Skip to content

LLC Member and Shareholder Disputes · Grand Rapids and Kent County

Grand Rapids LLC Member and Shareholder Dispute Attorney

I handle disputes among Michigan LLC members and shareholders for either side, starting with the governing documents, the company records and the deadlines that apply.

A sheet of white paper torn across the middle against a light background.

LLC member and shareholder disputes in Michigan

I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids business litigation lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. When the owners of a company stop agreeing, the fight is usually about control, money, or access to information. This page covers LLC member and shareholder disputes in Michigan, including freeze-outs and oppression claims, being removed from a company you co-own, the right to see company records, buyouts, and court-ordered dissolution. I act for either side of an owner dispute, whether the owner, the company, or the other owners. The short answers below come from my Michigan legal library.

Most owner disputes I see in Kent County start the same way. One side controls the money, the books or the decisions, and the other side is shut out. Michigan gives a minority owner a statutory claim for that kind of conduct, but only in the circuit court, only on proof of conduct the statute defines, and only within time limits that differ by remedy. The entity type matters because the Legislature wrote one statute for LLCs and a separate one for corporations.

For an LLC the claim is MCL 450.4515. For a corporation it is MCL 450.1489. Each lets the court dissolve the company, change a provision of the governing documents, order or forbid an act, order a buyout at fair value, or award damages. Each also says that conduct permitted by an agreement is not willfully unfair and oppressive. That is why I read the operating agreement or the shareholder agreement and bylaws before anything else.

Timing is the trap. A claim for damages under either statute must be filed within 3 years after the claim accrued or 2 years after the owner discovered or should have discovered it, whichever comes first. The Michigan Supreme Court treats the LLC period as a true statute of limitations. The period for non-damages relief, such as a buyout order, is less settled. In 2026 the Court of Appeals held, in a corporation case, that the longer 6-year period applies to relief other than damages. The Supreme Court has not decided the question for LLCs. I treat the shortest plausible deadline as the real one until the documents show otherwise.

An oppression claim is not the only tool. Some owners need to sue in the company’s name for harm done to the company. Some only need the books. Some need the company ended or the other side bought out. The table below sorts the main claims.

Michigan owner dispute claims, deadlines and key rules

Claim or issue What must be shown Time limit or key rule Authority
LLC member oppression Managers or members in control acted illegally or fraudulently, or engaged in willfully unfair and oppressive conduct toward the company or the member: a continuing course of conduct, or a significant action or series of actions, that substantially interferes with the member’s interests as a member Damages: 3 years after accrual or 2 years after discovery, whichever is first. The claim accrues when the interference occurs, even if the financial loss is not yet calculable MCL 450.4515; Frank v. Linkner, 500 Mich. 133 (2017)
Shareholder oppression (corporation) Directors or those in control acted illegally, fraudulently or in a willfully unfair and oppressive way. The Court of Appeals also requires proof that they acted with intent to interfere with the shareholder’s interests as a shareholder Damages: 3 years after accrual or 2 years after discovery. Other relief: 6 years under MCL 600.5813, per a 2026 published Court of Appeals decision. No claim by a holder of publicly traded shares MCL 450.1489; Franks v. Franks, 330 Mich. App. 69 (2019); Turner v. J & J Slavik, Inc., No. 370564 (Mich. Ct. App. June 12, 2026); MCL 600.5813
LLC derivative claim A written demand on the managers or members, a member who held that status when the act occurred, a plaintiff who fairly and adequately represents the company, and continued membership through judgment Wait 90 days after the demand unless it is rejected sooner or waiting would cause irreparable injury MCL 450.4510; MCL 450.4514
Corporate derivative claim A shareholder at the time of the act, who fairly and adequately represents the corporation, continues as a shareholder, and made a written demand Wait 90 days after the demand unless it is rejected sooner or waiting would cause irreparable injury. Direct versus derivative turns on who was harmed and who receives the remedy MCL 450.1492a; MCL 450.1493a; Murphy v. Inman, 509 Mich. 132 (2022)
LLC member records and accounting A written request. A member may inspect and copy the records the Act requires the company to keep, during business hours at the member’s expense, and may ask for other information that is just and reasonable Request in writing first. A formal accounting is available as the operating agreement provides or when just and reasonable MCL 450.4503
Shareholder records A written demand from a shareholder of record that states a proper purpose and describes the records with reasonable particularity If inspection is not permitted within 5 business days, apply to the circuit court. If the court orders inspection, the corporation pays costs and reasonable attorney fees unless it proves it refused in good faith with a reasonable basis to doubt the right MCL 450.1487
Judicial dissolution of an LLC On application by or for a member, that the company is unable to carry on business in conformity with the articles of organization or operating agreements Circuit court of the county of the registered office. Dissolution also happens by events the articles or operating agreement set, or by unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote MCL 450.4802; MCL 450.4801
Corporate dissolution for deadlock On action by a director or by shareholders entitled to vote in a director election, that directors or shareholders cannot agree on material matters, or are divided so they cannot elect successors, and the corporation cannot function effectively in a way that serves creditors and shareholders Circuit court judgment MCL 450.1823

