
Charged with murder or manslaughter in Michigan? How the degrees, the mental state and the sentence work
I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. This page covers murder, manslaughter and related homicide charges in Michigan from the defense side: how the degrees differ, what the prosecutor has to prove about the defendant’s state of mind, how a person can be charged when someone else did the killing, what the sentences are, including for defendants under 21, and how bond works. I do not promise outcomes.
The short answer. What separates the homicide charges is mostly the defendant’s state of mind. First-degree murder requires planning or one of a short list of circumstances, second-degree murder is every other murder, and manslaughter is a killing without malice. First-degree murder carries mandatory life without parole for an adult, but Michigan courts have changed that rule for defendants who were under 21 when the offense happened. A person charged with murder is not entitled to bond as of right. Nothing here predicts how your case will end.
Families usually call me after an arrest or a first appearance, when the charge says murder and nobody has explained what it means. Many homicide cases turn on a narrow question: the defendant’s state of mind, the timing, or whether the facts support a lesser charge. The sentencing law for young defendants also moved quickly in 2025 and 2026, so I read the current decisions and check the status of a ruling before I advise anyone.
The homicide charges at a glance
The table gives the usual charges and the statutory penalty for an adult. The sections below explain the exceptions.
| Charge | What it requires | Statutory penalty for an adult | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-degree murder | A willful, deliberate and premeditated killing, including by poison or lying in wait; a murder during a listed felony; or the murder of a peace officer or corrections officer on duty | Life without eligibility for parole | MCL 750.316(1) |
| Second-degree murder | Every other murder: a death caused by the defendant with malice and without justification or excuse | Life or any term of years | MCL 750.317 |
| Manslaughter | A killing without malice: voluntary, in the heat of passion on adequate provocation; or involuntary, an unintended killing through gross negligence or with an intent to injure | Up to 15 years, a fine of up to $7,500, or both | MCL 750.321 |
| Firearm pointed intentionally, without malice, that discharges and kills | Wounding or injuring a person by discharging a firearm intentionally aimed at that person, without malice, where the injuries cause death | The statute makes it manslaughter | MCL 750.329 |
| Delivery of a controlled substance causing death | Delivering a schedule 1 or 2 controlled substance, other than marihuana, that is consumed and causes a death | Life or any term of years | MCL 750.317a |
| Felony-firearm, added to a homicide count | Carrying or possessing a firearm while committing or attempting a felony | 2 years for a first offense, served first and consecutively, with no parole or probation during that term | MCL 750.227b |
Malice and the three states of mind
Murder is the unlawful killing of one person by another with malice. The elements of second-degree murder are a death, caused by an act of the defendant, with malice, and without justification or excuse. Malice means an intent to kill, an intent to cause great bodily harm, or an intent to do an act in wanton and willful disregard of the likelihood that its natural tendency is to cause death or great bodily harm. People v. Goecke, 457 Mich. 442, 463 to 464 (1998). The model jury instruction puts the third state of mind in plainer words: the defendant knowingly created a very high risk of death or great bodily harm, knowing that death or such harm would be the likely result. M Crim JI 16.5.
Malice is also what separates murder from manslaughter. The Michigan Supreme Court has said that the only element distinguishing the two is malice. People v. Mendoza, 468 Mich. 527, 540 (2003). In a murder trial the jury decides the degree in its verdict. MCL 750.318. That is why so much defense work is aimed at the mental-state question, and why I look at lesser offenses from the first day.
First-degree murder: premeditation and deliberation
The statute makes first-degree murder of “any other willful, deliberate, and premeditated killing,” along with murder by poison or lying in wait. MCL 750.316(1)(a). The jury instruction asks the jury to find that the intent to kill was thought out beforehand and that the killing was deliberate, meaning the defendant considered the pros and cons and chose the action. It requires real and substantial reflection for long enough to give a reasonable person a chance to think twice, says the law does not set how much time is needed, and says the killing cannot be the result of a sudden impulse without thought or reflection. M Crim JI 16.1. Lying in wait means the defendant hid, planning to take another person by surprise. M Crim JI 16.2.
In People v. Oros the Court explained that premeditation and deliberation may be shown by an interval between the first homicidal thought and the act that would let a reasonable person take a “second look.” It noted that the minimum time is incapable of exact determination, that it is often said to require only a “brief moment of thought” or a “matter of seconds,” and that the fact-finder decides whether the time was enough. The question on review is whether the evidence fairly supports an inference of premeditation and deliberation. People v. Oros, 502 Mich. 229, 242 to 243 (2018). So there is no safe number of seconds. The defense is built from the circumstances: whether there was a real interval, what happened in it, and whether the evidence points to a sudden impulse.
