These are general answers about Michigan law, not advice about your situation. Each answer links to the statute, court rule or case it rests on. Last reviewed October 2026.
By Mitchell S. Bisson, Michigan attorney (P79807). Reviewed October 2026.
Quick answers
The short version
A federal habeas petition under 28 USC 2254 asks a federal court to decide whether you are in custody under a state judgment in violation of the Constitution or federal law. Under 28 USC 2254(b)(1), the petition generally cannot be granted unless you have exhausted the remedies available in state court. The Supreme Court says that means one complete round of the state's established appellate review process.
What is the one-year deadline for a federal habeas petition from a Michigan conviction?
You have one year from the date your judgment becomes final under 28 USC 2244(d)(1)(A): the conclusion of direct review or the expiration of the time to seek it. If you applied to the Michigan Supreme Court, that includes the 90 days to petition the U.S. Supreme Court. If you did not, the clock starts when your time to apply to the Michigan Supreme Court expired, with no 90-day add-on.
Does filing an MCR 6.500 motion stop the federal habeas clock?
It can pause the clock, but only in part. Under 28 USC 2244(d)(2), the time during which a properly filed application for state post-conviction or other collateral review with respect to the pertinent judgment or claim is pending is not counted toward the one-year period. Under Pace v DiGuglielmo, a state petition that the state court rejects as untimely is not properly filed and does not toll the clock.
Michigan law, reviewed October 2026. General information, not advice about your situation. Select a question for the full answer and the authority behind it.
Michigan ยท 11 questions
Questions on this page
- What is federal habeas corpus for a Michigan state conviction, and do I have to go through the state courts first?
- Can I file a federal habeas petition after I finish my Michigan sentence?
- What if some of my claims were never raised in state court when I file my federal habeas petition?
- What is the one-year deadline for a federal habeas petition from a Michigan conviction?
- Does filing an MCR 6.500 motion stop the federal habeas clock?
- Can a late federal habeas petition ever be saved?
- What is procedural default in a Michigan habeas case, and can it be excused?
- Why is it so hard to win a federal habeas petition after a Michigan conviction?
- What is a certificate of appealability, and do I need one to appeal a denied habeas petition?
- Can I file a second federal habeas petition?
- I was convicted in federal court in Michigan. Is a 2255 motion the same as habeas, and what are the deadlines?
What is federal habeas corpus for a Michigan state conviction, and do I have to go through the state courts first?
A federal habeas petition under 28 USC 2254 asks a federal court to decide whether you are in custody under a state judgment in violation of the Constitution or federal law. Under 28 USC 2254(b)(1), the petition generally cannot be granted unless you have exhausted the remedies available in state court. The Supreme Court says that means one complete round of the state's established appellate review process.
Section 2254(a) limits relief to custody in violation of the Constitution, laws or treaties of the United States. In O'Sullivan v Boerckel, the Supreme Court held that a state prisoner must invoke one complete round of the state's established appellate review process, including discretionary review in the state's highest court when that is part of the process. For a Michigan conviction, that generally means presenting each claim in the Court of Appeals and by application to the Michigan Supreme Court. Under 28 USC 2254(c), you have not exhausted a claim if you still have a right under state law to raise it by any available procedure. A court may deny a petition on the merits despite non-exhaustion under 28 USC 2254(b)(2). If the state court decided a claim on the merits, 28 USC 2254(d) allows relief only if the decision was contrary to or an unreasonable application of clearly established federal law, or rested on an unreasonable determination of the facts, and 28 USC 2254(e)(1) presumes state fact findings correct unless rebutted by clear and convincing evidence.
Can I file a federal habeas petition after I finish my Michigan sentence?
Generally not for that conviction. Section 2254(a) covers a person in custody pursuant to a state-court judgment, and the Supreme Court reads that to require custody under the conviction you challenge when you file (Maleng v Cook). Custody is not limited to prison, since a parolee is in custody under an unexpired sentence, but collateral consequences of a fully expired sentence are not enough.
In Maleng v Cook, the petitioner challenged a 1958 conviction whose sentence had expired but which had been used to enhance later sentences. The Court held he was not in custody under the 1958 sentence, because it had fully expired when he filed, but was in custody under the later sentences he had not yet begun to serve. The Court noted that physical confinement is not required, and that a parolee, whose release is conditioned on reporting and other restrictions, remains in custody under the unexpired sentence. It also described Carafas v LaVallee, where the petition was filed while the petitioner was incarcerated and the case was not moot when the sentence expired during the appeal, because of the collateral consequences. In Garlotte v Fordice, the Court held that a prisoner serving consecutive sentences remains in custody under all of them until all are served and may attack the conviction underlying an earlier sentence. The practical lesson is to file while you are still serving the sentence you are challenging. In Rivers v Guerrero (2025), the Court said that the petitioner's no longer being in custody on one conviction did not defeat habeas jurisdiction where he remained incarcerated on related sentences that the new evidence might implicate. Time limits also apply: the one-year period in 28 USC 2244(d) runs whether or not you are still serving. If you are close to finishing a sentence, the sequence of filings should be planned early.
