
In an arbitration clause or a mediation order? Know what you gave up and what a court can still review
I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids civil litigation lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. This page explains how arbitration and mediation work in Michigan civil disputes: when an arbitration clause is enforced, how an arbitration is run, how little a court can change afterward, and how court-ordered mediation and case evaluation differ. I represent people on either side of a civil case, whether they want to enforce an arbitration clause or avoid one. I do not promise outcomes.
The short answer. A written agreement to arbitrate is generally valid, enforceable and irrevocable, except on grounds that would revoke any contract. MCL 691.1686(1). The court decides whether an agreement to arbitrate exists and whether a dispute falls within it, and the arbitrator decides whether a contract containing a valid arbitration agreement is enforceable. MCL 691.1686(2), (3). Once there is an award, a court can vacate it only on narrow statutory grounds and within a short deadline, which is 90 days after notice of the award under the Michigan act for most current arbitrations. MCL 691.1703. Mediation is different. A mediator has no authoritative decision-making power, so a case settles only if the parties agree. MCR 2.411(A)(2). Nothing here predicts how your case will end.
People often sign an arbitration clause without a second thought and then find out it controls where the dispute is decided, who decides it, how much discovery there is and how little room there is to appeal. Others are in court and are ordered to mediation or case evaluation without knowing how those processes work.
Three processes that are not the same
Arbitration, mediation and case evaluation are often grouped together as alternatives to trial, but they work very differently. The table sets out the differences that matter most.
| Process | Who decides | Is the result binding? | Main authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arbitration | An arbitrator or panel chosen under the parties’ agreement | Yes. The award can be confirmed as a judgment and can be vacated only on narrow grounds | MCL 691.1686; MCL 691.1702; MCL 691.1703 |
| Mediation under the court rules | No one. The mediator facilitates communication and helps the parties explore settlement | Only if the parties agree to a settlement | MCR 2.410; MCR 2.411 |
| Case evaluation | A panel of 3 persons evaluates a case in which the relief sought is primarily money damages | Only if all parties accept. If any party rejects, the action proceeds to trial in the normal fashion | MCR 2.403(A), (D), (M), (N) |
A private mediation that the parties arrange on their own, outside a court order, is governed by whatever the parties sign.
Which law governs your arbitration
For most arbitrations today, the governing Michigan law is the Uniform Arbitration Act, MCL 691.1681 and following. Beginning July 1, 2013, it governs an agreement to arbitrate whenever made. MCL 691.1683(1). It does not apply to an arbitration between members of a voluntary membership organization when arbitration is required and administered by the organization, although a party may ask a court to confirm or vacate an award in that setting on limited grounds. MCL 691.1683(2). The court rule on arbitration says the same thing from the other direction: an action or proceeding commenced on or after July 1, 2013 is governed by the statute and not by the rule, and the rest of the rule applies to other forms of arbitration. MCR 3.602(A). In Fette v Peters Constr Co, 310 Mich App 535, 541-543 (2015), the Court of Appeals explained that the Legislature repealed the former act and replaced it with the Uniform Arbitration Act effective July 1, 2013, and that the new act does not apply to a proceeding commenced before that date.
Federal law can also apply. The Federal Arbitration Act provides that a written arbitration provision in a contract evidencing a transaction involving commerce is valid, irrevocable and enforceable, save upon such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. 9 USC 2. It also has its own deadline: notice of a motion to vacate, modify or correct an award must be served within three months after the award is filed or delivered. 9 USC 12. Which law governs a particular motion can depend on the contract, the parties and the forum, so I read the clause first and plan around the shortest deadline that could apply.
Is the arbitration clause enforceable, and who decides
A clause is judged like any other contract term: it is enforceable unless a ground exists at law or in equity to revoke a contract. MCL 691.1686(1). The statute divides the questions. The court decides whether an agreement to arbitrate exists and whether the controversy is subject to it. An arbitrator decides whether a condition precedent to arbitrability has been fulfilled and whether the contract containing the arbitration agreement is enforceable. MCL 691.1686(2), (3). If a party challenges the existence or scope of the agreement in court, the arbitration may continue pending the court’s final decision unless the court orders otherwise. MCL 691.1686(4).
