Skip to content

Operating Agreements and LLC Management · Grand Rapids and Kent County

Grand Rapids Operating Agreement and LLC Management Lawyer

I advise and represent members and managers in Michigan LLC disputes over operating agreements, authority, distributions, records and exits.

A tablet showing a financial chart with a pen resting on it beside a laptop

Operating agreements and managing a Michigan LLC: who decides, who is paid and who can leave

I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids business lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. This page explains how a Michigan limited liability company is run once it exists: what an operating agreement is and what it can change, who has authority to bind the company, how managers are chosen and removed, how distributions work, and what happens when a member wants out or a creditor comes after an owner. I advise and represent members, managers and the company itself, and I take whichever side the facts put my client on. I do not promise outcomes.

The short answer. The Michigan LLC Act supplies default rules, and the operating agreement changes most of them. Unless the articles say the company is managed by managers, the members manage it. MCL 450.4401. If the agreement is silent on voting, each member has one vote and a majority in interest approves most matters. MCL 450.4502(1), (8). If it is silent on distributions, they are shared in equal shares among the members. MCL 450.4303(1)(b). Those defaults surprise people who assumed that voting and profits followed their capital, so I read the agreement first.

The statute defines an operating agreement as a written agreement among all the members, or by the sole member, about the affairs of the company and the conduct of its business, and it includes any provision of the articles of organization on those subjects. MCL 450.4102(2)(r). I often see an LLC with a template agreement signed at formation and never read again, or with no written agreement at all. Where the agreement is silent, the statutory defaults fill the gap.

I look at the articles, the operating agreement and any amendments, the company’s records, and the way the owners actually behaved. Then I tell you who has authority, what the agreement lets you do, and what the other side can and cannot do. Whether you are the manager who is being accused of overreaching, the member who has been cut out, or the company that needs its records in order, the work starts with the same documents.

Operating agreement and LLC management issues at a glance

The table sets out the issues I handle most often, what has to be shown, and the rule that matters.

Issue What must be shown Time limit or key rule Authority
Who manages the company Whether the articles state that the business is managed by managers If they do not, the members manage and are treated as managers with the duties and liabilities of managers MCL 450.4401
Voting What the operating agreement provides Default is one vote per member and a majority in interest of members entitled to vote. Dissolution, merger, conversion and amending the articles belong to the members, not the managers MCL 450.4502(1), (4), (8)
Removing a manager A vote of the members With or without cause unless the agreement says only for cause. A removal for cause requires a meeting called for that purpose, advance notice of the allegations and a chance to be heard MCL 450.4403(2), (3)
Authority to bind the company An act of a manager that apparently carries on the business in the usual way Binds the company unless the manager lacked authority and the other person actually knew it, or the articles or the Act establish it MCL 450.4406
Manager duty claim Failure to act in good faith, with ordinary prudent care, in a manner reasonably believed to be in the “best interests of the limited liability company” 3 years after accrual or 2 years after discovery, whichever is first MCL 450.4404(1), (6)
Unlawful distribution A distribution that leaves the company unable to pay debts as they come due, or with assets below liabilities plus certain preferences Proceeding barred unless started within 2 years after the effect of the distribution is measured MCL 450.4307(1); MCL 450.4308
Member oppression Acts of managers or members in control that are illegal, fraudulent, or willfully unfair and oppressive to the company or the member Damages claim within 3 years after accrual or 2 years after discovery, whichever is first MCL 450.4515(1), (2)
Records request Reasonable written request during ordinary business hours A member may inspect and copy the records the company must keep, at the member’s expense MCL 450.4503(3); MCL 450.4213
Court dissolution Application by or for a member showing the company is unable to carry on business in conformity with the articles or operating agreements Circuit court for the county of the registered office MCL 450.4802

Member-managed or manager-managed

The articles of organization decide this. Unless they state that the business is to be managed by or under the authority of managers, the members manage the company, subject to anything the operating agreement says to restrict or enlarge their management rights. In a member-managed company the members are treated as managers for purposes of the Act, including the rule on agency authority, and they carry the duties, liabilities, limits on liability and indemnification rights of managers. MCL 450.4401.

If the articles delegate management to managers, the articles themselves are notice to third parties that managers, not members, have agency authority. The agreement may set qualifications for managers, including a requirement that they be members, and the number of managers is fixed under the agreement. MCL 450.4402. This is the first thing I check in an authority dispute.

Authority, voting and removal

A manager is an agent of the company for the purpose of its business. An act of a manager that apparently carries on the business in the usual way binds the company, including signing an instrument in the company’s name. The company escapes only if the manager lacked authority for that matter and the other party actually knew it, or the articles or the Act establish the lack of authority. MCL 450.4406. That cuts both ways: an outsider can often hold the company to a contract a manager signed in the usual course, and a company that wants out of one needs proof of what the other side knew.

