
Partnership dissolution and joint venture disputes in Michigan
I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids business litigation lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. Business partners who built something together can end up in a fight over who controls it, who owes what, and who keeps the assets. This page covers partnership dissolution and joint venture questions in Michigan, including ending a partnership, lockouts and access to the books, court-ordered dissolution, winding up, liability after a partner leaves, and filing deadlines. I act for either side, partner or former partner. The short answers below come from my Michigan legal library.
Partnership fights in Kent County usually start with one of three events. A partner announces that he or she is done. A partner is shut out of the business or the books. Or one side keeps the business, the clients or the property and the other side asks what a share is worth. Michigan’s Uniform Partnership Act, MCL 449.1 and the sections after it, dates from 1917 and still governs general partnerships. Most of its rules apply only if the partners did not agree otherwise, which is why the agreement, and what the partners actually did, come first.
The first question is whether a partnership exists at all. The Act defines a partnership as an association of two or more persons to carry on as co-owners a business for profit. MCL 449.6. Nothing in that definition requires a signed agreement. In Byker v. Mannes, 465 Mich. 637 (2002), the Michigan Supreme Court looked at whether the parties intended to carry on a business for profit as co-owners, not at whether they ever used the word “partners.” People who ran a business together on a handshake can be partners, and people who call each other partners can fail the test.
Dissolution is the next step, and it is often misunderstood. Under the Act, dissolution changes the relationship among the partners, but the partnership continues until its affairs are wound up. MCL 449.30. Any partner can dissolve a partnership that has no definite term by express will. A partner who dissolves in breach of the agreement can be liable to the others for damages.
Deadlines are less tidy than the Act makes them look. The right to an account accrues at the date of dissolution unless the partners agreed otherwise. MCL 449.43. Claims for breach of contract, injury to property and other wrongs each have their own limitation periods, and a claim accrues when the wrong was done, not when it was discovered. I treat the shortest period that could apply as the deadline. The table below sorts the main issues.
Michigan partnership and joint venture claims, deadlines and key rules
| Claim or issue | What must be shown | Time limit or key rule | Authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether a partnership exists | An association of two or more persons carrying on as co-owners a business for profit. A share of the profits is prima facie evidence of partnership, but not if it was paid as a debt, wages, rent, an annuity, interest on a loan, or the price of a business or its good will | No written agreement is required. Co-owning property, or sharing gross returns, does not of itself make a partnership | MCL 449.6; MCL 449.7; Byker v. Mannes, 465 Mich. 637 (2002) |
| Joint venture versus partnership | The parties’ agreement and how they actually operated. The label can change who owns property and who must consent to a sale | In Kay Investment, joint venturers held real property as tenants in common. Partners hold partnership property as tenants in partnership | Kay Investment Co., LLC v. Brody Realty No. 1, LLC, 273 Mich. App. 432 (2007); MCL 449.25 |
| Dissolution by a partner’s choice | Dissolution without breaching the agreement: the term or undertaking ended, any partner chose to leave a partnership with no definite term, all partners agreed, or a partner was expelled in good faith under the agreement. Dissolution in breach of the agreement is possible but can bring damages | No partnership is indissoluble. Wrongful dissolution exposes the partner who caused it to damages | MCL 449.31; MCL 449.38(2); Urbain v. Beierling, 301 Mich. App. 114, 122-124 (2013) |
| Dissolution by court decree | On application by or for a partner, grounds such as a partner incapable of performing his or her part, conduct that prejudices the business, willful or persistent breach of the agreement, a business that can be carried on only at a loss, or other circumstances that make dissolution equitable | The court shall decree dissolution when a listed ground is shown. A decree may be unnecessary where a partner can dissolve at will | MCL 449.32(1) |
| Information and formal account | A partner may demand true and full information on all things affecting the partnership. A formal account is available if a partner is wrongfully excluded, if the agreement provides for it, if a partner must account for a benefit or profit under section 21, or when it is just and reasonable | The right to an account accrues at the date of dissolution unless the agreement says otherwise | MCL 449.20; MCL 449.21; MCL 449.22; MCL 449.43 |
