These are general answers about Michigan law, not advice about your situation. Each answer links to the statute, court rule or case it rests on. Last reviewed October 2026.
By Mitchell S. Bisson, Michigan attorney (P79807). Reviewed October 2026.
Quick answers
The short version
Can I appeal my sentence in Michigan, and how do appellate courts review it?
Yes. Michigan's sentencing guidelines are advisory under People v Lockridge, and in People v Posey the Michigan Supreme Court severed the part of MCL 769.34(10) that required affirmance of within-guidelines sentences, so every sentence is reviewed for reasonableness (proportionality), with a nonbinding rebuttable presumption that a within-guidelines sentence is proportionate. A sentence appeal follows the path for the conviction: by right after trial, by leave after a plea.
What do I have to do to preserve a sentencing guidelines scoring error for appeal in Michigan?
Under MCR 6.429(C), you cannot raise on appeal a challenge to guidelines scoring, or to the accuracy of information relied on in sentencing, for a sentence within the guidelines range unless you raised it at sentencing, in a proper motion for resentencing, or in a proper motion to remand filed in the Court of Appeals. A motion to correct an invalid sentence under MCR 6.429 is one way to raise it.
What is a Ginther hearing in a Michigan criminal appeal?
A Ginther hearing is an evidentiary hearing in the trial court, named for People v Ginther, where facts outside the trial record are developed, most often to support a claim that trial counsel was ineffective. The Michigan Supreme Court said a defendant who wants to advance claims that depend on matters not of record can be required to seek an evidentiary hearing at the trial court level.
Michigan law, reviewed October 2026. General information, not advice about your situation. Select a question for the full answer and the authority behind it.
Michigan ยท 10 questions
Questions on this page
- Can I appeal my sentence in Michigan, and how do appellate courts review it?
- What do I have to do to preserve a sentencing guidelines scoring error for appeal in Michigan?
- What is a Ginther hearing in a Michigan criminal appeal?
- What do I have to prove to succeed on an ineffective assistance of counsel claim in Michigan?
- Can I withdraw a guilty plea in Michigan after it is entered?
- What is a Cobbs evaluation, and can I withdraw my plea if the judge exceeds it?
- What is a motion for relief from judgment under MCR 6.500 in Michigan?
- What limits apply to an MCR 6.500 motion in Michigan, and can I file more than one?
- How do I appeal after a judge denies my MCR 6.500 motion?
- Can I get a lawyer appointed for my criminal appeal in Michigan if I cannot afford one?
Can I appeal my sentence in Michigan, and how do appellate courts review it?
Yes. Michigan's sentencing guidelines are advisory under People v Lockridge, and in People v Posey the Michigan Supreme Court severed the part of MCL 769.34(10) that required affirmance of within-guidelines sentences, so every sentence is reviewed for reasonableness (proportionality), with a nonbinding rebuttable presumption that a within-guidelines sentence is proportionate. A sentence appeal follows the path for the conviction: by right after trial, by leave after a plea.
In Lockridge, the Court held that a guidelines range calculated in violation of the Sixth Amendment is advisory only and that departure sentences are reviewed for reasonableness. In Posey, the Court held that the portion of MCL 769.34(10) mandating appellate affirmation of within-guidelines sentences is severed as inconsistent with Lockridge, and it directed the Court of Appeals to apply a nonbinding rebuttable presumption of proportionality to the within-guidelines minimum sentence there. MCR 6.425(F)(5) requires the court, when it imposes a minimum sentence longer than the guidelines range, to advise the defendant on the record and in writing that review is available, by right if the conviction followed trial or by application if it followed a plea. The sentencing transcript, and any transcript of a hearing on a motion relating to sentencing, must accompany an application for leave under MCR 7.205(B)(4)(f). If a brief argues the sentence, counsel must send a copy of the presentence report to the court under MCR 7.212(C)(7). Preservation matters for scoring challenges, which are governed by MCR 6.429(C). No result on a sentencing issue can be promised, because review turns on the record the sentencing court made.
What do I have to do to preserve a sentencing guidelines scoring error for appeal in Michigan?