Felony murder
A murder committed in the perpetration of, or an attempt to perpetrate, a listed felony is first-degree murder. The list includes arson, criminal sexual conduct in the first, second or third degree, a major controlled substance offense, robbery, carjacking, home invasion, larceny of any kind, extortion and kidnapping, among others. MCL 750.316(1)(b).
Malice is still required. In People v. Aaron the Court abolished the rule that defined malice as the intent to commit the underlying felony and wrote that it was no longer acceptable to equate that intent with an intent to kill, an intent to do great bodily harm, or wanton and willful disregard of the likelihood of death or great bodily harm. People v. Aaron, 409 Mich. 672, 727 to 728 (1980). The model instruction accordingly requires one of the three states of mind and also that the defendant was committing, attempting, or helping someone else commit the felony when the act causing death was done. M Crim JI 16.4. In a felony-murder case I look first at the felony. If it fails, the first-degree theory fails with it.
Second-degree murder
Second-degree murder covers “all other kinds of murder,” punishable by life or any term of years in the court’s discretion. MCL 750.317. No plan is required. It is not a specific-intent crime, and the model instruction’s use note says so. M Crim JI 16.5. The Court has also stated that second-degree murder is a general-intent crime to which voluntary intoxication is not an available defense. Goecke, 457 Mich. at 464.
Goecke shows how the third state of mind works in a driving case. The Court held that a district court abused its discretion by refusing to bind over a second-degree murder charge against a defendant who, the evidence suggested, drove at high speed through a red light after drinking and after a near collision. The question was wanton and willful disregard of the likelihood of death or great bodily harm. 457 Mich. at 462 to 464, 469 to 470.
Voluntary and involuntary manslaughter
Voluntary manslaughter. The Court’s formulation, drawn from older cases, is that the killing, though intentional, is committed under the influence of passion or heat of blood produced by an adequate or reasonable provocation, before a reasonable time has passed for the blood to cool, and is the result of temporary excitement rather than wickedness of heart. To show it, one must show that the defendant killed in the heat of passion, that adequate provocation caused the passion, and that no time passed in which a reasonable person could have controlled the passion. Mendoza, 468 Mich. at 534 to 535. The element that disappears is malice, which provocation and heat of passion negate. Id. at 540. The model instruction for voluntary manslaughter as a lesser offense is M Crim JI 16.9. I develop the provocation evidence before trial, including what happened in the minutes before the killing.
Involuntary manslaughter. This is the catch-all for an unintended killing that is not murder, not voluntary manslaughter, and not justified or excused. If the homicide was committed with malice it is murder, and if it was committed with a lesser mental state of gross negligence or an intent to injure, and not malice, it is only involuntary manslaughter. People v. Holtschlag, 471 Mich. 1, 21 to 22 (2004). The instruction offers two routes: gross negligence, or an unlawful act done with an intent to injure, such as an assault and battery. M Crim JI 16.10. Gross negligence has its own definition in M Crim JI 16.18. A separate statute makes it manslaughter when a person intentionally, but without malice, aims a firearm at someone and the discharge causes death. MCL 750.329(1).
Causation and justification
A murder charge requires proof that the defendant’s act caused the death and that the killing was without justification or excuse. Goecke, 457 Mich. at 463 to 464. The model instructions include M Crim JI 16.15, which is designed for cases where there is an issue whether the defendant’s act caused the death or whether an intervening cause did, and M Crim JI 16.16, which applies where a physically susceptible victim or improper medical treatment is involved. M Crim JI 16.15 and 16.16, use notes. Self-defense and defense of others are justifications, and in many homicide cases they are the main issue.
Charged when someone else did the killing
A person who procures, counsels, aids or abets an offense may be prosecuted and punished as if he or she had directly committed it. MCL 767.39. In People v. Robinson, the Court held that a defendant must possess the criminal intent to aid, abet, procure or counsel the commission of an offense, and is liable for the offenses the defendant specifically intends to aid or abet, or has knowledge of, as well as the crimes that are the natural and probable consequences of the offense intended. The defendant there joined an assault in which a codefendant shot and killed the victim, and the Court reinstated a second-degree murder conviction on both theories. People v. Robinson, 475 Mich. 1, 14 to 15 (2006).
For felony murder the instruction requires that the defendant was committing, or helping someone else commit, the felony, and “help” means acts or encouragement before or during the crime that aid it, with intent that the felony be committed. M Crim JI 16.4(6). A case against a passenger, a driver or a lookout rests on what that person did and what he or she intended or knew, which is where I look for gaps.