The Michigan Supreme Court has described arbitration as a matter of contract. In Altobelli v Hartmann, 499 Mich 284, 295, 302-303 (2016), the Court applied a broad arbitration clause to claims against individual agents and looked at the gravamen of the claim, not just its label. The words of the clause matter a great deal: whether it covers all disputes or only some, whether it reaches tort and statutory claims as well as contract claims, and who it protects.
If one side sues despite a clause, the other side can move to compel arbitration. The court proceeds summarily and orders arbitration unless it finds there is no enforceable agreement to arbitrate, and it cannot refuse to order arbitration because the claim lacks merit. MCL 691.1687(1), (4). Court proceedings on a claim subject to arbitration are stayed. MCL 691.1687(6), (7). The court rules also list an agreement to arbitrate as an affirmative defense that must be pleaded in the responsive pleading and as a ground for summary disposition. MCR 2.111(F)(3); MCR 2.116(C)(7). I raise it in the first response, because a party that goes forward in court without raising it invites a fight about whether it was given up. Before an arbitrator is in place, a court can order provisional remedies to protect the arbitration, and asking for one does not waive the right to arbitrate. MCL 691.1688(1), (3).
How an arbitration runs
A person starts an arbitration by giving notice in the agreed manner, or in the absence of an agreement by certified or registered mail or by service as for a civil action, describing the nature of the controversy and the remedy sought. MCL 691.1689(1). Before accepting an appointment, a proposed arbitrator must make a reasonable inquiry and disclose any known facts that a reasonable person would consider likely to affect impartiality, including a financial or personal interest and past or present relationships with the parties, their counsel or the witnesses. MCL 691.1692(1). A neutral arbitrator who does not disclose a known, direct and material interest in the outcome, or a known, existing and substantial relationship with a party, is presumed to act with evident partiality. MCL 691.1692(5). I look at those disclosures closely, and I object in time, because the statute ties an objection to a later motion to vacate.
The arbitrator may conduct the arbitration in the manner the arbitrator considers appropriate for a fair and expeditious disposition, and may decide a request for summary disposition of a claim or issue if all parties agree or if one party asks on notice to the others. MCL 691.1695(1), (2). If a hearing is ordered, notice must be given not less than 5 days before it begins, and each party has the right to be heard, to present evidence material to the controversy and to cross-examine witnesses. MCL 691.1695(3), (4). A party may be represented by a lawyer. MCL 691.1696. The arbitrator can issue subpoenas, can permit depositions and may permit or limit discovery as appropriate, taking into account the needs of the parties, the agreement and the desirability of a fair, expeditious and cost effective proceeding. MCL 691.1697(1) to (3). That last point matters in a business case. Discovery in arbitration is usually narrower than in court, and what you need must be requested early and justified to the arbitrator.
On remedies, an arbitrator may award punitive damages or other exemplary relief if authorized by law in a civil action on the same claim, and may award reasonable attorney fees and expenses if authorized by law in a civil action on the same claim or by the agreement of the parties. As to other remedies, the arbitrator may order what the arbitrator considers just and appropriate, and the fact that a court could not or would not grant the remedy is not a ground to refuse to confirm or to vacate the award. MCL 691.1701(1) to (3). The award must be made in a signed record and notice given to each party, within the time in the agreement or ordered by the court. MCL 691.1699. A party can ask the arbitrator to modify or correct the award within 20 days after receiving notice of it. MCL 691.1700(1), (2).
After the award: confirm, vacate or modify
After receiving notice of an award, a party may move the court to confirm it, and the court issues a confirming order unless the award is modified or corrected or is vacated. MCL 691.1702. The court shall vacate an award if it was procured by corruption, fraud or other undue means; if there was evident partiality by a neutral arbitrator, corruption by an arbitrator or misconduct prejudicing a party’s rights; if the arbitrator refused to postpone the hearing on sufficient cause, refused to consider material evidence or conducted the hearing contrary to the statute so as to prejudice a party substantially; if the arbitrator exceeded the arbitrator’s powers; if there was no agreement to arbitrate and the party did not participate without objecting; or if the arbitration was conducted without proper notice. MCL 691.1703(1). A motion to modify or correct is limited to an evident mathematical miscalculation or mistake in a description, an award on a claim not submitted, or an imperfection in form. MCL 691.1704(1). The deadlines differ by source, and they are short.