| Winding up and payment order | Partners who did not wrongfully dissolve the partnership may wind up its affairs, and any partner may ask the court to supervise on cause shown. Creditors are paid first, then partners owed other than capital and profits, then capital, then profits | Partners contribute to cover a shortfall in liabilities, in the proportions in which they share profits if a partner cannot pay | MCL 449.37; MCL 449.40; Urbain, 301 Mich. App. 114, 129-130 (2013) |
| Liability after a partner leaves | Dissolution does not discharge existing liability. Discharge comes by agreement among the partner, the creditor and the person continuing the business, which may be inferred from the creditor’s dealings after learning of the dissolution. A partner can still bind the partnership to some outsiders who lack notice | Creditors of the dissolved partnership become creditors of a person or partnership that continues the business in the situations the statute lists | MCL 449.35; MCL 449.36; MCL 449.41; MCL 449.42 |
| Limitation periods | It depends on the claim. Breach of contract: 6 years. Injury to person or property: 3 years. Other personal actions with no stated period: 6 years | A claim accrues when the wrong was done, regardless of when damage results | MCL 600.5807(9); MCL 600.5805(2); MCL 600.5813; MCL 600.5827 |
What has to be shown in a partnership dissolution case
That a partnership exists, and what its terms are. If there is a written partnership agreement, it controls most questions. If there is none, the Act supplies default rules. Partners share profits equally, have equal rights in management, and are not entitled to a salary for working in the business. A majority decides ordinary matters, no one can become a partner without everyone’s consent, and an act that contradicts the agreement needs everyone’s consent. MCL 449.18. In Urbain v. Beierling, 301 Mich. App. 114 (2013), the Court of Appeals dealt with a partnership that lasted about four months with no written agreement. Partners who skipped the paperwork can still have a case, but the proof comes from conduct, payments, tax returns, bank records and messages.
That the money or property is partnership property. A partner is a co-owner of specific partnership property as a tenant in partnership, and a partner’s right in that property is not assignable except along with the rights of all the partners. MCL 449.25.
How the partnership ended. Dissolution has statutory causes. Without breaching the agreement, a partnership ends when its definite term or undertaking ends, when any partner chooses to leave a partnership with no definite term, when all partners agree, or when a partner is expelled in good faith as the agreement allows. Dissolution also follows death or bankruptcy of a partner, events that make the business unlawful, and a court decree. A partner may also dissolve by express will in breach of the agreement. MCL 449.31. The reason decides who has the right to wind up and who may owe damages.
Grounds for a court decree. Where a partner will not leave and the others cannot continue, a partner can ask the court for a decree. The grounds are in MCL 449.32(1): a partner incapable of performing his or her part, conduct that tends to prejudice the business, willful or persistent breach of the agreement or conduct that makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on the business with that partner, a business that can only be carried on at a loss, or other circumstances that make dissolution equitable. I match each ground to documents and witnesses.
Access to information and a formal account. A partner can demand true and full information about anything affecting the partnership. MCL 449.20. A partner who is wrongfully excluded from the business or its property has a right to a formal account, as does a partner whose agreement provides for one, or whenever it is just and reasonable. MCL 449.22. Every partner must also account to the partnership for any benefit, and holds as trustee any profit made without the other partners’ consent from a transaction connected with the partnership or from using its property. MCL 449.21. In Urbain, the Court of Appeals said a formal accounting should be provided within a reasonable time after dissolution. 301 Mich. App. 114, 129 (2013).
Defenses and answers I look at in a partnership dispute
There was no partnership. The Act says the sharing of gross returns, and the co-ownership of property, do not of themselves establish a partnership. A person who received a share of profits is presumed to be a partner, but not if the payment was a debt, wages, rent, an annuity to a widow or representative of a deceased partner, interest on a loan, or the price of a business or its good will. MCL 449.7. Employees, lenders, landlords and buyers on installment terms are the usual examples. The question is whether the parties intended to carry on a business for profit as co-owners. Byker, 465 Mich. 637 (2002).
