
Commercial contract and UCC disputes in Michigan
I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids business litigation lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. Disputes over goods, equipment, supply deals and business loans often turn on what the contract says and which rules apply to it. This page covers commercial contract and UCC questions that Michigan businesses raise, including warranty disclaimers, deadlines on defective goods, limits on remedies, repossession of equipment, personal guaranties and UCC filings. I act for either side of these disputes, buyers and sellers, lenders and borrowers. The short answers below come from my Michigan legal library.
Most of these disputes start the same way. A buyer takes delivery of equipment or inventory, something is wrong, and an angry email goes out. The seller answers with the paper: a quote, an acknowledgment, an invoice, terms on the back of a form. The buyer has a purchase order with different terms, and each side says its own form controls. In a sale of goods the Uniform Commercial Code (the Code) decides that question and sets the deadlines. The usual limit for suing is the four-year period in MCL 440.2725(1), and the original agreement may cut it to as little as one year.
Other clocks run faster. A buyer who keeps the goods has to give the seller notice of the problem within a reasonable time, or MCL 440.2607(3)(a) bars any remedy. A buyer who wants to send the goods back has to reject them or revoke acceptance within a reasonable time. I find the dates first.
This page covers the commercial and UCC side of a contract dispute, from battle of the forms to repossession of business equipment. I act for buyers and sellers, lenders and borrowers, and I read every document from both sides of the table. Nothing here predicts how your case will end, and I do not promise outcomes.
Michigan commercial contract and UCC claims, deadlines and remedies
These are the rules in the statutes and the case law. The numbers in your case depend on the goods, the documents and the dates.
| Claim or issue | What must be shown | Time limit or key rule | Authority |
|---|---|---|---|
| Battle of the forms | An acceptance or written confirmation that states different or additional terms | Between merchants, additional terms are part of the contract unless the offer limits acceptance, they materially alter it, or objection is given in time | MCL 440.2207(1)-(2); Power Press Sales Co. v. MSI Battle Creek Stamping, 238 Mich. App. 173, 180-183 (2000) |
| Rejection and cure | Goods or tender that fail in any respect to conform to the contract | Reject within a reasonable time and seasonably notify the seller; the seller may cure in the cases the statute describes | MCL 440.2601; MCL 440.2602(1); MCL 440.2508 |
| Notice of breach after acceptance | Notice that the transaction is claimed to involve a breach; the buyer must establish the breach | Within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered the breach, or the buyer is barred from any remedy | MCL 440.2607(3)-(4); American Bumper & Manufacturing Co. v. Transtechnology Corp., 252 Mich. App. 340, 345-348 (2002) |
| Revocation of acceptance | A nonconformity that substantially impairs the value of the goods to the buyer | Within a reasonable time after discovery and before a substantial change in the goods; effective when the seller is notified | MCL 440.2608; Colonial Dodge, Inc. v. Miller, 420 Mich. 452, 457-459 (1985) |
| Time to sue on a sale of goods | Any action for breach of a contract for sale | 4 years from accrual; the agreement may reduce it to not less than 1 year but not extend it; a warranty breach occurs at tender of delivery | MCL 440.2725(1)-(2); Baker v. DEC International, 458 Mich. 247 (1998) |
| Repossession of equipment | A default and a secured party with a security interest in the collateral | Possession by judicial process, or without a court if there is no breach of the peace; the debtor may redeem before a sale or acceptance in satisfaction | MCL 440.9609(1)-(2); MCL 440.9623 |
What the buyer or the seller has to prove
The law that applies. Article 2 applies to transactions in goods under MCL 440.2102. In Neibarger v. Universal Cooperatives, Inc., 439 Mich. 512, 534 (1992), the Michigan Supreme Court approved the test that asks whether the predominant factor of the transaction is service with goods incidentally involved, or a sale with labor incidentally involved. I work out which one I have before I count days.
The contract. A sale of goods for $1,000 or more needs a writing signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought, with exceptions that include specially manufactured goods, goods paid for and accepted or received and accepted, and an admission in a pleading or testimony (MCL 440.2201(1)-(3)).
