose.

You also give up any claim that the plea resulted from promises or threats not disclosed to the court, or that it was not your own choice (MCR 6.302(B)(4)). And you may be giving up the right to appeal issues that would otherwise be appealable after a trial, and any appeal from the conviction and sentence on a plea is by application for leave to appeal, not by right (MCR 6.302(B)(5)). The judge must also tell you the name of the offense, the maximum possible prison sentence, and any mandatory minimum. The advice about the rights you give up and the appeal consequences can be given in a writing on a form approved by the State Court Administrative Office, but the judge must still obtain from you orally on the record a statement that the rights were read and understood and a waiver of them (MCR 6.302(B)). A plea is hard to undo, so ask your lawyer about every item before you sign.

Authority: MCR 6.302. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

Can I change my mind and withdraw my plea in Michigan?

It depends on timing. You may withdraw any plea until the court accepts it on the record. After acceptance but before sentence, a plea may be withdrawn only in the interest of justice and not if it would substantially prejudice the prosecutor, though some situations give you a right to withdraw. After sentence, a motion to withdraw must be filed within the time for an application for leave to appeal, and later relief is under subchapter 6.500.

The situations that give you a right before sentence under MCR 6.310(B)(2) include: the court says it cannot follow a sentencing agreement, the court cannot sentence as it stated, or a consecutive sentence will be imposed and you were not advised that the law permits or requires it. But the first two of those rights, which involve a sentencing agreement or a stated sentence the court cannot follow, can be lost if you commit misconduct after the plea, such as absconding, failing to appear for sentencing, or violating bond or the plea agreement terms, unless the court allows withdrawal for good cause. If, on a motion after sentence, the court finds an error in the plea proceeding that would entitle you to withdraw, it must correct the advice or inquiry and let you choose to keep or withdraw the plea. To raise a plea defect on appeal, you must first move to withdraw in the trial court under MCR 6.310(D). The prosecutor can also move to vacate the plea if you do not comply with its terms.

Authority: MCR 6.310. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

Can I appeal if I plead guilty in Michigan?

Usually only by application for leave to appeal, not by right, and you may be giving up issues you could raise after a trial. MCR 6.302(B)(5) requires the judge to tell you that. To raise a claim that the plea was not understanding, voluntary, or accurate, or that the court did not follow the plea rules, you generally must first move to withdraw the plea in the trial court.

MCR 6.310(D) says a defendant convicted on a plea may not raise on appeal a claim of noncompliance with the plea rules, or any other claim that the plea was not understanding, voluntary, or accurate, unless the defendant moved to withdraw the plea in the trial court on that basis. Under MCR 6.310(C), the motion is filed within the time for an application for leave to appeal, after which relief is limited to the procedure in subchapter 6.500. A conditional plea under MCR 6.301(C)(2) is one way to preserve a specified pretrial ruling for appeal, and that appeal is also by leave only. Sentencing issues, such as a guidelines scoring error, have their own preservation rules, and appeal deadlines are short and strict. If you are considering an appeal, speak to an appellate lawyer promptly.

Authority: MCR 6.302; MCR 6.310; MCR 6.301. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

What is a conditional plea in Michigan?

A conditional plea is a guilty, no contest, guilty but mentally ill, or not guilty by reason of insanity plea that preserves a specified pretrial ruling for appeal. Under MCR 6.301(C)(2), it needs the consent of both the court and the prosecutor, and it entitles you to withdraw the plea if the specified ruling is overturned on appeal. The appeal is by application for leave only.

The ruling or rulings you reserve the right to appeal must be specified orally on the record or in a writing made part of the record. Typical candidates are a ruling denying a motion to suppress evidence or a ruling on a legal question the case turns on, but the prosecutor and judge must agree, so there is no right to a conditional plea. A conditional plea is useful when the main dispute in the case is a pretrial legal issue and a trial would add little. If the appeal is lost, the plea and conviction stand. If it is won, you can withdraw the plea and the case returns to the trial court. Because the preserved ruling must be specified precisely, the language matters, and it should be drafted carefully with the prosecutor.