The agreement says otherwise. Most of the Act’s rules give way to the partners’ agreement. That includes the rules on sharing profits and losses and the rules for distribution after dissolution. An agreement can set a term, set buyout terms, or restrict who can wind up. A partner who left in breach of the agreement faces the damages rule in MCL 449.38(2).
The departure was wrongful, so the exit price is reduced. When a partner dissolves in breach of the agreement, the other partners, if they all want to continue the business in the same name, can do so during the agreed term if they pay the departing partner the value of his or her interest, less damages caused by the dissolution, or secure payment by a bond the court approves. In valuing the departing partner’s interest, the statute says the value of good will is not considered. MCL 449.38(2). A partner thinking about leaving should know this before leaving, not after.
It was a joint venture, not a partnership. The label can change the outcome. In Kay Investment Co., LLC v. Brody Realty No. 1, LLC, 273 Mich. App. 432 (2007), the Court of Appeals held that the parties had formed a joint venture under a written agreement with that title, and that joint venturers held real property as tenants in common, so all owners had to consent to a sale or the property could be partitioned. The Act treats partners as tenants in partnership. MCL 449.25. I read the agreement and look at how the parties actually ran the business before choosing a theory.
The claim is late. The right to an account accrues at dissolution. MCL 449.43. A contract claim has 6 years under MCL 600.5807(9), an injury-to-property claim has 3 years under MCL 600.5805(2), and the residual period for other personal actions is 6 years under MCL 600.5813. A claim accrues when the wrong was done, regardless of when damage results. MCL 600.5827. The sections of the Act I reviewed do not state how long an accounting claim lasts, so I treat the shortest period that could apply as the deadline until the documents show a longer one. A limitations defense must be stated in the responsive pleading, and can support summary disposition. MCR 2.111(F)(3); MCR 2.116(C)(7).
An accounting that shows nothing is owed. A formal accounting does not create money that is not there. In Urbain, the Court of Appeals found no damage from a failure to provide an accounting where the partnership had no profits or assets. 301 Mich. App. 114, 129 (2013). Before I recommend a suit for an accounting, I want to know what the books will likely show.
Remedies and consequences in a partnership dissolution
Dissolution and an order to wind up. The court can decree dissolution when a ground under MCL 449.32(1) is shown, and any partner can ask the court, on cause shown, to oversee the winding up. MCL 449.37. Unless the partners agreed otherwise, the partners who did not wrongfully dissolve the partnership have the right to wind it up.
Payout after a rightful dissolution. When dissolution does not breach the agreement, each partner, unless otherwise agreed, may have the partnership property applied to its liabilities and the surplus applied to pay in cash the net amount owing to the partners. MCL 449.38(1). The order of payment is creditors who are not partners, then partners owed other than capital and profits, then capital, then profits. If assets fall short, partners contribute to the shortfall. MCL 449.40.
A retiring partner when the business continues. When a partner retires and the business continues under the conditions the Act lists, without a settlement of accounts, the retiring partner may have the value of his or her interest at dissolution determined and is paid as an ordinary creditor, with interest or, at the partner’s option, the profits attributable to the use of the partner’s right in the property. MCL 449.42.
Personal liability. General partners are jointly and severally liable for the partnership’s wrongful acts and misapplied money, and jointly liable for its other debts. MCL 449.15. A registered limited liability partnership is different: a partner is generally not personally liable for the partnership’s debts solely because of being a partner, but remains liable for his or her own wrongful acts. MCL 449.46.
Partnership or joint venture, and why the label matters
Many business owners say “joint venture” to describe a single project: a development, a purchase, a one-time contract. Which label applies depends on the agreement and on how the owners actually ran the business. In Kay Investment, the written agreement was titled a joint venture agreement, and the Court of Appeals treated the venture as distinct from a partnership for purposes of how the real property was owned. 273 Mich. App. 432 (2007).
Partnership property is held by the partners as tenants in partnership, and a partner has no right to possess it for any purpose other than the partnership’s without the others’ consent. MCL 449.25. Joint venturers who own property as tenants in common can find that a sale needs every owner’s consent, and that a court can partition the property if they cannot agree. I sort out the label early, because it affects which rules apply and what a court can order.