The breach. A buyer who accepted the goods must establish the breach (MCL 440.2607(4)). An express warranty comes from an affirmation of fact or promise, a description, or a sample or model that is part of the basis of the bargain, but not from mere opinion or a statement of value (MCL 440.2313). The implied warranty of merchantability applies when the seller is a merchant for goods of that kind (MCL 440.2314(1)-(2)). An implied warranty of fitness arises when the seller had reason to know the buyer’s particular purpose and that the buyer relied on the seller’s skill or judgment (MCL 440.2315).
Battle of the forms: whose terms are in the contract
Under MCL 440.2207(1), an acceptance or written confirmation operates as an acceptance even though it states additional or different terms, unless the acceptance is expressly made conditional on assent to them. The additional terms are proposals. Between merchants they become part of the contract unless the offer expressly limits acceptance to its terms, they materially alter it, or objection is given within a reasonable time. Conduct by both parties can establish a contract even if the writings do not, and the terms are then those on which the writings agree plus the Code’s gap-fillers.
In Challenge Machinery Co. v. Mattison Machine Works, 138 Mich. App. 15, 23-26 (1984), a seller’s quotation and the buyer’s purchase order carried conflicting warranty and damages terms. The Court of Appeals held that the conflicting provisions cancelled out and the Code’s own provisions applied. Challenge Machinery was decided before November 1, 1990, so a later panel need not follow it (MCR 7.215(J)(1)). In Power Press Sales Co. v. MSI Battle Creek Stamping, 238 Mich. App. at 180-183 (2000), an indemnity clause appeared for the first time in the seller’s invoice. The court held that under Michigan law an indemnity clause should be deemed a material alteration, and because the buyer never expressly accepted it, it was not part of the agreement.
So the fine print on the last form sent does not automatically control. I collect every form in the order it was sent, note which say acceptance is conditional, look for written objections and check whether the parties performed anyway.
Rejection, cure, acceptance and revocation
If goods or the tender fail in any respect to conform to the contract, the buyer may reject the whole, accept the whole, or accept any commercial unit and reject the rest (MCL 440.2601). Rejection must be within a reasonable time after delivery and is ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller. After rejection, any exercise of ownership by the buyer is wrongful as against the seller, and a buyer in possession must hold the goods with reasonable care at the seller’s disposition (MCL 440.2602(1)-(2)). A seller may cure if the time for performance has not expired, on seasonable notice and a conforming delivery within the contract time, or, if it had reasonable grounds to believe the tender would be acceptable, on seasonable notice and a further reasonable time (MCL 440.2508).
A buyer accepts by signaling that the goods conform or will be kept anyway, by failing to make an effective rejection, or by doing an act inconsistent with the seller’s ownership (MCL 440.2606(1)). Acceptance with knowledge of a nonconformity cannot be revoked for it unless the buyer reasonably assumed it would be cured (MCL 440.2607(2)).
Revocation is the buyer’s route when the defect shows up after acceptance. Under MCL 440.2608, the nonconformity must substantially impair the value of the goods to the buyer, and the buyer must have accepted either on the reasonable assumption that it would be cured, or without discovering it because of the difficulty of discovery or the seller’s assurances. In Colonial Dodge, Inc. v. Miller, 420 Mich. at 457-459, a car buyer found the spare tire he ordered was missing. The Supreme Court held that the omission substantially impaired the car’s value to him, that the concealed location made the defect hard to discover, and that notice the morning after delivery was within a reasonable time. A seller has no right to cure after a buyer revokes under section 2608(1)(b), though its repair attempts still bear on substantial impairment and timely notice (Head v. Phillips Camper Sales & Rental, Inc., 234 Mich. App. 94, 106 (1999)).
Warranties, disclaimers and limits on remedies
To exclude the implied warranty of merchantability, the language must mention merchantability and, in a writing, be conspicuous. To exclude an implied warranty of fitness, the exclusion must be in a conspicuous writing. Unless the circumstances indicate otherwise, expressions like as is or with all faults exclude all implied warranties, and a buyer who examined the goods as fully as it wanted, or refused to, has no implied warranty for defects an examination ought to have revealed (MCL 440.2316(2)-(3)). Whether a disclaimer is conspicuous is for the judge. In Davis v. LaFontaine Motors, Inc., 271 Mich. App. 68, 76-77 (2006), the Court of Appeals found a disclaimer conspicuous where it sat under a capitalized WARRANTY DISCLAIMER heading that a capitalized cross-reference on the first page pointed to.