What if some of my claims were never raised in state court when I file my federal habeas petition?
A petition mixing exhausted and unexhausted claims is a mixed petition. Under Rhines v Weber, a federal court may stay it while you return to state court only if you had good cause for not exhausting, the unexhausted claims are potentially meritorious, and you were not intentionally dilatory. A pending federal petition does not toll the one-year period under 28 USC 2244(d)(2) (Duncan v Walker), so the delay can cost you.
Under 28 USC 2254(b)(1)(A), a habeas application generally cannot be granted unless you exhausted state remedies, and under 2254(c) you have not exhausted a claim if you can still raise it by an available state procedure. Section 2254(b)(2) lets a court deny a claim on the merits despite non-exhaustion. In Rhines, the Court said stay and abeyance should be available only in limited circumstances, because a stay excuses the failure to exhaust first. It is appropriate only with good cause, and not when the unexhausted claims are plainly meritless, and the court should set reasonable time limits on the trip to state court and back. If a stay is inappropriate, the court should allow you to delete the unexhausted claims and proceed on the rest if dismissal would unreasonably impair your right to federal relief. In Duncan v Walker, the Court held that a federal habeas petition is not an application for state post-conviction or other collateral review, so it does not toll the period in 28 USC 2244(d)(2). The Court expressly did not decide whether equitable tolling is available (533 US at 181). A dismissal without prejudice can therefore leave the claims out of time. In Michigan, the return trip is normally a motion under MCR 6.502, which generally allows one motion (MCR 6.502(G)) and requires all available grounds (MCR 6.502(A)). In Amos v Renico, for example, the district court held the case in abeyance until the claims were exhausted. Raising every claim in state court first avoids the problem.
What is the one-year deadline for a federal habeas petition from a Michigan conviction?
You have one year from the date your judgment becomes final under 28 USC 2244(d)(1)(A): the conclusion of direct review or the expiration of the time to seek it. If you applied to the Michigan Supreme Court, that includes the 90 days to petition the U.S. Supreme Court. If you did not, the clock starts when your time to apply to the Michigan Supreme Court expired, with no 90-day add-on.
The four starting dates in 28 USC 2244(d)(1) are final judgment, removal of a state-created impediment, a newly recognized and retroactive constitutional right, and the date a claim's factual predicate could have been discovered with due diligence. The first is the usual one, and the trap is the 90 days. In Jimenez v Quarterman, the Supreme Court treated a conviction as final when the time to seek certiorari in the Supreme Court expired, and under Supreme Court Rule 13.1 a certiorari petition is due within 90 days after entry of the judgment of the state court of last resort, or of the order denying discretionary review. But in Gonzalez v Thaler, a prisoner who did not seek review in the state's highest court got no 90-day add-on, because the Supreme Court could not have reviewed that judgment. For a Michigan criminal case, that means the clock may start 56 days after the Court of Appeals decision if no application is filed (MCR 7.305(C)(2)), or 90 days after the Michigan Supreme Court's decision if one is. The year keeps running while no properly filed state collateral motion is pending, so treat the date the judgment becomes final as a firm calendar entry.
Does filing an MCR 6.500 motion stop the federal habeas clock?
It can pause the clock, but only in part. Under 28 USC 2244(d)(2), the time during which a properly filed application for state post-conviction or other collateral review with respect to the pertinent judgment or claim is pending is not counted toward the one-year period. Under Pace v DiGuglielmo, a state petition that the state court rejects as untimely is not properly filed and does not toll the clock.
Tolling pauses the period but does not erase time that already ran before the state motion was filed, so days between the end of direct review and the filing of the 6.500 motion count against the year. The question of what is properly filed turns on the state's rules for filing. In Pace, the Supreme Court held that because the state court rejected the petition as untimely, it was not properly filed under 28 USC 2244(d)(2). A Michigan 6.500 motion that does not substantially comply with MCR 6.502 can be returned under MCR 6.502(D), and whether a rejected filing counts as properly filed for federal purposes depends on the case law and the specific facts. Whether a given period counts as pending, including the time for appeals from the 6.500 decision, depends on the case law and the specific dates. Because tolling is only as good as the state filing, a 6.500 motion should not be treated as a safe harbor for the federal deadline.
Can a late federal habeas petition ever be saved?