Under MCR 6.429(C), you cannot raise on appeal a challenge to guidelines scoring, or to the accuracy of information relied on in sentencing, for a sentence within the guidelines range unless you raised it at sentencing, in a proper motion for resentencing, or in a proper motion to remand filed in the Court of Appeals. A motion to correct an invalid sentence under MCR 6.429 is one way to raise it.
MCR 6.429(B) controls timing. A motion to correct an invalid sentence may be filed before a timely claim of appeal. If a claim of appeal has been filed, the motion may be filed only under MCR 7.208(B) or the remand procedure in MCR 7.211(C)(1). If the defendant may appeal only by leave or did not file a timely claim, the motion may be filed within the time for an application for leave under MCR 7.205(A)(2)(a) and (b)(i)-(iii). If the defendant is no longer entitled to appeal by right or by leave, relief is under subchapter 6.500. A trial court may also correct an invalid sentence on its own initiative after at least 14 days' notice, and only within 6 months of entry of the judgment. At sentencing, MCR 6.425(D)(2) requires the court to let the parties be heard on a challenge to the presentence report and to make a finding or state that it will not consider the information. Raising the challenge at sentencing is usually the simplest way to preserve it.
What is a Ginther hearing in a Michigan criminal appeal?
A Ginther hearing is an evidentiary hearing in the trial court, named for People v Ginther, where facts outside the trial record are developed, most often to support a claim that trial counsel was ineffective. The Michigan Supreme Court said a defendant who wants to advance claims that depend on matters not of record can be required to seek an evidentiary hearing at the trial court level.
On a direct appeal, a defendant commonly asks for the hearing by moving to remand in the Court of Appeals under MCR 7.211(C)(1). The motion must identify an issue to be reviewed and show that the issue is of record and must be initially decided by the trial court, or that development of a factual record is required. It must be supported by an affidavit or offer of proof about the facts to be established at the hearing. A timely motion must be granted if it comes with the trial court's certificate that it will grant a motion for new trial. Filing the motion stays further proceedings in the Court of Appeals until it is denied or the trial court proceedings finish, unless the court orders otherwise, and the appellant's brief is due 21 days after the trial court's decision or the transcript, whichever is later. Another option is a motion in the trial court under MCR 7.208(B) within the time for the appellant's brief, which the trial court must decide within 56 days unless it finds good cause to adjourn. Without a hearing, the appellate court may reject the claim for lack of a record.
What do I have to prove to succeed on an ineffective assistance of counsel claim in Michigan?
Under Strickland v Washington, which Michigan follows, you must show that counsel's representation fell below an objective standard of reasonableness, and that there is a reasonable probability that, but for counsel's unprofessional errors, the result of the proceeding would have been different. A reasonable probability is a probability sufficient to undermine confidence in the outcome.
The Michigan Supreme Court applied the Strickland standard in People v Trakhtenberg, which also confirms that Michigan courts use the federal constitutional test. Both parts must be shown. Strickland describes a strong presumption that counsel's conduct falls within the wide range of reasonable professional assistance, so a claim needs specific facts about what counsel did or failed to do and why that fell short. Because many of those facts are not in the trial transcript, these claims usually require a record built through a Ginther hearing, and an appeal without that record may be decided only on the existing transcript. The prejudice part focuses on outcome: a mistake that did not matter to the result does not satisfy the standard. The same federal standard appears in federal habeas review, where 28 USC 2254(d) adds a layer of deference to the state court's decision. Start with what the record already shows before deciding whether a claim has support.
Can I withdraw a guilty plea in Michigan after it is entered?
It depends on timing. Before the court accepts the plea on the record, you have a right to withdraw it. After acceptance but before sentencing, MCR 6.310(B)(1) allows withdrawal only in the interest of justice, and not if it would substantially prejudice the prosecutor, except in the situations in MCR 6.310(B)(2) where withdrawal is a right. After sentencing, a motion must be filed within the time for an application for leave to appeal, generally 6 months after entry of the judgment of sentence.