The operating agreement may set voting rights, including limited or no voting for some members. If it does not, each member has one vote, and a membership interest held by two or more persons counts as one. An LLC that existed before July 1, 1997 and voted in proportion to distributions keeps doing so until an operating agreement changes it. MCL 450.4502(1), (2). Unless the Act, the articles or the agreement require more, a majority in interest of the members entitled to vote approves a matter. MCL 450.4502(8). Only members, not managers, can authorize dissolution under section 801(c), a merger, an amendment of the articles or a conversion, and unless the agreement says otherwise a sale of all or substantially all assets outside the ordinary course requires a vote of the members. MCL 450.4502(4), (6).

Managers are selected by a majority in interest of the members entitled to vote. The members may remove a manager with or without cause unless the agreement allows removal only for cause. Removal for cause can happen only at a meeting called for that purpose, with reasonable advance notice of the allegations and a chance for the manager to be heard. MCL 450.4403.

Duties of managers and the limits an agreement can set

A manager must act in good faith, with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances, and in a manner the manager reasonably believes to be in the “best interests of the limited liability company”. A manager may rely on information from other managers, members, employees, lawyers, accountants and committees, unless the manager knows something that makes the reliance unwarranted. A manager who performs the office in compliance with that section is not liable for the action taken. MCL 450.4404(1)-(4). Unless the agreement or a member vote under section 502 provides otherwise, a manager must account to the company for any profit or benefit from a transaction connected with the company’s business or winding up, or from personal use of company property. MCL 450.4404(5).

The articles or the operating agreement may eliminate or limit a manager’s monetary liability to the company or its members for breach of the section 404 duties. The limit cannot reach a financial benefit the manager was not entitled to, an unlawful distribution, a knowing violation of law, or an act before the provision took effect. MCL 450.4407. When a manager has a personal interest in a transaction, the transaction is protected from being set aside or giving rise to damages if the manager shows it was fair to the company, or that the material facts were disclosed and approved by the disinterested managers or by the members entitled to vote who have no interest. Other claims about the transaction remain available. MCL 450.4409.

Unless the operating agreement provides otherwise, the company may indemnify, hold harmless and defend a member, manager or other person against losses, expenses, claims and demands, but not for conduct described in section 407(a), (b) or (c). It may also buy insurance for them. MCL 450.4216. The statute says the company may do this. It does not say the company must, so the agreement is where I look first when a member or manager asks who pays for a defense.

Money: contributions, distributions and what a creditor can reach

A member’s contribution can be cash, property, services performed or a promise to contribute, but a promise to contribute is not enforceable unless it is in writing and signed by the member. MCL 450.4301(1); MCL 450.4302(1). Distributions are allocated as the operating agreement provides. If it does not, they are shared in equal shares among all the members. An LLC that existed before July 1, 1997 and allocated distributions by contributions keeps doing so until an operating agreement changes it. MCL 450.4303(1)(b), (2).

A distribution cannot be made if afterward the company could not pay its debts as they come due in the usual course, or its total assets would be less than its total liabilities plus certain preferences. MCL 450.4307(1). A member or manager who votes for or assents to a violating distribution can be personally liable, jointly and severally, to the company if the person did not comply with the duty of care, and a member who accepts one knowing the facts is liable for the excess. A manager entitled to take part in the decision is presumed to have assented unless he or she votes against it or files a written dissent within a reasonable time. MCL 450.4308(1)-(3).

A member has no interest in specific company property. MCL 450.4504(2). A judgment creditor of a member can obtain a charging order, which entitles the creditor to the distributions the member would receive, and a charging order is a lien the creditor cannot foreclose. The creditor does not become a member, and the statute makes the charging order the exclusive remedy against the membership interest. MCL 450.4507(2), (4)-(6).

Transfers, withdrawal and exits

Unless the agreement says otherwise, a membership interest can be assigned in whole or in part. An assignment alone gives the buyer only the distributions the seller would have received, not management rights. MCL 450.4505(1), (2). In a company with more than one member, an assignee becomes a member only by unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote, unless the agreement provides otherwise. MCL 450.4506(1).

A member can withdraw only as the operating agreement provides, and a member who withdraws that way may be entitled to a withdrawal distribution. The agreement may also provide for expulsion or other events that end membership. MCL 450.4509. The Act gives a member no right to withdraw except as the agreement provides, so without those provisions the usual routes are an oppression claim or a request to dissolve. That is why the exit terms are the clauses I check first in a dispute: who can leave, who can be removed, who buys the interest, and at what price.