A death after drug use
Michigan has a separate felony for delivering a schedule 1 or 2 controlled substance, other than marihuana, in violation of MCL 333.7401 when the substance is consumed by that person or anyone else and causes a death. It is punishable by life or any term of years. MCL 750.317a. In People v. Plunkett the Court held it is a general-intent crime that does not require an intent that death occur, and that the intent required is the same general intent required to deliver the substance. People v. Plunkett, 485 Mich. 50, 60 (2010). The causation proof, including toxicology and whether another substance contributed, is where these cases are tested. A major controlled substance offense is also a listed felony for first-degree felony murder. MCL 750.316(1)(b), (4)(c).
Bond and the early hearings
Bond. The Michigan Constitution makes persons bailable before conviction, with exceptions. Bail may be denied to a person indicted for, or arraigned on a warrant charging, murder, when the proof is evident or the presumption great. If bail is denied, trial must begin within 90 days or the court must set bail, unless the delay is attributable to the defense. Const 1963, art 1, § 15. The court rule says the same and adds a custody hearing, which either side may request, where the defendant may be present with a lawyer, call witnesses and cross-examine. MCR 6.106(B), (G). If the court does not make the required findings, the defendant must be released under the ordinary rules. MCR 6.106(G)(2)(b). When bond is set, the rule lists factors that include the seriousness of the offense, the probability of conviction and the likely sentence, community ties, and the defendant’s record. MCR 6.106(F)(1). A release decision can be reviewed by motion, for abuse of discretion. MCR 6.106(H). I ask for the custody hearing early.
Preliminary examination. A felony begins in district court, and a defendant must be bound over for trial if the court finds probable cause to believe that an offense outside the district court’s jurisdiction was committed and that the defendant committed it. The magistrate is not to discharge the accused where the evidence conflicts or raises a reasonable doubt, because that is the jury’s province. Goecke, 457 Mich. at 469 to 470. The examination is the first chance to hear the prosecution’s witnesses under oath, and I use it to test malice, premeditation, the predicate felony and the cause of death. The case is then bound over to circuit court. MCL 766.13.
Limitations periods
There is no limitations period for murder. An indictment for murder, conspiracy to commit murder or solicitation to commit murder may be found and filed at any time. MCL 767.24(1)(a). For manslaughter, the statute allows 10 years after the offense, or, if the offense was reported to police within a year and the offender was unknown, 10 years after the offender is identified. MCL 767.24(6). The manslaughter periods are not new. The statute as amended by 2011 PA 203 allowed 10 years after the offense, and 2012 PA 363, effective March 28, 2013, added the 10 years after the offender is identified, if the offense was reported to police within a year. For an older manslaughter offense I check which version of the statute governed on the offense date.
Sentences for adults
For a person who was 21 or older at the time of the offense, first-degree murder carries life without eligibility for parole. MCL 750.316(1). A prisoner serving life for first-degree murder is not eligible for parole. MCL 791.234(6)(a). In People v. Langston, discussed below, the Court left undisturbed People v. Hall, 396 Mich. 650 (1976), which held that mandatory life without parole for felony murder is not cruel or unusual punishment, to the extent it applies to a defendant who was at least 21 at the time of the offense and is not within the class entitled to relief under that opinion. People v. Langston, No. 163968 (Mich. July 28, 2026).
Second-degree murder is punishable by life or any term of years. MCL 750.317. A prisoner serving a parolable life sentence is subject to the parole board’s jurisdiction after serving 15 calendar years of a sentence for a crime committed on or after October 1, 1992. MCL 791.234(7)(a). Manslaughter carries up to 15 years. MCL 750.321. A felony-firearm count adds 2 years for a first offense, served before and consecutively with the sentence for the felony. MCL 750.227b.
Defendants who were under 21
Under 18. For an offense committed before the eighteenth birthday, the prosecutor may move for life without parole on a first-degree murder conviction and on a few other listed offenses. The motion is due within 21 days after conviction. If it is not filed in time, the court must impose a term of years. If it is filed, the court holds a hearing as part of sentencing, considers the factors in Miller v. Alabama, and states on the record the aggravating and mitigating circumstances and its reasons. If the court does not impose life without parole, the maximum must be at least 60 years and the minimum no less than 25 and no more than 40 years, with credit for time served but no good-time or similar credits. MCL 769.25(2) to (4), (6), (7), (9), (10). In People v. Taylor (2022), the Court held that the prosecutor, as the moving party, bears the burden of proof at a Miller hearing, that the burden is to rebut a presumption that the juvenile is not deserving of life without parole, and that if the prosecutor cannot do so by clear and convincing evidence the court must impose a term of years. People v. Taylor, 510 Mich. 112 (2022). Miller held that mandatory life without parole for those under 18 at the time of their crimes violates the Eighth Amendment. 567 U.S. 460, 465 (2012).