A partner who leaves is not always free of the old business. Dissolution does not discharge existing liability. MCL 449.36. After dissolution a partner can still bind the partnership to some outside parties who had no notice of the dissolution, and a partner can bind the partnership by acts that are appropriate for winding up. MCL 449.35. Notice to creditors and customers, and a written release, are steps I raise with clients on either side.
How I handle a partnership dissolution or joint venture case
- Read the paper and fix the deadlines. I start with any partnership or joint venture agreement, the tax returns, the bank records, the lease and loan documents, and the messages that show how the business actually ran. I decide whether there is a partnership, a joint venture or something else, find the date of dissolution if there was one, and calendar the shortest deadline that could apply.
- Decide how the relationship ended. I work out whether dissolution was rightful or wrongful, whether a court decree is needed, and who has the right to wind up. That choice affects damages, the exit price and control of the assets.
- Get the books. If you are shut out, I send a written demand for information and, if needed, ask the court for a formal accounting. If you hold the books and have been asked for them, I review what has to be produced before anything goes out.
- Send a demand, or answer one. A demand letter sets out the facts, the statutory and contract basis, and the relief sought. If you are on the receiving end, I read the demand against the documents before anyone responds.
- File or respond in the right court. I choose the court based on the amount in controversy and the relief sought, plead the claims the facts support, and raise the defenses that must be raised in the first responsive pleading, including limitations and any agreement to arbitrate.
- Take the discovery and build the numbers. That means financial statements, general ledgers, bank statements, tax returns, draws and capital accounts, and then the figures a court or a settlement will turn on: contributions, draws, liabilities, the value of the interest, and any damages from the way the partnership ended.
Ways a partnership dispute may end without a trial
A negotiated buyout. One partner buys the other out at an agreed price, with a payment schedule, a release, and terms on use of the business name, customer relationships and any restrictive covenants.
An agreed winding up. The partners agree on who winds up the business, how assets are sold or divided, how creditors are paid, and how the accounts are settled. That can follow the statutory order of payment or a different one the partners agree to.
Mediation and other ADR. Civil cases are subject to alternative dispute resolution unless a rule provides otherwise, and mediation is a process in which the mediator has no power to decide the case. MCR 2.410(A)(1); MCR 2.411(A)(2). Case evaluation is aimed at cases where the relief sought is primarily money damages or division of property, and a court may exempt claims for equitable relief for good cause. MCR 2.403(A)(1), (A)(4).
Whether to settle is your decision. I give you my view of the strengths, the weaknesses and the cost of continuing, and I do not promise outcomes.
What I need from you
Bring any partnership or joint venture agreement and every amendment, the business’s tax returns, bank statements, financial statements, and records of what each partner put in and took out. Bring the lease and loan documents, any business name filing, the emails and texts about the dispute, and a timeline with dates, including the date the partnership ended or the date you were shut out. If you are the one being sued, bring the summons and complaint and note the date and manner of service, because the answer deadline runs from service. Do not delete messages or alter the books, do not move partnership money or property, and do not sign a buyout, release or payment plan until someone has read it against the agreement. Do not discuss fault with your partner or their lawyer until you have spoken with me.
Where your Kent County partnership or joint venture case will be heard
I represent clients in Grand Rapids, Kentwood, Grandville, Wyoming and across Kent County. Under MCL 600.8301(1), the district court has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions when the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000. Kent County district courts include the 61st District Court in Grand Rapids, the 59th in Walker and Grandville, the 62A in Wyoming, the 62B in Kentwood and the 63rd for Rockford, Lowell, Cedar Springs, East Grand Rapids and the surrounding townships. Larger claims are filed in the Kent County Circuit Court, the 17th Judicial Circuit. A dispute between a business and its owners, or about the dissolution or governance of a business enterprise, can qualify as a business or commercial dispute under MCL 600.8031, which defines the cases eligible for a business court docket and counts a partnership or joint venture as a business enterprise.
Why people hire me for a Michigan partnership or joint venture matter
You work directly with me, the lawyer handling your case. I give you the strengths and weaknesses of the case straight, including what it could cost you and what it could recover. I build the case the facts support, and then we decide together how to proceed.