Records every LLC must keep and what a member can see

The company must keep at its registered office or principal place of business a current list of members and managers with their addresses, the articles and amendments, tax returns and financial statements for the 3 most recent years, the operating agreements, and records showing each member’s relative share of distributions and voting rights. MCL 450.4213.

On written request, a member is entitled to the most recent annual financial statement and tax returns. On reasonable written request during ordinary business hours, a member may inspect and copy those required records at the member’s expense, and may seek other information and books as is just and reasonable. A member may also seek a formal accounting as the agreement provides or when circumstances make it just and reasonable. MCL 450.4503. A records demand is often the first step before any lawsuit, because it shows whether distributions were paid in the shares the agreement requires.

Oppression, deadlock and dissolution

A member may sue in the circuit court for the county of the company’s principal place of business or registered office to establish that the acts of the managers or members in control are illegal or fraudulent or are willfully unfair and oppressive conduct toward the company or the member. The statute defines that conduct as a continuing course of conduct or a significant action or series of actions that substantially interferes with the interests of the member as a member, and it excludes conduct permitted by the articles, the operating agreement, another agreement to which the member is a party, or a consistently applied written company policy. MCL 450.4515(1), (2).

The remedies include dissolution and liquidation, cancellation or alteration of a provision in the articles or operating agreement, an order directing, altering or prohibiting an act of the company or its members or managers, purchase of the member’s interest at fair value by the company or the members responsible, and damages. MCL 450.4515(1)(a)-(e). Timing is the common trap. The Michigan Supreme Court held that the 3-year period is a statute of limitations and that the claim accrues when a manager substantially interferes with the member’s interests as a member, even if no calculable financial loss has yet occurred. In that case, amending the operating agreement to subordinate the plaintiffs’ units started the clock. Frank v. Linkner, 500 Mich. 133 (2017). A member who waits for the financial harm to show up can lose the damages claim.

Separately, the circuit court may decree dissolution on application by or for a member whenever the company is unable to carry on business in conformity with the articles or operating agreements. MCL 450.4802. A company also dissolves on the events the articles or agreement specify, on a unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote, or on a judicial decree. MCL 450.4801.

Defenses I see most often

  • The agreement allowed it. Oppression does not include conduct permitted by the articles, the operating agreement, another agreement the member signed, or a consistently applied written policy. MCL 450.4515(2).
  • Limitations. A manager duty claim and an oppression damages claim each carry the 3-year and 2-year limits, and an unlawful distribution proceeding must start within 2 years. MCL 450.4404(6); MCL 450.4515(1)(e); MCL 450.4308(5).
  • Compliance with the duty of care and reliance. A manager who performs the office in compliance with section 404 is not liable, and may rely on qualified people unless the manager knows reliance is unwarranted. MCL 450.4404(2)-(4).
  • Exculpation. If the articles or agreement limit a manager’s monetary liability, the claim must fit one of the exceptions. MCL 450.4407.
  • Interested transaction approved. A manager can defend a transaction as fair, or as approved by disinterested managers or members after disclosure. MCL 450.4409.
  • Apparent authority. A company that wants out of a contract signed by a manager must show the manager lacked authority and the other party actually knew it. MCL 450.4406.

How I handle an operating agreement or LLC management dispute

  1. Get every version of the agreement. I collect the articles, the operating agreement, any amendments, side letters and the company records. A dispute over what the agreement says is a different case from a dispute over what happened.
  2. Fix who is a member and who is a manager. I confirm how each person was admitted, whether the company is member-managed or manager-managed, and who signed what.
  3. Apply the defaults where the agreement is silent. Voting, distributions, transfer and removal each have a statutory default, and in many LLC disputes the default is what decides the case.
  4. Identify the claim or the defense and its deadline. A duty claim, an oppression claim and an unlawful distribution claim each run on their own clocks, and I calendar them at the start.
  5. Ask for the records. A written request under section 503 usually comes before a lawsuit, and I frame it around the records the company must keep.
  6. Negotiate the exit or the fix. I propose a buyout, an amendment, a manager change or a documented withdrawal. If the other side will not deal, I file in circuit court.
  7. Prepare for trial. I build the case from the company’s own records and the witnesses who made the decisions.

Ways an LLC dispute may end without a trial

  • Buyout. The company or the other members buy the interest at an agreed price and payment schedule.
  • Amended agreement. The members sign a new operating agreement that settles management, voting, distributions and exits.
  • Manager change. The members vote to remove or replace a manager under the agreement, with the transition terms in writing.
  • Accounting and repayment. A distribution that violated the agreement is repaid or corrected.