Older sentences. Montgomery held that Miller announced a substantive rule of constitutional law. Montgomery v. Louisiana, 577 U.S. 190 (2016). For a case that was final on or before June 24, 2012, MCL 769.25a sets a resentencing process that follows MCL 769.25 where the prosecutor seeks life without parole, and without a motion it sets a maximum of 60 years and a minimum of 25 to 40 years. MCL 769.25a(1), (4).
Eighteen, 19 and 20. In People v. Parks the Michigan Supreme Court held that mandatory life without parole for 18-year-olds convicted of first-degree murder violates the state constitution’s ban on cruel or unusual punishment, and that these defendants are entitled to the protections in the individualized sentencing procedure of MCL 769.25. People v. Parks, 510 Mich. 225 (2022). On April 10, 2025, in People v. Taylor and People v. Czarnecki, the Court extended Parks to defendants who were 19 or 20 at the time of the offense and held that the rule applies retroactively on collateral review. A judge can still sentence a 19- or 20-year-old to life without parole, but only after the MCL 769.25 or 769.25a procedure. Taylor, No. 166428; Czarnecki, No. 166654. Days earlier, on April 1, 2025, in People v. Poole, a unanimous Court held that Parks announced a substantive rule that applies retroactively. People v. Poole, No. 166813 (Mich. Apr. 1, 2025).
Second-degree murder for young defendants. In People v. Stovall the Court held that a parolable life sentence for a juvenile convicted of second-degree murder is cruel or unusual under the state constitution. People v. Stovall, 510 Mich. 301 (2022). On July 30, 2026, in People v. Eads, six justices joined an opinion, and one justice dissented, holding that a sentence of 50 to 75 years for second-degree murder committed by a youthful offender, defined in the opinion as someone under 21, violates the prohibition on cruel or unusual punishment and applies retroactively on collateral review. People v. Eads, No. 168205 (Mich. July 30, 2026).
Older felony-murder convictions. On July 28, 2026, in People v. Langston, an opinion by Justice Bolden, joined by three other justices, held that mandatory life without parole for a pre-Aaron felony-murder conviction is cruel or unusual punishment under the state constitution if two conditions are met. The defendant must first show that the jury was not instructed on malice as Aaron defined it. The burden then shifts to the prosecutor to prove beyond a reasonable doubt, from the trial evidence, that a properly instructed jury would have found that malice. If the prosecutor cannot, the remedy is to strike the no-parole aspect of the sentence. The Chief Justice concurred in part and dissented in part, disagreeing with the remedy, Justice Zahra dissented, and Justice Thomas did not participate. People v. Langston, No. 163968 (Mich. July 28, 2026).
These decisions are recent, and a later order can change how a decision applies. I check the Supreme Court’s docket for the status of any decision before I rely on it in a client’s case.
How I handle a homicide case
- Stop the statements. I tell the client and the family not to discuss the case with police, jail callers or anyone else, and I find out what has already been said, recorded or texted.
- Pin down the theory. I read the complaint to see the degree charged, any felony predicate, whether the client is charged as the actor or an aider, and which lesser offenses the facts could support.
- Fight for release. I request the custody hearing and prepare the community, employment and family evidence the court rule lists.
- Use the preliminary examination. I cross-examine the prosecution’s witnesses on malice, timing, identification and the cause of death, and I move to reduce or dismiss counts that the testimony does not support.
- Work the forensic proof. I review the autopsy, toxicology, scene, phone and video evidence, and I consult independent forensic professionals where the cause of death or the sequence of events is disputed.
- Plan for sentencing from the start. I check the client’s age at the time of the offense, because it can change the sentencing procedure and the sentence range, and I explain what each offer on the table means.
Ways a homicide case may end without a trial
None of these is automatic. Each depends on the facts, the evidence, the prosecutor and the court.
Dismissal or a reduced charge at the preliminary examination. If the testimony does not establish probable cause on a count or a degree, the court may decline to bind it over, though the standard is low, and the prosecutor can ask the circuit court to review a refusal to bind over. Goecke, 457 Mich. 442.
A negotiated plea to a lesser offense. A plea to second-degree murder, manslaughter or another charge can change the exposure a great deal. I explain the sentence range, parole rules and age-based protections before the client decides.
Dismissal by the prosecutor. A prosecutor may dismiss after a review of the evidence or a forensic finding. I do not count on it.