Fees depend on the type of case, its complexity and whether it is likely to go to trial. I explain my fee arrangement at the consultation, before you decide whether to hire me.
Questions I hear from people ending a partnership or joint venture in Michigan
Can I end our Michigan partnership whenever I want, even if we agreed to stay in business for a set time?
If there is no definite term or particular undertaking, any partner can dissolve the partnership by express will (MCL 449.31(1)(b)). If there is a term, a partner can still cause dissolution by express will, but doing so against the agreement can make that partner liable to the others for damages under MCL 449.38(2). The Court of Appeals has said there can be no indissoluble partnership.
My partner has locked me out of the business and won’t show me the books. What are my rights?
A partner is entitled to true and full information about partnership affairs on demand (MCL 449.20), and to a formal account if wrongfully excluded from the business or its property, if an agreement provides for it, or whenever circumstances make it just and reasonable (MCL 449.22). In Urbain v Beierling the Court of Appeals said a formal accounting should be provided within a reasonable time after dissolution without the need for a lawsuit.
When can a Michigan court dissolve a general partnership if my partner and I cannot get along?
On application by or for a partner, MCL 449.32(1) says the court shall decree dissolution when a partner is incapable of performing his part, engages in conduct that tends to prejudice the business, willfully or persistently breaches the agreement or makes it not reasonably practicable to carry on with him, when the business can only be carried on at a loss, or when other circumstances render dissolution equitable. Where a partner can dissolve at will, a decree may be unnecessary.
After a Michigan partnership dissolves, who winds it up, and who gets paid first?
Dissolution does not end the partnership; it continues until winding up is complete (MCL 449.30). Unless otherwise agreed, partners who did not wrongfully dissolve it have the right to wind up, and any partner can ask the court to supervise for cause (MCL 449.37). Under MCL 449.40, creditors other than partners are paid first, then partners owed other than capital and profits, then capital, then profits, and partners must contribute to cover any shortfall in liabilities.
If I leave a Michigan partnership, am I still responsible for its debts, and can my old partners still bind me?
Leaving does not erase debts that already exist. MCL 449.36(1) says dissolution does not discharge a partner’s existing liability, though you can be discharged by agreement among you, the creditor, and the person or partnership continuing the business, which may be inferred from the creditor’s course of dealing after learning of the dissolution. After dissolution a partner can still bind the partnership to some outsiders who had no notice (MCL 449.35).
We called our deal a joint venture, not a partnership. Does that change who can sell the property or how we split things up?
It can. In Kay Investment v Brody Realty, the Court of Appeals treated a joint venture, an association to carry out a single business enterprise for profit, as legally distinct from a partnership. It held joint venturers owned the real property as tenants in common, so every owner had to consent to a sale or the property could be partitioned. Which label applies turns on the agreement and how the owners actually operated.
How long do I have to sue a former partner over a dissolved partnership?
It depends on the claim, and one point lacks a published Michigan decision. MCL 449.43 says the right to an account accrues at the date of dissolution. A breach of fiduciary duty claim is generally subject to the three-year period in MCL 600.5805(2), and under MCL 600.5827 a claim accrues when the wrong was done, not when it was discovered, and breach of contract is six years (MCL 600.5807(9)). An unpublished Court of Appeals opinion applied six years to a UPA accounting claim, but it is not binding.
If we never signed a partnership agreement, how do Michigan partners split profits and make decisions?
Subject to any agreement among the partners, MCL 449.18 says partners share profits equally, have equal management rights, and are not entitled to a salary. Ordinary business disputes are decided by a majority, but no new partner can be admitted without all partners’ consent, and acting against an agreement requires everyone’s consent.
Related Michigan pages
- Grand Rapids Business Litigation Attorney
- Grand Rapids LLC Member and Shareholder Dispute Attorney
- Grand Rapids Breach of Fiduciary Duty Attorney
- Grand Rapids Commercial Lease Dispute Attorney
- Leaving or dissolving a business
- How the Kent County Business Court Handles Commercial Cases
I handle partnership dissolution and joint venture disputes in Michigan for either side. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.