Sometimes. In Holland v Florida, the Supreme Court held the one-year period is subject to equitable tolling if the petitioner shows he has been pursuing his rights diligently and that some extraordinary circumstance stood in his way. In McQuiggin v Perkins, the Court held that actual innocence, if proved, is a gateway through which a petitioner may pass even after the limitations period has expired.
Holland says the diligence required is reasonable diligence, not maximum feasible diligence, and that equitable tolling is available only if the petitioner shows both elements. McQuiggin says unjustifiable delay is not an absolute barrier to an innocence claim but is a factor in deciding whether actual innocence has been reliably shown. The statute offers other starting dates in 28 USC 2244(d)(1)(B)-(D) in narrow situations. Equitable tolling asks for diligence over the whole period, so a petitioner would need records showing what was done and when, such as letters to counsel, court filings and requests for case information. These are exceptions, not planning tools. A petitioner who is late and relies on them has to prove the facts, usually with documents and dates, and the court decides whether the showing is enough. Treat the one-year deadline as firm and count conservatively.
What is procedural default in a Michigan habeas case, and can it be excused?
If the state courts refused to hear a claim because you did not follow a state procedural rule, such as raising it on direct appeal under MCR 6.508(D)(3), a federal court generally will not review it unless you show cause and actual prejudice, or a fundamental miscarriage of justice. In the Sixth Circuit, an unexplained Michigan order that only cites MCR 6.508(D) does not create a default by itself, but a reasoned ruling that invokes the rule can.
Procedural default is the doctrine under which a federal court will not review claims, including constitutional ones, that a state court declined to hear because the prisoner failed to follow a state procedural rule (Martinez v Ryan, 566 US at 9). A default can be overcome by showing cause for it and actual prejudice, or that not considering the claim would be a fundamental miscarriage of justice (Coleman v Thompson, 501 US at 748-750, which Martinez later qualified on other grounds). In Michigan, MCR 6.508(D)(3) is the usual source. In Guilmette v Howes, the en banc Sixth Circuit held that the one-line orders citing MCR 6.508(D) are ambiguous and therefore unexplained, so the federal court looks to the last reasoned state decision. In Amos v Renico, ineffective-assistance claims that the Michigan trial court rejected under MCR 6.508(D)(3) were treated as defaulted on an independent and adequate state ground, with no actual prejudice shown to excuse the default, while claims the trial court rejected under a different subrule were not defaulted because the bar was not clearly and expressly invoked. Martinez recognized a narrow exception: where state law requires ineffective-assistance-of-trial-counsel claims to be raised in an initial-review collateral proceeding, the absence of counsel there, or ineffective counsel, can be cause if the underlying claim is substantial. It does not reach errors in appeals from the initial-review proceeding or in successive collateral proceedings, and it applies only where state law channels the claim to the initial-review collateral proceeding. Under Shinn v Martinez Ramirez, even when it applies, it does not open the door to new evidence. Also, under 28 USC 2254(i), the ineffectiveness of counsel in state post-conviction proceedings is not itself a ground for relief.
Why is it so hard to win a federal habeas petition after a Michigan conviction?
Under 28 USC 2254(d), relief is barred on any claim the state courts decided on the merits unless that decision was contrary to or an unreasonable application of clearly established Supreme Court law, or rested on an unreasonable view of the facts. Unreasonable is not the same as wrong: relief is foreclosed so long as fairminded jurists could disagree with the state court. Review is also generally limited to the state-court record.
Section 2254(d)(1) and (2) set the two exceptions. In Harrington v Richter, the Supreme Court said an unreasonable application of federal law is different from an incorrect one, and that a state court's ruling that a claim lacks merit precludes federal relief so long as fairminded jurists could disagree on its correctness. A state court that denies relief without explanation is presumed to have decided the claim on the merits unless there is reason to think otherwise, and under Wilson v Sellers a federal court looks through an unexplained order to the last reasoned state decision and presumes the same reasoning. Under Cullen v Pinholster, review under 2254(d)(1) is limited to the record that was before the state court. State fact findings are presumed correct unless rebutted by clear and convincing evidence (2254(e)(1)), and 2254(e)(2) restricts evidentiary hearings if you failed to develop the facts in state court. In Shinn v Martinez Ramirez, the Court held that a federal court may not hold a hearing or consider outside evidence based on the ineffective assistance of state postconviction counsel. The Court enforced these limits again in 2026, in Klein v Martin (Jan.) and McCarthy v Hernandez (June), summarily reversing courts of appeals that had ordered or upheld habeas relief. But in Pitchford v Cain (May 2026) the Court held that a state court had unreasonably applied Batson and unreasonably found a waiver, so relief remains possible. The practical consequence is that a claim should be built around Supreme Court holdings and the state record.