A contract may also change the remedy. Under MCL 440.2719, the agreement may limit the buyer to return of the goods and repayment of the price, or to repair and replacement, and a remedy expressly agreed to be exclusive is the sole remedy. If an exclusive or limited remedy fails of its essential purpose, remedy may be had under the Code. Consequential damages may be limited or excluded unless that is unconscionable, and a limitation where the loss is commercial is not prima facie unconscionable. In Severn v. Sperry Corp., 212 Mich. App. 406, 414-415 (1995), the seller could not fix a defective grinder, and the Court of Appeals found enough evidence that the repair-and-replace warranty failed of its essential purpose, opening the Code’s standard warranty remedies.
Defenses and answers I look at in a commercial contract or UCC case
No notice, or late notice. This is the defense I check first when I act for a seller. In American Bumper & Manufacturing Co. v. Transtechnology Corp., 252 Mich. App. at 345-348, a commercial buyer’s notice was held inadequate because it did not serve the purposes of the notice rule and the buyer’s conduct did not meet the Code’s standard of commercial good faith, and the bar reached its indemnification claims too. When I act for a buyer, the notice goes out early and in writing.
The deadline. A claim filed after the four-year period, or a shorter period in the original agreement, is subject to dismissal. The statute of limitations and the statute of frauds are affirmative defenses that must be stated in the responsive pleading under MCR 2.111(F)(3), and a motion under MCR 2.116(C)(7) can rest on either one.
The disclaimer, the limited remedy or a term that is not in the contract. I check whether the disclaimer meets the Code’s wording rules, whether it survived the battle of the forms, and whether a limited remedy failed of its essential purpose. The party relying on an indemnity clause or a damages cap has to show it became part of the agreement.
A tort theory that goes around the Code. Where a plaintiff seeks to recover economic loss caused by a defective product purchased for commercial purposes, the exclusive remedy is the UCC, including its statute of limitations (Neibarger, 439 Mich. at 527-528).
Damages, remedies and consequences
A buyer’s remedies. When the seller fails to deliver or repudiates, or the buyer rightfully rejects or justifiably revokes, the buyer may cancel, recover the price paid, and either cover or recover damages for nondelivery (MCL 440.2711(1)). A buyer that covers with a reasonable substitute purchase recovers the added cost plus incidental or consequential damages, less expenses saved (MCL 440.2712). For goods the buyer kept, warranty damages are the difference at the time and place of acceptance between the value of the goods accepted and their value as warranted (MCL 440.2714(2)). Consequential damages include loss from needs the seller had reason to know of that could not reasonably be prevented by cover (MCL 440.2715(2)).
A seller’s remedies. If the buyer wrongfully rejects or revokes, fails to make a payment due on or before delivery, or repudiates, the seller may withhold delivery, resell and recover damages, recover damages for nonacceptance or in a proper case the price, or cancel (MCL 440.2703). A good-faith, commercially reasonable resale lets the seller recover the shortfall plus incidental damages (MCL 440.2706(1)). Without resale, the measure is the market-price difference or, if that is inadequate, the profit including reasonable overhead (MCL 440.2708(1)-(2)). A small claim can cost more to litigate than it could recover, so I tell clients early what a claim could recover and what it could cost.
The four-year clock, and why notice is a separate deadline
An action for breach of any contract for sale must be commenced within 4 years after the cause of action accrued. The agreement may reduce the period to not less than 1 year but may not extend it. The claim accrues when the breach occurs, whether or not the aggrieved party knew of it, and a warranty breach occurs when tender of delivery is made. The exception is a warranty that explicitly extends to future performance, where discovery of the breach must await that performance (MCL 440.2725(1)-(2)).
In Baker v. DEC International, 458 Mich. 247 (1998), the Michigan Supreme Court held that when the seller is obligated to install the goods, tender of delivery does not occur until installation is completed. The notice rule is a separate clock: a buyer can be inside four years and still be barred because it did not give notice in time. I calendar both, shorter one first.
Repossession, redemption and personal guaranties
After default, a secured party may take possession of the collateral, by judicial process or without it if it proceeds without breach of the peace (MCL 440.9609(1)-(2)). In Magley v. M & W Inc., 325 Mich. App. 307, 316-317 (2018), the Court of Appeals explained that repossessing property in which a creditor has no security interest can be conversion, that a repossession agent is not shielded by acting for the lender, and that the incidental taking of other property can support a conversion claim.