Authority: MCR 6.301. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

Can I plead guilty to a lesser charge in Michigan?

Only with the prosecutor's consent. MCR 6.301(D) says the court may not accept a plea to an offense other than the one charged without the consent of the prosecutor. Whether a lesser charge is offered depends on the prosecutor, the facts, your record, and the strength of the evidence.

A reduction can happen at several stages: before the preliminary examination, at the probable cause conference, after discovery and motions, or on the eve of trial. If the court finds no probable cause for the charged felony at the preliminary examination, it may reduce the charge to a non-felony under MCR 6.110(F), which is a different route. The judge can accept or reject an agreement, and a plea that involves a sentence agreement carries the withdrawal rights described in MCR 6.310(B)(2). When comparing an offer, the points to check are the new maximum sentence, mandatory minimums, the guidelines range, collateral effects such as licensing and immigration, and whether any habitual offender notice will be dropped. Ask your lawyer to put the whole offer in writing.

Authority: MCR 6.301; MCR 6.110; MCR 6.310. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

Does the judge have to accept my plea agreement in Michigan?

No. Under MCR 6.302(C)(4), if the agreement is for a sentence to a specified term or range, or a prosecutorial recommendation, the court may reject it, accept it after considering the presentence report, accept it without the report, or take it under advisement. If it later chooses not to follow an agreement for a specified term or range, you must be allowed to withdraw from the plea agreement, unless you committed misconduct before sentencing (MCR 6.310(B)(3)).

There is an important difference between an agreement for a specified sentence and a prosecutor's recommendation. The rule says a judge's decision not to follow a sentence recommendation does not by itself entitle you to withdraw your plea. That is why the exact wording of the deal matters. If the court accepts the agreement without the presentence report or takes it under advisement, it must explain that it is not bound. When the court says it cannot follow the agreement, MCR 6.310(B)(2)(a) says it states the sentence it intends to impose and gives you the chance to affirm or withdraw the plea. If you commit misconduct after the plea and before sentencing, such as absconding or violating bond, you can lose that right unless the court allows withdrawal for good cause (MCR 6.310(B)(3)). Ask whether the prosecutor's promise is a recommendation or a binding term, and put it on the record.

Authority: MCR 6.302; MCR 6.310. Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

Can a guilty plea in Michigan get a noncitizen deported?

It can, and your defense lawyer has a duty to tell you about the risk. In Padilla v Kentucky, the United States Supreme Court held that counsel must inform a client whether a plea carries a risk of deportation. The immigration effect of a given plea has to be checked before you plead.

Immigration consequences depend on federal law, your status, the offense, the sentence, and sometimes the exact wording of the plea, so a plea that looks minor in state court can have a very different effect in immigration court. Federal immigration law defines a conviction to include a guilty or no contest plea followed by any punishment, penalty, or restraint, even if the state withholds a formal judgment of guilt (8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A)), so do not assume a no contest plea or a deferral avoids the problem. Under Padilla, the Sixth Amendment requires advice about deportation risk, and the Michigan plea rules, MCR 6.302, require the court to tell you the name of the offense and the maximum possible sentence, including any mandatory minimum, and to make sure the plea is understanding, voluntary, and accurate. If you are not a citizen, tell your lawyer before any plea discussions begin so the offer can be checked for immigration effects before you respond to it. Do not rely on the judge or the prosecutor to explain immigration effects.

Authority: Padilla v Kentucky, 559 US 356 (2010); MCR 6.302; 8 USC 1101(a)(48)(A). Reviewed Oct. 27, 2026.

Questions about a Michigan matter?

Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.

Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com

This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.

Have a question about your case?

The sooner I am involved, the more I can do. I keep what you tell me private. Please share only the basics until we have spoken.