What is a certificate of appealability, and do I need one to appeal a denied habeas petition?
Yes, for a habeas case challenging a state court judgment. Under 28 USC 2253(c)(1)(A), you cannot appeal the final order unless a circuit justice or judge issues a certificate of appealability, and under 28 USC 2253(c)(2) that requires a substantial showing of the denial of a constitutional right. The certificate must indicate which specific issues satisfy that showing.
Section 2253(c)(3) requires the certificate to name the specific issue or issues that meet the standard. In Miller-El v Cockrell, the Supreme Court explained that a petitioner satisfies the standard by demonstrating that jurists of reason could disagree with the district court's resolution of the constitutional claims or that the issues presented are adequate to deserve encouragement to proceed further. That is a threshold test and is not the same as proving the claim will win. Section 2253(a) makes the final order reviewable by the court of appeals for the circuit where the proceeding is held, which for a Michigan federal district court is the Sixth Circuit. If the district judge denies a certificate, the applicant may ask a circuit judge to issue one (Fed. R. App. P. 22(b)(1)); if no certificate issues, the appeal cannot go forward on those issues. A notice of appeal is due within 30 days after entry of the judgment denying the petition under Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(1)(A), and a missed deadline can end the appeal. Because the certificate decision depends on how the district court decided each claim, the order should be read claim by claim to identify which issues are worth presenting.
Can I file a second federal habeas petition?
Only in narrow circumstances. Under 28 USC 2244(b), a claim in a second or successive 2254 application that was already presented must be dismissed. A new claim must be dismissed unless it relies on a new, retroactive rule of constitutional law, or on facts that could not have been discovered earlier through due diligence and that would establish by clear and convincing evidence that, but for constitutional error, no reasonable factfinder would have found guilt.
Before filing a second or successive application in the district court, the applicant must move in the court of appeals for an order authorizing it under 28 USC 2244(b)(3)(A). A three-judge panel decides, may authorize filing only on a prima facie showing that the requirements are met, and must grant or deny within 30 days after the motion is filed. The grant or denial is not appealable and is not the subject of a petition for rehearing or certiorari under 28 USC 2244(b)(3)(E). Even after authorization, the district court dismisses any claim that does not satisfy the statute under 28 USC 2244(b)(4). Whether a later petition counts as second or successive can depend on how the first one ended, so that question should be answered before filing anything. Because the gate is narrow, the first petition needs to include every claim that is ready and exhausted, which is a reason to prepare it carefully.
I was convicted in federal court in Michigan. Is a 2255 motion the same as habeas, and what are the deadlines?
A federal prisoner challenges a conviction or sentence by motion under 28 USC 2255 in the court that imposed it, not by a 2254 petition. A one-year limit applies, running from the latest of four dates, usually when the judgment of conviction becomes final (2255(f)). A second or successive motion needs a court of appeals panel to certify newly discovered evidence or a new retroactive constitutional rule (2255(h)).
Section 2255(a) lets a prisoner in custody under a federal sentence move the sentencing court to vacate, set aside or correct the sentence. The other three starting dates in 2255(f) are removal of an unlawful government impediment, a newly recognized and retroactive right, and the date the facts could have been discovered with due diligence. How the judgment becomes final depends on your direct appeal history. Section 2255(e) bars a habeas application by a prisoner who can use the motion, unless the motion is inadequate or ineffective to test the legality of the detention. In Jones v Hendrix (2023), the Court held that this saving clause does not let a prisoner use 28 USC 2241 to get around the limits on successive motions based on a new interpretation of a statute. Two 2026 decisions matter. In Bowe v United States (Jan. 2026), the Court held that the 2244(b)(1) bar on repeating a claim does not apply to successive 2255 motions, and that the certiorari bar in 2244(b)(3)(E) does not stop the Court from reviewing a federal prisoner's request to file one, though the 2255(h) conditions still apply. In Fernandez v United States (May 2026), the Court held that a prisoner who attacks the validity of a conviction must proceed through 2255, not through a compassionate release motion under 18 USC 3582. Appeals from a ruling on the motion are governed by 2255(d), and the court may appoint counsel (2255(g)).
Related
More questions and pages
- All appeals questions in Michigan
- Appeal deadlines and starting an appeal
- Leave applications, district court, agency and Supreme Court appeals
- Reconsideration, new trial and relief from judgment
- Briefs, the record, standards of review and oral argument
- Stays, bonds, costs and timing of an appeal
- Criminal appeals, plea withdrawal and MCR 6.500 motions
- Criminal court process: pleas, sentencing and probation, the steps that come before a criminal appeal
- Michigan appeals lawyer
- Michigan civil litigation questions
Questions about a Michigan matter?
Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.