Yes, you can refuse a chemical test after an OWI arrest in Michigan, but there is a cost: a one-year license suspension (two years for a second refusal within seven years) and 6 points, unless you request a hearing within 14 days and win. The roadside breath test is a different test with different rules.
Two different tests
Michigan separates the preliminary breath test, usually a handheld device at the roadside, from the chemical tests of blood, breath or urine given after an arrest. The consequences of refusing are not the same.
The roadside preliminary breath test
If an officer has reasonable cause to believe you were driving and that alcohol or another intoxicating substance may have affected your ability to drive, the officer may require a preliminary breath analysis. For a driver under 21, reasonable cause to believe you had any bodily alcohol content is enough. MCL 257.625a(2). The officer may base an arrest in whole or part on the result. MCL 257.625a(2)(a). The prosecution’s use of the result at trial is limited: it can be used to decide whether the arrest was valid and, in narrow situations, to rebut testimony about your breath alcohol level. MCL 257.625a(2)(b).
Refusing the roadside test is a civil infraction, not a criminal charge. MCL 257.625a(2)(d). One exception: a commercial motor vehicle driver who refuses the roadside test commits a misdemeanor punishable by up to 93 days, a fine of up to $100, or both. MCL 257.625a(5). Taking the roadside test does not replace the later one. You remain subject to implied consent. MCL 257.625a(2)(c).
The chemical test and implied consent
Once you are arrested for an offense listed in MCL 257.625c(1), which includes OWI, OWVI and the under-21 offense, you are considered to have consented to chemical testing of your blood, breath or urine. The officer must then advise you of the following. MCL 257.625a(6)(b).
- You may demand that a person of your own choosing administer one of the chemical tests if you take a test at the officer’s request.
- The results are admissible and will be considered with the other evidence.
- You are responsible for obtaining a chemical analysis of a sample taken at your own request.
- If you refuse, a test must not be given without a court order, but the officer may seek one.
- Refusing results in a license suspension and 6 points on your driver record.
Whether you were advised of these rights is one of the four issues at the hearing described below. MCL 257.625f(4)(d).
What happens if you refuse
A refusal does not necessarily end the testing. A test may not be given without a court order, but the officer can ask a court for one. MCL 257.625d(1). The Fourth Amendment limits what police can do without a warrant. The U.S. Supreme Court has held that the natural dissipation of alcohol in the blood does not create an emergency justifying a warrantless blood test in every case. Missouri v McNeely, 569 US 141 (2013).
The officer must immediately send the Secretary of State a written report stating that there were reasonable grounds, that you refused, and that you were advised of the consequences. MCL 257.625d(2). The officer must also give you written notice that you have 14 days from the date of the notice to request a hearing. The notice must say that failing to request one will result in suspension, and that you do not have to hire a lawyer for the hearing but may. MCL 257.625e. If you do not request a hearing in time, the Secretary of State suspends your license for one year, or two years for a second or subsequent refusal within seven years. MCL 257.625f(1)(a). Commercial drivers face different sanctions. MCL 257.625f(1)(b), (c). Six points are recorded. MCL 257.320a(8).
The hearing
The statute calls for the hearing to be scheduled within 45 days after the arrest, though the hearing officer may not impose a sanction for missing that limit. MCL 257.625f(2). The hearing is narrow. It covers only whether the officer had reasonable grounds to believe you committed a listed crime, whether you were arrested, whether your refusal was reasonable, and whether you were advised of your rights. MCL 257.625f(4). If you lose, the suspension is imposed, and you may petition the circuit court in the county of arrest for review. MCL 257.625f(7)(a). That petition is due within 63 days after the determination, or within 182 days for good cause. MCL 257.323(1).
What a refusal means in the criminal case
The criminal charge goes forward either way. A refusal may be brought up at trial only to show that a test was offered, not as evidence of guilt, and the jury must be instructed that way. MCL 257.625a(9). The prosecution can still use other admissible evidence of impairment, such as how you drove and what officers saw. MCL 257.625a(7). Penalties and license consequences for a first offense are in my post on a first OWI arrest in Michigan.
What I look at first
The 14-day deadline runs on its own, so I look at it first. Then I look at whether the officer had reasonable grounds, whether you were given the required advisements, and whether the refusal was reasonable. I cannot tell you how a hearing or a case will turn out. How I handle these cases is on my Grand Rapids OWI lawyer page. The court case is handled through my criminal defense representation in Kent County, and the Michigan legal FAQs have short answers on OWI refusals.
Questions about refusing a breath test in Michigan
Is refusing a breath test a crime in Michigan?
For most drivers, not by itself. A refused roadside test is a civil infraction, and a refused chemical test after arrest brings license sanctions under the implied consent statutes. A commercial driver who refuses the roadside test commits a misdemeanor. MCL 257.625a(2)(d), (5); MCL 257.625f.
Can the officer still get a sample after I refuse?
Possibly. A test cannot be given without a court order, but the officer may seek one. MCL 257.625d(1).
What if I miss the 14-day deadline?
The Secretary of State then imposes the suspension: one year, or two years for a second or subsequent refusal within seven years. MCL 257.625f(1)(a).
Will the jury hear that I refused?
Only to show that a test was offered. It cannot be used as evidence of guilt, and the jury must be told so. MCL 257.625a(9).
If you were arrested for OWI in Kent County or anywhere in West Michigan, call my Grand Rapids office at (616) 213-3327 or use the contact page. This post is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not make me your lawyer.