| Governing law | To vacate | To modify or correct | Authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michigan Uniform Arbitration Act | A motion within 90 days after notice of the award. For corruption, fraud or other undue means, 90 days after the ground is known or should have been known | A motion within 90 days after notice of the award | MCL 691.1703(2); MCL 691.1704(1) |
| Court rule for arbitrations the act does not cover, such as a proceeding begun before July 1, 2013 | A complaint or motion to vacate within 21 days after the date of the award. The same rule also lets a motion be filed within 91 days, or within 21 days after the grounds are known for corruption, fraud or undue means, so I treat 21 days as the deadline | A complaint within 21 days after the date of the award. A motion within 91 days | MCR 3.602(J)(1), (J)(3), (K)(1), (K)(2) |
| Domestic relations arbitration (divorce, custody, support) | A motion to vacate within 21 days after the date of the award. For corruption, fraud or undue means, within 21 days after the grounds are known or should have been known | The arbitrator can correct errors or omissions on a motion filed within 14 days after the award. In court, the rule above applies, so I calendar 21 days | MCR 3.602(J)(3), (K)(1); MCL 600.5081(4); MCL 600.5078(3) |
| Federal Arbitration Act | Notice of a motion served within three months after the award is filed or delivered | Same | 9 USC 12 |
Where the act applies, it controls and the court rule does not. MCR 3.602(A). The rule’s own text is not consistent. Subrule (J)(1) requires a complaint or motion to vacate within 21 days after the date of the award, while subrule (J)(3) allows a motion within 91 days, with 21 days for corruption, fraud or undue means and for any domestic relations case. I do not rely on the longer period. If the act does not clearly govern, I file within 21 days.
If the court vacates an award on grounds other than the lack of an agreement, it may order a rehearing. If the award is vacated for corruption, fraud or undue means, or for evident partiality, corruption or misconduct by the arbitrator, the rehearing must be before a new arbitrator. For the other grounds, the rehearing may be before the same arbitrator or a successor. MCL 691.1703(3). If the court denies a motion to vacate, it confirms the award unless a motion to modify is pending. MCL 691.1703(4). A judgment entered on the award can be recorded, docketed and enforced like any other judgment, and the court may allow costs and, on a prevailing party’s request in a contested proceeding, reasonable attorney fees and expenses of the litigation after the award. MCL 691.1705. Appeals can be taken from orders such as an order denying a motion to compel arbitration, an order confirming or denying confirmation of an award, and an order vacating an award without directing a rehearing. MCL 691.1708.
How narrow court review of an award is
The statutory grounds are narrow, and the case law makes them narrower in practice. In Gordon Sel-Way, Inc v Spence Bros, 438 Mich 488, 495-497, 501 (1991), the Michigan Supreme Court explained that arbitrators draw their authority from the contract and exceed their powers when they act beyond the material terms of the contract. The Court held that an error must be evident on the face of the award and so substantial that the award would otherwise be substantially different, and that a court may not reinterpret the contract or set aside an award on the merits. In Fette v Peters Constr Co, 310 Mich App 535, 541-543 (2015), the Court of Appeals said review of an arbitration award is extremely limited and the court cannot review the arbitrator’s findings of fact or the merits of the decision.
For a client, this means the decision that matters is the one made before the award. Choosing the arbitrator, objecting to bias in time, making the record at the hearing and asking for discovery that you need are the steps that count. After an award, a motion to vacate is a real option when the facts fit one of the statutory grounds, but a disagreement with the arbitrator’s reading of the contract or the facts is not one of them.
Mediation and case evaluation in a lawsuit
All civil cases are subject to alternative dispute resolution processes unless a statute or court rule provides otherwise. MCR 2.410(A)(1). The court may order a case to an appropriate process after consulting the parties, and a party has 14 days after the order to move to set it aside or modify it. MCR 2.410(C)(1), (E). The parties may stipulate to a mediator, and the court must appoint the mediator they stipulate to if the mediator can serve within a time that does not interfere with the trial schedule. MCR 2.411(B)(1). If the case settles in mediation, the attorneys must submit the documents to conclude the case within 21 days, and the mediator’s report to the court is limited to the date of completion, who took part, whether the case settled and whether more ADR is contemplated. MCR 2.411(C)(3), (C)(4). Mediation costs are divided between the parties pro rata unless they agree otherwise or the court orders otherwise, and the mediator’s fee is a cost of the action. MCR 2.411(D)(2), (D)(4).