If the lender sells, it must send a reasonable authenticated notification of disposition to the debtor and any secondary obligor, and, for collateral other than consumer goods, to the other claimants and lienholders the statute lists (MCL 440.9611(2)-(3)). A debtor may redeem by tendering fulfillment of all obligations secured by the collateral plus the reasonable expenses and attorney fees the statute describes, at any time before the secured party has collected the collateral, disposed of it or contracted to dispose of it, or accepted it in satisfaction (MCL 440.9623).
Some equipment loans carry a personal guaranty. In Bandit Industries, Inc. v. Hobbs International, Inc., 463 Mich. 504, 512 (2001), the Michigan Supreme Court said that assuming another’s debt is a substantial undertaking and courts will not assume it absent a clearly expressed intention. A fax from a company president giving assurance of payment was not enough to create a personal guaranty. The words decide what a guarantor owes, so I read them first, whichever side I represent.
How I handle a commercial contract or UCC case
- Collect every form and fix the dates. I gather the quote, purchase order, acknowledgment, invoice and warranty, build a timeline, and calendar the shortest plausible deadline.
- Protect the goods and the proof. I want photographs, serial numbers, test data and an independent inspection when the defect is technical. For a lender, I want the loan documents, default history and an inventory of what was taken.
- Send or answer the notice. A notice of breach, rejection or revocation, a written demand for adequate assurance and an offer to cure each have rules on timing and content. If you are accused, I review the notice against the statute.
- File, serve and answer. A defendant served in Michigan has 21 days to serve and file an answer or take other action permitted by the rules, and 28 days if service is made outside Michigan or by registered mail (MCR 2.108(A)(1)-(2)). The answer has to state the affirmative defenses. Bring me the summons the day you get it.
- Discovery, motions and trial. A motion under MCR 2.116(C) can rest on the statute of limitations or the statute of frauds under (C)(7), failure to state a claim under (C)(8), or no genuine issue of material fact under (C)(10), except as to the amount of damages. If the case does not settle, I am prepared to try it.
Ways a commercial contract or UCC dispute may end without a trial
Whether any of these is available depends on the facts, the documents and the other side. None is automatic.
Negotiated settlement, cure or redemption. Most commercial disputes that resolve do so by agreement, often after the key documents are exchanged, and a seller with time to cure or a borrower who redeems under MCL 440.9623 can end a dispute early. The paper matters as much as the number.
Summary disposition, arbitration or an offer of judgment. If the notice rule, the limitation period, the statute of frauds or the unambiguous contract answers the question, a judge can decide it on motion under MCR 2.116. If the agreement sends disputes to arbitration or to a particular court, the case may be resolved there. Until 28 days before trial, a party may serve a written offer to stipulate to a judgment under MCR 2.405(B), which can end the case or shift actual costs.
What I need from you
Bring the quote, purchase order, acknowledgment, invoice and any terms that came with them, in the order they were sent. Bring the emails and texts, delivery and inspection records, photographs, repair tickets and payment records. If you financed equipment, bring the loan agreement, any guaranty and every default or repossession notice. If you are the one being sued, bring the summons and complaint and note the date and manner of service. Do not use, resell or scrap rejected goods. Do not delete messages or alter documents. Do not sign a release or payment plan before I have read it against the contract. Do not take equipment back yourself.
Where your Kent County commercial contract and UCC case will be heard
I represent clients in Grand Rapids, Kentwood, Grandville, Wyoming and across Kent County. Under MCL 600.8301(1), the district court has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions when the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000. Kent County district courts include the 61st District Court in Grand Rapids, the 59th in Walker and Grandville, the 62A in Wyoming, the 62B in Kentwood and the 63rd for Rockford, Lowell, Cedar Springs, East Grand Rapids and the surrounding townships. Larger claims are filed in the Kent County Circuit Court, the 17th Judicial Circuit. A dispute between business enterprises, or between a business and its suppliers, owners, managers or similar parties, can qualify as a business or commercial dispute under MCL 600.8031, which defines the cases eligible for a business court docket.
Why people hire me for a Michigan commercial contract and UCC matter
You work directly with me, the lawyer handling your case. I give you the strengths and weaknesses of the case straight, including what it could cost you and what it could recover, and I lay out the strongest arguments the other side has. I build the case the facts support, and then we decide together how to proceed.