What I need from you

Bring the articles of organization, the operating agreement and every amendment, and any buy-sell agreement or side letter. Bring the company’s tax returns and financial statements for the last three years, the bank statements that show distributions and capital contributions, and any email or text in which a member or manager made a decision. Write out when and how you became a member, what you contributed, how decisions were actually made, and what changed. Do not sign a buyout, a withdrawal or an amended agreement until I have read it.

Where your Kent County LLC case will be heard

The statutes put an LLC oppression claim in the circuit court of the county where the company has its principal place of business or registered office, and a dissolution application in the circuit court of the county where the registered office is located. MCL 450.4515(1); MCL 450.4802. For a Kent County company, that is the 17th Judicial Circuit, which consists of Kent County. MCL 600.518. The district court has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions when the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000. MCL 600.8301(1). Michigan law sets the Kent County district courts by municipality: the 61st District Court serves the city of Grand Rapids, the 59th serves the cities of Grandville and Walker, the 62A serves the city of Wyoming, the 62B serves the city of Kentwood, and the 63rd serves the rest of Kent County. MCL 600.8128a; MCL 600.8130.

Why people hire me for an LLC dispute

You work directly with me, the lawyer who will argue your case. I read the agreement before I give an opinion, I tell you what the statute allows and where your position is weak, and I tell you what each path is likely to cost in time and money. I do not promise outcomes. I act for members and managers on either side of these disputes, so I know how each side builds its case. My fee depends on the work involved and how far the dispute goes, and we talk about it at the consultation before you decide whether to hire me.

Questions I hear from people running or leaving a Michigan LLC

Can a creditor take my LLC interest or the LLC’s assets to collect my personal debt?

Not directly. For a judgment against a member, a Michigan court may enter a charging order that reaches only the distributions the member would receive. The creditor cannot foreclose on the interest, does not become a member unless the operating agreement provides otherwise or the creditor is admitted as a member, and the statute makes the charging order the exclusive remedy against the membership interest.

Authority: MCL 450.4507; MCL 450.4504(2). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Are there limits on how much an LLC can distribute to its members in Michigan?

Yes. A distribution cannot be made if afterward the LLC could not pay its debts as they come due in the usual course, or if its total assets would be less than its total liabilities plus certain preferential amounts. A member or manager who approves a violating distribution can be personally liable to the company.

Authority: MCL 450.4307(1); MCL 450.4308. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

What records does a Michigan LLC have to keep?

An LLC must keep at its registered office or principal place of business a current list of members and managers with addresses, its articles and amendments, tax returns and financial statements for the 3 most recent years, its operating agreements, and records showing each member’s share of distributions and voting rights.

Authority: MCL 450.4213; MCL 450.4503(3). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

What duties does a manager of a Michigan LLC owe?

A manager must act in good faith, with the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would use, and in a manner the manager reasonably believes most benefits the company. A manager may rely on reports from qualified people, and must account to the LLC for profits from company transactions unless the agreement or a member vote says otherwise.

Authority: MCL 450.4404; MCL 450.4401; MCL 450.4502. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can an operating agreement limit a manager’s liability to the LLC?

Yes, in part. The articles or operating agreement may eliminate or limit a manager’s monetary liability to the company or its members for breaching the standard of conduct. It cannot cover receiving a financial benefit the manager was not entitled to, unlawful distributions, a knowing violation of law, or acts before the provision took effect.

Authority: MCL 450.4407; MCL 450.4404; MCL 450.4308. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Yes, unless the operating agreement says otherwise. An LLC may indemnify, hold harmless, and defend a member, manager, or other person against losses, expenses, claims, and demands. It cannot indemnify conduct described in MCL 450.4407(a), (b), or (c). It may also buy insurance for them.

Authority: MCL 450.4216; MCL 450.4407. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can I sell or transfer my membership interest in a Michigan LLC?

Usually, unless the operating agreement says otherwise. An interest is assignable in whole or in part. But an assignment alone gives the buyer only the distributions the seller would have received. In an LLC with more than one member, the buyer becomes a member only by unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote, unless the operating agreement provides a different rule.

Authority: MCL 450.4505; MCL 450.4506; MCL 450.4504. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can I withdraw from my Michigan LLC and get paid for my share?

Only as the operating agreement allows. MCL 450.4509 says a member may withdraw from a Michigan LLC only as provided in the operating agreement, and a withdrawing member may be entitled to a withdrawal distribution. The agreement may also provide for expulsion or other events that end membership.

Authority: MCL 450.4509; MCL 450.4515; MCL 450.4307; MCL 450.4505. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

I advise and represent LLC members and managers in Kent County and West Michigan. Contact me 24/7 by phone or email. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.

Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit.

Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan.

MBisson@BissonLegal.com

This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.

Do not wait. Call me.

The sooner I am involved, the more I can do. I keep what you tell me private. Please share only the basics until we have spoken.