MCR 6.310(C)(1) ties the post-sentence motion to the periods in MCR 7.205(A)(2)(a) and (b)(i)-(iii), which are longer than 6 months in some situations. After that period, relief is available only under subchapter 6.500 under MCR 6.310(C)(2). Some withdrawal rights are automatic before sentencing: if the plea involves an agreement for a specified sentence or range and the court says it cannot follow it, or if the court states it will sentence to a specified term or range and cannot, or if a consecutive sentence will be imposed and the defendant was not advised that the law permits or requires it. A defendant who commits misconduct after the plea but before sentencing, such as absconding, may lose some of these rights unless the court allows otherwise for good cause. If the court finds an error in the plea proceeding, it must correct it and give you the choice to keep the plea or withdraw it. To raise on appeal a claim that the plea was not understanding, voluntary or accurate, you generally must have moved to withdraw it in the trial court under MCR 6.310(D).
What is a Cobbs evaluation, and can I withdraw my plea if the judge exceeds it?
Under People v Cobbs, at a party's request a judge may state on the record the sentence that appears appropriate based on the information then available. If you plead guilty or no contest in reliance on that preliminary evaluation and the judge later decides the sentence must exceed it, you have an absolute right to withdraw the plea. The evaluation does not bind the judge's sentencing discretion.
Cobbs explains that additional facts may emerge later, from the presentence report, from statements by the prosecutor and the victim, or from other sources, so the judge's early view is not a promise. The decision not to sentence in line with a preliminary evaluation is not an automatic basis for recusal. The court rule that covers related situations is MCR 6.310(B)(2): if a plea involves an agreement for a specified term or range and the court states it cannot follow it, the court must state the sentence it intends to impose and let the defendant affirm or withdraw the plea. If the plea involves a statement by the court that it will sentence to a specified term or range, and the court says it cannot, the court must give the defendant the opportunity to affirm or withdraw but must not state the sentence it intends. The right described in Cobbs arises when the sentence must exceed the evaluation, so the exact words the judge used on the record matter. A defendant who wants a Cobbs evaluation must ask for it.
What is a motion for relief from judgment under MCR 6.500 in Michigan?
A motion under MCR 6.502 is the post-appeal procedure for challenging a Michigan circuit court conviction or sentence that is no longer subject to review under the court rules for the Court of Appeals or Supreme Court. It is filed in the court that convicted you, substantially in the form approved by the State Court Administrative Office, with a verification, and it must state all grounds for relief that are available.
MCR 6.501 says a circuit court conviction not subject to appellate review under subchapters 7.200 or 7.300 may be reviewed only under subchapter 6.500. The motion may seek relief from one judgment only, may not be noticed for hearing, and is limited to 50 double-spaced pages combined with any memorandum unless the court orders otherwise. It is filed with the clerk and served on the prosecutor under MCR 6.503. The court may appoint counsel for an indigent defendant at any time and must appoint counsel if it directs oral argument or an evidentiary hearing, and appointed counsel has 56 days to supplement the motion under MCR 6.505. If the court directs a response, the prosecutor has at least 56 days under MCR 6.506. The court then decides whether an evidentiary hearing is needed under MCR 6.508(B). MCR 6.502 and MCR 6.503 set no calendar deadline for filing a 6.500 motion, but the limits in MCR 6.508(D) and the one-year federal habeas clock under 28 USC 2244(d) make delay costly.
What limits apply to an MCR 6.500 motion in Michigan, and can I file more than one?
MCR 6.508(D) bars relief if the conviction can still be challenged on appeal, or if the claim was decided against you before (unless a retroactive change in the law undermined the prior decision), and bars claims (other than jurisdictional defects) that could have been raised on appeal or in a prior motion unless you show good cause and actual prejudice. MCR 6.502(G) allows only one motion, with exceptions for a retroactive change in law, new evidence, or a final order vacating a related conviction.