Mediation communications are confidential. They are not subject to discovery, are not admissible in a proceeding and may not be disclosed to anyone other than mediation participants, with the exceptions listed in the rule. MCR 2.412(C), (D).
Case evaluation is a different process. A panel of 3 persons evaluates a case in which the relief sought is primarily money damages, and each party sends a $75 fee, or $50 if a judge is on the panel. MCR 2.403(A)(1), (D)(1), (H)(1). Each party must file a written acceptance or rejection within 28 days after service of the evaluation, and a failure to file within 28 days counts as a rejection. If all parties accept, judgment is entered in accordance with the evaluation unless the award is paid within 28 days. If all or part is rejected, the action proceeds to trial in the normal fashion. MCR 2.403(L)(1), (M)(1), (N)(1). The current text of the rule does not impose a fee penalty for rejecting an evaluation. A separate rule on offers of judgment can shift costs and fees, and I handle that rule on its own.
What I look for in a dispute resolution clause
When a client brings me a contract, I read the dispute resolution clause as carefully as the price terms. I look at whether it requires arbitration for every dispute or only some, whether it names an administrator and rules, how many arbitrators decide and how they are chosen, and how much discovery is allowed. I check whether the clause requires mediation or a notice period before anyone can sue or start an arbitration, whether it allocates the cost of arbitration and attorney fees, and whether it carves out claims for an injunction or collection. I also look for a jury trial waiver and a clause that shortens the time to bring a claim, because all of these interact. Fee provisions in an arbitration agreement matter because the statute allows an arbitrator to award fees authorized by the parties’ agreement.
How I handle an arbitration or mediation
- Read the clause and the facts. I identify the clause, the parties it binds, the claims it covers and any step that must come first.
- Decide whether to enforce or avoid it. If my client wants arbitration, I move to compel it and to stay the lawsuit. If my client wants to stay in court, I look at whether the clause is enforceable and whether the dispute falls within it.
- Check the deadlines. I calendar the contract deadlines and the statute of limitations for the underlying claim, and the shortest period that could apply to challenging an award.
- Shape the process. I deal with the arbitrator’s disclosures, the schedule, the discovery plan and the hearing format before the evidence is presented.
- Build the record. I present the case with documents, witnesses and cross-examination as if it will not be reviewed, because the review is narrow.
- Prepare for mediation. I assemble a settlement analysis with the strengths and weaknesses of each side, the cost of continuing and a walk-away number you set, and then you decide.
- Protect your rights after the award. I decide within days whether to confirm, vacate or modify, and I file inside the deadline.
How these disputes can end
An arbitration ends with an award, which is confirmed and entered as a judgment unless a court vacates or modifies it. A mediation ends with a signed settlement or without one, and a case that does not settle goes back on the court’s track. A case evaluation ends when the parties accept or reject the panel’s number. I tell you where I think your case is strong and weak at each stage, and I do not promise a result.
What I need from you
Bring the contract with every amendment, any terms of service or order form that may contain an arbitration clause, and every demand letter, notice or filing. If an arbitration has started, bring the demand, the administrator’s rules, the arbitrator disclosures and any scheduling order. If an award has been issued, bring it with the date you received it, because that date starts the clock. If a court has ordered mediation or case evaluation, bring the order. Write down who signed the agreement and in what capacity, what was said when it was signed and whether anyone has paid or promised to pay. If you have already taken part in a hearing, tell me what you objected to and when.
Where your Kent County civil case will be heard
I represent clients in Grand Rapids, Kentwood, Grandville, Wyoming and across Kent County, whether the dispute is in court or in arbitration. Under MCL 600.8301(1), the district court has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions when the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000. Michigan law sets the Kent County district courts by municipality. The 61st District Court serves the city of Grand Rapids, the 59th serves the cities of Grandville and Walker, the 62A serves the city of Wyoming and the 62B serves the city of Kentwood. MCL 600.8128a; MCL 600.8130(1)-(3). The 63rd District Court serves the rest of Kent County, which includes the cities of Rockford, Lowell, Cedar Springs and East Grand Rapids and the surrounding townships. MCL 600.8130(4). Larger claims are filed in the Kent County Circuit Court, the 17th Judicial Circuit. MCL 600.518.