What the owner has to prove

Owner status. The plaintiff must be a member of the LLC or a shareholder. In Turner, the company had stopped treating the plaintiff as a shareholder after it ended his employment, and the Court of Appeals upheld findings that this refusal was part of the oppressive conduct. I fix ownership from the operating agreement, the stock ledger and the tax filings.

Control. The statute reaches the acts of managers or members in control of an LLC, and the acts of directors or those in control of a corporation. I identify who actually made each decision, who signed, and who benefited.

Conduct the statute counts. Both statutes define willfully unfair and oppressive conduct as a continuing course of conduct, or a significant action or series of actions, that substantially interferes with the owner’s interests as an owner. The definition says it may include terminating employment or cutting employment benefits to the extent that doing so interferes disproportionately with distributions or other ownership interests. In Turner the Court of Appeals upheld findings of oppression where the company withheld its books and records, would not recognize the owner’s shares, and obscured its finances. The same pattern shows up in other forms: no meetings, no distributions, no financial statements, a sudden dilution, or a pay structure that moves profit out of the company to the controlling owners.

Intent, for a corporation. The Court of Appeals reads the corporate statute to require proof that the defendants took the acts with intent to interfere with the plaintiff’s interests as a shareholder. Franks v. Franks, 330 Mich. App. 69 (2019). The defense answer is usually a legitimate business reason, so I look for evidence of motive: timing, who gained, and whether the reason was ever stated before the dispute began.

Employment is not the same as ownership. In Franchino v. Franchino, 263 Mich. App. 172 (2004), the Court of Appeals held that the corporate oppression statute protects a shareholder’s interests as a shareholder, not employment or a board seat as such. That case predates the statute’s 2006 amendment, so I read it against the current text, which says termination of employment may count to the extent it disproportionately interferes with distributions or other owner interests.

A court sitting in equity. In Madugula v. Taub, 496 Mich. 685, 720 (2014), the Michigan Supreme Court held that a claim under MCL 450.1489 carries no right to a jury, because the statute’s remedies are equitable. The judge decides the facts and the remedy. The judge has discretion over the remedy, so I present a clear account of what happened and a remedy that fits it.

Defenses and answers I look at in an owner dispute

The agreement allowed it. Both statutes exclude conduct permitted by the governing documents. The LLC statute also excludes conduct permitted by another agreement the member signed, or by a consistently applied written company policy. The corporate statute excludes conduct permitted by an agreement, the articles, the bylaws, or a consistently applied written corporate policy. If the operating agreement lets the majority set compensation, issue new interests, or expel a member on stated terms, the claim has to get around that language. The opposite is also true. A company that broke its own agreement has a harder time calling the conduct permitted.

The claim is late. In Frank v. Linkner, 500 Mich. 133 (2017), the Michigan Supreme Court held that the LLC statute’s time limit is a statute of limitations, that it runs from accrual or from discovery, whichever comes first, and that a member-oppression claim accrues when a manager substantially interferes with the member’s interests as a member, even if the member has not yet suffered a calculable financial loss. Claims for damages were barred unless tolling applied, and the Court pointed to the fraudulent concealment statute, MCL 600.5855, which allows 2 years after discovery. The Court did not decide the period for non-damages relief; it left that for the trial court. Late-claim defenses must be raised in the first responsive pleading under MCR 2.111(F)(3), and can be the basis for summary disposition under MCR 2.116(C)(7). For a corporation, Turner held that the 3-year and 2-year periods apply only to the damages request and that the 6-year period governs the buyout and other equitable relief. It is a published opinion, and I check for further appellate history before relying on it.