Fees depend on the type of case, its complexity and whether it is likely to go to trial. I explain my fee arrangement at the consultation, before you decide whether to hire me.
Questions I hear from people in a commercial contract or UCC dispute in Michigan
The seller sold me business equipment as is. Does that end any warranty claim in Michigan?
It usually ends the implied warranties, but not necessarily everything. Under MCL 440.2316(3)(a), words like “as is” or “with all faults” exclude all implied warranties unless the circumstances indicate otherwise. Without such words, a disclaimer of merchantability must mention merchantability and, in a writing, be conspicuous, and a disclaimer of fitness for a particular purpose must be in a conspicuous writing. Express promises are read together with the disclaimer (MCL 440.2316(1)).
When does the 4-year deadline start on a claim for defective goods, and does it still apply if the deal included installation or services?
Under MCL 440.2725 you have 4 years, and a breach of warranty occurs when the seller tenders delivery, even if you did not know of the defect. The exception is a warranty that explicitly extends to future performance of the goods. Where the seller had to install the goods, the Michigan Supreme Court held in Baker v DEC that tender was not complete until installation. A mixed goods and services deal falls under the UCC when the sale of goods is the predominant purpose (Neibarger).
My sales contract limits me to repair or replacement and bars lost profits. Is that enforceable in Michigan?
Often yes between businesses, within limits. MCL 440.2719 lets a contract limit the buyer to repair or replacement and exclude consequential damages unless the exclusion is unconscionable, and a limit on commercial loss is not prima facie unconscionable. If the limited remedy fails of its essential purpose, remedies under the Code are available. In Severn v Sperry, a seller that could not fix a defective grinder within a reasonable time could not rely on its limited warranty.
My supplier says it may not deliver the goods I ordered. What can I do before and after a breach?
If you have reasonable grounds for insecurity, MCL 440.2609 lets you demand adequate assurance in writing and, if commercially reasonable, suspend your own performance. Failing to give adequate assurance within a reasonable time, not over 30 days, is a repudiation. After a failure to deliver or repudiation, you can cancel and either cover with substitute goods and recover the added cost, or recover the market-price difference (MCL 440.2711 to 440.2713).
Will a Michigan court enforce a liquidated damages clause in my contract?
Courts sustain a liquidated damages clause if the amount is reasonable in relation to the possible injury and is not unconscionable or excessive, according to UAW-GM Human Resource Center v KSL Recreation. Whether a clause is a valid liquidated amount or an unenforceable penalty is a question of law for the judge, so the numbers and the nature of the harm matter.
Can I sue for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing in Michigan?
Michigan does not recognize an independent tort claim for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, according to Ulrich v Federal Land Bank, and the Court of Appeals has also declined to recognize it as a stand-alone contract claim. In Kircher v Boyne USA, the Michigan Supreme Court held in 2025 that the implied covenant is not an independent cause of action and does not override express contract terms. Your remedy is usually a breach of contract claim based on the contract’s actual terms. A tort claim exists only where there is a legal duty that arises apart from the contract promise.
What does it mean to sign a personal guaranty for a business loan in Michigan?
A guarantor’s liability depends on an independent collateral agreement to pay the obligation if the primary borrower fails, according to Comerica Bank v Cohen. The Court of Appeals described a guaranty, like a surety contract, as a special kind of contract whose undertaking receives strict interpretation, and also said guaranty contracts are construed like other contracts. That cuts both ways: the exact wording decides what you owe.
Can a lender take my business equipment without going to court if I default?
Often yes. After default, MCL 440.9609 lets a secured party take possession of collateral by judicial process or, without a court, if it proceeds without breach of the peace. The statute does not define breach of the peace, and the debtor cannot waive that duty in the loan documents (MCL 440.9602). You can redeem until the lender has sold or contracted to sell the collateral or accepted it in satisfaction, by paying everything it secures plus the lender’s reasonable expenses (MCL 440.9623).
Related Michigan pages
- Grand Rapids Business Litigation Attorney
- Grand Rapids Commercial Lease Dispute Attorney
- Grand Rapids Tortious Interference Attorney
- Grand Rapids LLC Member and Shareholder Dispute Attorney
- Grand Rapids Breach of Contract Attorney
- Business contracts
- contract damages and remedies
I handle commercial contract and UCC disputes in Michigan for either side. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.