Why people hire me for a Michigan arbitration or mediation matter
You work directly with me, the lawyer handling your case. I give you the strengths and weaknesses of the case straight, including what it could cost you and what it could recover. I build the case the facts support, and then we decide together how to proceed. In an arbitration or mediation, that means I tell you how the process will work, what you can still challenge and what you cannot.
Fees depend on the type of case, its complexity and whether it is likely to go to trial. I explain my fee arrangement at the consultation, before you decide whether to hire me.
Questions I hear from people facing arbitration or mediation in Michigan
Is an arbitration clause in my contract enforceable in Michigan?
Generally, yes. Under MCL 691.1686(1), an agreement contained in a record to submit existing or future controversies to arbitration is valid, enforceable, and irrevocable except on a ground that exists at law or in equity for the revocation of a contract. The court decides whether an agreement to arbitrate exists or a controversy is covered by it, and an arbitrator decides conditions precedent and whether the contract is enforceable.
Can I overturn an arbitration award in Michigan?
Only on narrow grounds. Under MCL 691.1703, a court shall vacate an award procured by corruption, fraud, or other undue means; for evident partiality by a neutral arbitrator, corruption, or misconduct that prejudiced a party’s rights; or because the arbitrator exceeded the arbitrator’s powers, among other listed grounds. Under the Uniform Arbitration Act the motion must be filed within 90 days after notice of the award (or, for corruption or fraud, 90 days after the ground is known or should have been known); older arbitrations and domestic relations arbitrations are governed by MCR 3.602(J), which sets its own deadlines, including 21 days for domestic relations awards, so confirm the deadline in the rule and the arbitration agreement right away.
How long do I have to challenge a Michigan arbitration award in court?
If the arbitration proceeding began on or after July 1, 2013, Michigan’s Uniform Arbitration Act applies, and a motion to vacate must be filed within 90 days after you receive notice of the award or of a modified or corrected award (MCL 691.1703(2)). For corruption, fraud or other undue means, the 90 days run from when you knew or should have known of the ground. The act controls over the court rule in those cases (MCR 3.602(A)). The court rule still governs other arbitrations, and its text is not consistent: MCR 3.602(J)(1) requires a complaint or motion to vacate within 21 days after the date of the award, while MCR 3.602(J)(3) allows a motion within 91 days, or 21 days after the grounds are known for corruption, fraud or undue means. Because of that conflict, 21 days is the period to calendar. A domestic relations arbitration is also on the 21-day clock (MCR 3.602(J)(3); MCL 600.5081(4)).
What is mediation in a Michigan lawsuit, and is it binding?
Mediation is a process in which a neutral third party facilitates communication between the parties, helps identify issues, and explores solutions. Under MCR 2.411, a mediator has no authoritative decision-making power, so a case settles only if the parties agree. Case evaluation under MCR 2.403 is different: a three-person panel evaluates a primarily money-damages case.
Can I put a jury trial waiver in a business contract in Michigan?
Michigan treats the jury right as one that can be waived, and the Court of Appeals has applied contractual jury waiver clauses by their plain terms in unpublished decisions. Without a waiver, a jury must be demanded in writing within 28 days after the answer, with the fee.
Do I have to go to arbitration or mediation before I can sue my condominium association or another owner?
Not by statute alone. MCL 559.154(8) requires the bylaws to provide for binding arbitration of disputes over the condominium documents or between co-owners, but only upon the election and written consent of the parties. Without that election, either side may petition a court (MCL 559.154(9)). Once parties elect arbitration, they cannot go to court on that dispute. These subsections apply only to projects established on or after the amendatory act that added them.
Related Michigan pages
- Grand Rapids civil litigation attorney
- Breach of contract
- Civil discovery and trial
- Attorney fees and costs in civil cases
- Commercial contracts and UCC disputes
I represent plaintiffs and defendants in arbitration, mediation and civil cases in Kent County and West Michigan. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.