Wrong plaintiff, wrong claim. Many owner complaints are really claims for harm to the company, which belong to the company and can be brought by an owner only as a derivative claim. In Murphy v. Inman, 509 Mich. 132 (2022), the Michigan Supreme Court held that corporate directors owe common-law fiduciary duties directly to shareholders, and said courts distinguish direct from derivative claims by asking who suffered the harm and who would receive the benefit of any remedy. That is a corporation case, and I do not assume it decides every LLC question. A derivative plaintiff must first make a written demand and wait 90 days, unless the demand is rejected earlier or waiting would cause irreparable injury. MCL 450.4510 (LLC); MCL 450.1493a (corporation).

An arbitration clause. Many operating agreements send owner disputes to arbitration. In Altobelli v. Hartmann, 499 Mich. 284, 299 (2016), the Michigan Supreme Court applied agency principles to decide who falls within an operating agreement’s arbitration clause, and held that claims against the firm’s managers fell within a clause covering disputes between the firm and a former principal. Read the clause before filing, because a complaint filed in the wrong forum invites a motion to dismiss under MCR 2.116(C)(7), and the clause may control who decides the dispute.

Service and answer deadlines. A defendant served in Michigan has 21 days to answer or take other action, and 28 days if served outside Michigan or by registered mail. MCR 2.108(A)(1)-(2).

Remedies and consequences

The statutory menu. If the owner establishes grounds, the circuit court may grant relief it considers appropriate. For an LLC, the statute lists dissolution and liquidation, cancellation or alteration of a provision in the articles or operating agreement, direction or prohibition of an act, purchase of the member’s interest at fair value, and damages. MCL 450.4515(1). For a corporation, it lists dissolution, changes to the articles or bylaws, cancellation or alteration of a resolution or act, direction or prohibition of an act, purchase of the shares at fair value, and damages. MCL 450.1489(1). The lists are not exclusive.

A buyout at fair value. The statutes do not define fair value, and the court has wide discretion. In Turner, the trial court found that the defendants had destroyed the financial records that would have supported a valuation. With no other value evidence left, the court relied on the price the plaintiff had paid for the stock. The Court of Appeals upheld an order that the defendants buy the plaintiff’s 250 shares for $25,000 plus simple interest at 7 percent from May 1992, and agreed the interest was part of fair value, not an award of damages. That outcome turned on the facts of that case and gives no basis for predicting any other. In an ordinary case, the valuation fight is about method, date, discounts and the company’s real numbers, which is why access to records matters from the start.

Dissolution. Dissolution is available as oppression relief and under the separate LLC and deadlock statutes in the table. It ends the business, so it is usually leverage for a buyout, not the goal.

Damages. Damages must be proved, and the short limitation period applies to them. Where the controlling owners hid the numbers, proof of loss is the hard part, which is another reason to ask for the records early.

Attorney fees. Neither oppression statute contains a fee-shifting provision. Michigan follows the American rule, under which each side pays its own fees unless a statute, court rule or recognized exception applies. In Turner, the Court of Appeals affirmed the denial of attorney fees, holding that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding the limited exception for fraudulent or unlawful conduct inapplicable, and noted that the plaintiff had not appealed the denial of fees under the records statute. That statute, MCL 450.1487(5), requires the corporation to pay costs and reasonable attorney fees when the court orders inspection, unless the corporation proves it refused in good faith with a reasonable basis to doubt the right to inspect. In derivative cases, MCL 450.4514 lets the court order the company to pay the plaintiff’s reasonable expenses if the case produced a substantial benefit for it.

Whose claim is it, and what a court will not do

Three questions decide most owner cases before anyone talks about a buyout price. First, did the harm fall on the owner or on the company? Under the two questions in Murphy, an owner whose own distributions were cut is the one harmed and the one who would receive the remedy, which points to a direct claim. An owner who says the manager looted the company points to harm to the company, which usually means a derivative claim, and the recovery goes to the company. Second, what does the operating agreement or shareholder agreement say about the conduct? Third, when did the interference start, and what happened after?

A court will not rewrite a deal because an owner is unhappy. It will not treat a business decision the agreement allows as oppression, and it will not give a minority owner an exit the documents do not provide. For an LLC, a member may withdraw only as the operating agreement provides, and the agreement may provide for expulsion. MCL 450.4509. If the agreement is silent, the member who wants out has the statutory claims above, not a right to be paid out on demand.