What I need from you
Bring the complaint or warrant, the bond or custody order, every hearing notice and the name of the court and judge. Write down the client’s date of birth and the date of the offense, who was present, who was contacted afterward, and every conversation with police or investigators, with dates. Gather names of people who can speak to the client’s work, family and community ties. Preserve phones, messages, photographs and video, and do not delete anything. Do not discuss the case on jail calls or social media, and call me before anyone signs a statement or a waiver.
Where your Kent County homicide case will be heard
I represent clients charged in Grand Rapids, Kentwood, Grandville, Wyoming and across Kent County. A homicide charge begins in district court with arraignment and a preliminary examination. In Kent County that is the 61st District Court (the city of Grand Rapids), the 59th (the cities of Walker and Grandville), the 62A (the city of Wyoming), the 62B (the city of Kentwood) or the 63rd (the rest of Kent County). MCL 600.8130; MCL 600.8128a. If probable cause is found, the case is bound over to the Kent County Circuit Court, which is the 17th Judicial Circuit. MCL 766.13; MCL 600.518.
Why people hire me for a Michigan murder or homicide case
You work directly with me, the lawyer handling your case. I tell you where the law favors you and where it does not, and I explain what each offer means before you answer it. I tell you plainly when the law is unsettled. I do not promise outcomes. I build the case the facts support, and then we decide together how to proceed.
Fees depend on the charge, the complexity of the case and whether it is likely to go to trial. I explain my fee arrangement at the consultation, before you decide whether to hire me.
Questions I hear from people charged with murder or manslaughter in Kent County
What is the difference between first-degree murder, second-degree murder and manslaughter in Michigan?
The difference is the mental state. First-degree murder is a killing that is premeditated and deliberate, or one committed during a listed felony or against a peace officer or corrections officer. Second-degree murder is every other murder: a killing with malice but without planning. Manslaughter is a killing without malice. First-degree carries mandatory life without parole for people who were 21 or older at the time of the offense (younger defendants get an individualized sentencing hearing); second-degree carries life or any term of years; manslaughter carries up to 15 years.
What do “premeditated” and “deliberate” mean? How fast can a decision to kill count as first-degree murder?
Premeditation means thinking about the killing beforehand. Deliberation means measuring and evaluating the major facets of the choice. There has to be enough time between the intent to kill and the act for a reasonable person to take a second look, but Michigan law sets no minimum number of seconds or minutes. Jurors may infer both from the circumstances.
What is felony murder in Michigan, and do I have to intend to kill for it?
Felony murder is a murder committed during, or in an attempt to commit, a listed felony such as robbery, home invasion, carjacking or arson. Michigan does not treat the intent to commit the felony as enough. The prosecutor must still prove malice: an intent to kill, an intent to cause great bodily harm, or a knowing, wanton and willful disregard of the likelihood that death or great bodily harm would result.
When can a murder charge be reduced to voluntary manslaughter because of anger or provocation?
When the defendant killed in the heat of passion caused by something that would make a reasonable person act rashly, and acted before a reasonable time had passed to calm down. Provocation does not excuse the killing. It negates malice, which is what makes the offense manslaughter instead of murder. Whether the facts qualify is usually decided by the jury.
Can I be charged with murder if someone else did the killing?
Yes. Under MCL 767.39 a person who helps in committing a crime is punished as if he or she directly committed it. For murder, the prosecutor must prove that the crime was committed, that the person did something to assist, and that the person intended the crime, knew the other person intended it, or the crime was a natural and probable consequence of the crime the person intended to help. The assistance must be something the person actually did before or during the crime.
I was 18, 19 or 20 when the offense happened. Does first-degree murder still mean mandatory life without parole?
No. In People v Parks (2022) the Michigan Supreme Court held mandatory life without parole unconstitutional for 18-year-olds convicted of first-degree murder, and in People v Taylor (Apr. 10, 2025) it extended that rule to 19- and 20-year-olds. These defendants receive the individualized sentencing process of MCL 769.25. Life without parole is possible only if the prosecutor seeks it and wins a hearing; otherwise a term of years is required.
Can I get a bond on a murder charge in Michigan?
Not as of right. The Michigan Constitution allows bail to be denied to a person indicted for, or arraigned on a warrant charging, murder when the proof is evident or the presumption great. If bail is denied, trial must begin within 90 days or the court must schedule a bail hearing and set bail unless the defense caused the delay.
Related Michigan pages
- Grand Rapids Criminal Defense Lawyer
- Self-defense
- Grand Rapids Assault Lawyer
- Grand Rapids Felony Lawyer
- Felony firearm charges
- Criminal appeals
I defend people charged with murder, manslaughter and other homicide offenses, from the first arraignment through sentencing. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.