The defendant has the burden of establishing entitlement to relief under MCR 6.508(D). Actual prejudice has a rule-specific meaning: after a trial, that but for the error the defendant would have had a reasonably likely chance of acquittal, or that, having rejected a plea on incorrect information from the court or ineffective advice, it is reasonably likely the offer would have stayed open, been accepted and produced a less severe result (MCR 6.508(D)(3)(b)(i)(B)); after a plea, that the defect made the plea involuntary to a degree that it would be manifestly unjust to let the conviction stand; in any case, that the irregularity was so offensive to a sound judicial process that the conviction should not stand regardless of outcome; and for a sentence challenge, that the sentence is invalid. The court may waive the good cause requirement, and may waive the successive-motion limit, if it concludes there is a significant possibility that the defendant is innocent. Under MCR 6.502(G)(3), new evidence includes new scientific evidence, such as a shift in scientific consensus. If a pro se defendant files a first motion styled as something else, the court must give notice and 90 days to withdraw or amend before treating it as a 6.500 motion under MCR 6.502(D). Because only one motion is generally allowed, every available ground should be included before filing.
How do I appeal after a judge denies my MCR 6.500 motion?
Appeals from decisions under MCR 6.500 are by application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeals under MCR 6.509(A) and MCR 7.205(A)(1), which sets a 21-day period. MCR 7.205(A)(4)(a) allows a delayed application, with a statement explaining the delay, within 6 months of the decision under the subchapter, which includes a decision on a timely motion for reconsideration and a reissued order. The 6.500 process does not extend the time to appeal the original judgment.
MCR 6.509(A) defines a decision under the subchapter to include a decision on a motion filed under MCR 6.502, a decision on a timely motion for reconsideration, and a reissued order under MCR 6.508(F). That last rule requires a court that decides a motion in part to reissue the order within 7 days after deciding the remaining issues so that all decisions are in one order. If the trial court appointed counsel during the 6.500 proceeding, the appointment authorizes that lawyer to represent the defendant in the application for leave under MCR 6.509(B). If the prosecutor has not responded to the application and the Court of Appeals grants it, the prosecutor must file an appellee's brief within 56 days after an order directing a response, under MCR 6.509(C) and (D). A later application to the Michigan Supreme Court is governed by MCR 7.305. The time a properly filed 6.500 motion is pending can also matter to the one-year federal habeas period under 28 USC 2244(d)(2), so it should be tracked separately.
Can I get a lawyer appointed for my criminal appeal in Michigan if I cannot afford one?
Yes, if you are found indigent and request counsel on time. After a conviction following trial, the request must be filed within 42 days after entry of the judgment of sentence to appeal by right. After a plea, the request must be filed within 6 months after entry of the judgment of sentence. MCR 6.425(F) requires the court to advise you of these rights and give you a request-for-counsel form.
MCR 6.425(G)(1) sets the process: requests are granted or denied on forms approved by the State Court Administrative Office and provided by the Michigan Appellate Assigned Counsel System. Within 7 days after receiving the request, or after a postjudgment motion is decided, the trial court submits it to that system, which has 7 days to send a proposed order naming the State Appellate Defender Office or an approved private attorney, and the court then has 7 days to rule. If the defendant is indigent and the request was filed within 6 months of the judgment of sentence, or within the time for an appeal of right, the court must appoint a lawyer. After a trial, a request that comes after the 42 days but within 6 months still requires appointment for an indigent defendant, but the appeal then goes by application for leave rather than as of right. An order denying a request must state reasons and inform the defendant that the denial can be appealed by an application for leave under MCR 7.205. The appointment order must direct the court reporter to prepare the full transcript. The U.S. Supreme Court held in Halbert v Michigan that indigent defendants convicted on a plea who seek first-tier review in the Court of Appeals are entitled to appointed counsel.
Related
More questions and pages
- All appeals questions in Michigan
- Appeal deadlines and starting an appeal
- Leave applications, district court, agency and Supreme Court appeals
- Reconsideration, new trial and relief from judgment
- Briefs, the record, standards of review and oral argument
- Stays, bonds, costs and timing of an appeal
- Federal habeas corpus
- Criminal court process: pleas, sentencing and probation, the steps that come before a criminal appeal
- Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer
- Michigan appeals lawyer
- Michigan civil litigation questions
Questions about a Michigan matter?
Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.