How I handle an LLC member or shareholder dispute

  1. Read the governing documents and fix the deadlines. I start with the articles, the operating agreement or bylaws, every amendment, any shareholder or buy-sell agreement, and the company’s annual statements and tax filings. I identify the entity type, the arbitration and forum clauses, and the earliest date the conduct could have accrued. I calendar the shortest plausible deadline.
  2. Sort the claims. I decide which claims are direct, which are derivative, and which are records or dissolution claims, and whether the owner wants a buyout, a distribution, access to information, control or an exit.
  3. Get the records. If the books are the problem, I send a written request that satisfies the statute and sets out the purpose and the records sought. If the other side refuses, the corporate records statute gives a path to the circuit court for an order.
  4. Send a demand, or answer one. For a derivative claim, the written demand and 90-day wait are mandatory unless an exception applies. For a direct claim, a demand letter often sets out the conduct, the agreement terms and the relief sought. If you are on the receiving end, I read the demand against the documents before anyone responds.
  5. File or respond in the circuit court. I file in the county of the company’s principal place of business or registered office, plead the claims the facts support, and raise the defenses that must be raised in the first responsive pleading, including the time limit and any arbitration clause.
  6. Take the discovery that matters. In owner disputes, that means financial statements, general ledgers, tax returns, compensation records, communications among the controlling owners, and valuation material. I also send preservation letters early, because records that disappear change the case.
  7. Prepare for the judge. These claims are decided by a judge in equity, so I prepare a chronology, the documents, the witnesses, and a specific remedy request, including a valuation when a buyout is sought.

Ways an owner dispute may end without a trial

A negotiated buyout. Many owner disputes that settle do so through a buyout, with a price, a payment schedule, releases, and terms on non-disparagement, confidentiality and any restrictive covenants.

An agreed sale or dissolution. Sometimes both sides decide the company is worth more sold than fought over. An agreed sale of the business or its assets, or an agreed dissolution with a winding-up plan, can end the case.

Mediation and other ADR. Civil cases are subject to alternative dispute resolution unless a rule provides otherwise, and mediation is a process in which the mediator has no power to decide the case. MCR 2.410(A)(1); MCR 2.411(A)(2). Case evaluation is aimed at cases where the relief sought is primarily money damages or division of property, and a court may exempt claims for equitable relief for good cause. MCR 2.403(A)(1), (A)(4).

Offers to stipulate. A party can make a formal offer to stipulate to entry of judgment, and a rejected offer can carry cost consequences later. MCR 2.405.

Whether to settle is your decision. I give you my view of the strengths, the weaknesses and the cost of continuing, and I do not promise outcomes.

What I need from you

Bring the operating agreement or bylaws and every amendment, any shareholder, buy-sell or employment agreement, the articles of organization or incorporation, and the capital contribution and ownership records. Bring the financial statements and tax returns you received, and every written request you made for information and the response. Bring emails and texts about votes, pay, distributions, dilution or removal, and a timeline with dates. If you are the one being sued or the one who received a demand, bring the summons and complaint or the letter and note the date and manner of service, because the answer deadline runs from service. Do not delete messages or alter company records, do not move company money or sign a buyout, release or amendment until someone has read it against the governing documents, and do not discuss fault with the other owners or their lawyers until you have spoken with me.

Where your Kent County owner dispute will be heard

Both oppression statutes direct the action to the circuit court of the county where the company’s principal place of business or registered office is located. MCL 450.4515(1); MCL 450.1489(1). I represent clients in Grand Rapids, Kentwood, Grandville, Wyoming and across Kent County. Under MCL 600.8301(1), the district court has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions when the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000. Kent County district courts include the 61st District Court in Grand Rapids, the 59th in Walker and Grandville, the 62A in Wyoming, the 62B in Kentwood and the 63rd for Rockford, Lowell, Cedar Springs, East Grand Rapids and the surrounding townships. Larger claims are filed in the Kent County Circuit Court, the 17th Judicial Circuit. A dispute between a business and its present or former owners, members or shareholders, or about the governance or dissolution of a business enterprise, can qualify as a business or commercial dispute under MCL 600.8031, which defines the cases eligible for a business court docket.

Why people hire me for a Michigan LLC or shareholder dispute

You work directly with me, the lawyer handling your case. I give you the strengths and weaknesses of the case straight, including what it could cost you and what it could recover. I build the case the facts support, and then we decide together how to proceed.

Fees depend on the type of case, its complexity and whether it is likely to go to trial. I explain my fee arrangement at the consultation, before you decide whether to hire me.

Questions I hear from people in an LLC member or shareholder dispute in Michigan

What can I do if I am an LLC member being frozen out by the managers or controlling members?

MCL 450.4515 lets a member sue in circuit court to establish that the acts of the managers or members in control are illegal, fraudulent, or willfully unfair and oppressive toward the company or the member. If the member establishes grounds, the court may order relief such as dissolution, changes to the operating agreement, a buyout at fair value, or damages.

Authority: MCL 450.4515(1)-(2). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can I be fired from the company I co-own and still claim oppression?

Possibly. Both the LLC statute and the shareholder statute say willfully unfair and oppressive conduct may include termination of employment or limitations on employment benefits to the extent the actions interfere with distributions or other member or shareholder interests disproportionately as to the affected owner. It depends on the agreements and on how the action affected your ownership.

Authority: MCL 450.4515(2); MCL 450.1489(3). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

How long do I have to bring an LLC member oppression claim for damages?

A claim seeking damages must be commenced within 3 years after the cause of action accrued or within 2 years after you discovered or reasonably should have discovered it, whichever occurs first, under MCL 450.4515(1)(e). In Frank v Linkner the Michigan Supreme Court held the claim accrues when the managers substantially interfere with your interests, not when you suffer a calculable financial loss.

Authority: MCL 450.4515(1)(e); Frank v Linkner, 500 Mich 133 (2017); MCL 450.1489(1)(f). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can a minority shareholder in a Michigan corporation sue for oppression?

Yes, if the shares are not publicly traded. MCL 450.1489 lets a shareholder sue in circuit court to establish that the acts of the directors or those in control are illegal, fraudulent, or willfully unfair and oppressive. It cannot be used by a holder of shares listed on a national securities exchange or regularly traded in a market maintained by securities association members. The claim is tried to the court, not a jury.

Authority: MCL 450.1489(1)-(2); Madugula v Taub, 496 Mich 685 (2014). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Do I have a right to see my LLC’s or corporation’s books and records?

Yes, within limits. An LLC member can request financial statements and tax returns in writing, ask for true and full information on the company’s financial condition, and inspect required records on reasonable written request under MCL 450.4503. A corporate shareholder may inspect books and records for a proper purpose on written demand under MCL 450.1487, with a circuit court remedy if inspection is refused for 5 business days.

Authority: MCL 450.4503; MCL 450.1487(2)-(3). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

What does willfully unfair and oppressive conduct mean for an owner of an LLC or a corporation?

Under MCL 450.4515(2) and MCL 450.1489(3), it means a continuing course of conduct or a significant action or series of actions that substantially interferes with your interests as a member or shareholder. It does not include conduct permitted by the articles, an operating or shareholder agreement, another agreement (for an LLC member, one to which the member is a party), or a consistently applied written policy.

Authority: MCL 450.4515(2); MCL 450.1489(3); Madugula v Taub, 496 Mich 685 (2014). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can I withdraw from my Michigan LLC and get paid for my share?

Only as the operating agreement allows. MCL 450.4509 says a member may withdraw from a Michigan LLC only as provided in the operating agreement, and a withdrawing member may be entitled to a withdrawal distribution. The agreement may also provide for expulsion or other events that end membership.

Authority: MCL 450.4509; MCL 450.4515; MCL 450.4307; MCL 450.4505. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Do I have to prove the other owners meant to hurt me, and does breaking our shareholder agreement count as oppression?

For a corporation, intent matters. In Franks v Franks the Court of Appeals held that a shareholder must prove the controlling owners took acts that substantially interfered with the shareholder’s interests as a shareholder and did so with the intent to interfere, so a legitimate business reason can defeat the claim. The Supreme Court held in Madugula v Taub that a breach of a shareholder agreement may be evidence of oppression. The LLC statute is worded similarly, but no published LLC decision adopting either point has been identified.

Authority: MCL 450.1489(1); MCL 450.1489(3); MCL 450.4515(2); Franks v Franks, 330 Mich App 69 (2019); Madugula v Taub, 496 Mich 685 (2014); Turner v J & J Slavik, Inc, ___ Mich App ___ (Docket No. 370564, June 12, 2026) (published; subject to revision until final publication). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

I handle disputes among LLC members and shareholders in Michigan for either side. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.

Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.

Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.

MBisson@BissonLegal.com

This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.

Do not wait. Call me.

The sooner I am involved, the more I can do. I keep what you tell me private. Please share only the basics until we have spoken.