These are general answers about Michigan law, not advice about your situation. Each answer links to the statute, court rule or case it rests on. Last reviewed October 2026.
By Mitchell S. Bisson, Michigan attorney (P79807). Reviewed October 2026.
Quick answers
The short version
Can the prosecutor appeal in Michigan if a judge dismisses my criminal case?
Often yes. An order dismissing a criminal case is a final order, and the prosecution can appeal it as of right unless double jeopardy would bar further proceedings. A dismissal entered before the jury is sworn, or after a guilty verdict, does not raise that bar. A ruling that the prosecution's proof was insufficient is an acquittal, and it does.
Can the prosecutor appeal when a judge suppresses evidence in Michigan?
Not as a matter of right. A suppression order does not end the case, so the prosecution has to ask for permission to appeal, called an application for leave to appeal, within 21 days. The appellate court decides whether to hear it, and the application has to show how the prosecution would suffer substantial harm by waiting for a final judgment. If the ruling leads to a dismissal of the case, that dismissal can be appealed as of right.
Yes. The prosecution can ask the circuit court to review a refusal to bind a defendant over for trial, and it can also start over with a new complaint and more evidence. The reviewing court does not substitute its own view of the witnesses. It reviews the decision for abuse of discretion, and the magistrate is entitled to weigh credibility.
Michigan law, reviewed October 2026. General information, not advice about your situation. Select a question for the full answer and the authority behind it.
Michigan · 9 questions
Questions on this page
- Can the prosecutor appeal in Michigan if a judge dismisses my criminal case?
- Can the prosecutor appeal when a judge suppresses evidence in Michigan?
- Can the prosecutor appeal if the judge refuses to bind my case over for trial after the preliminary examination?
- Can the prosecutor appeal a sentence below the Michigan sentencing guidelines?
- Can the prosecutor appeal a not guilty verdict or a judge's directed verdict of acquittal in Michigan?
- What is double jeopardy in Michigan, and when can I be tried twice for the same conduct?
- What happens to my bond and my case while a prosecutor's appeal is pending in Michigan?
- How long does the prosecutor have to appeal in Michigan, and is it an appeal of right or by leave?
- Can the prosecutor appeal a ruling that keeps out a witness or key evidence before trial in Michigan?
Can the prosecutor appeal in Michigan if a judge dismisses my criminal case?
Often yes. An order dismissing a criminal case is a final order, and the prosecution can appeal it as of right unless double jeopardy would bar further proceedings. A dismissal entered before the jury is sworn, or after a guilty verdict, does not raise that bar. A ruling that the prosecution's proof was insufficient is an acquittal, and it does.
In a criminal case, an order dismissing the case is a final order (MCR 7.202(6)(b)(i)). The people may take an appeal of right from a final judgment or final order of the circuit court, but only if the protection against double jeopardy under Const 1963, art 1, § 15 and the Fifth Amendment would not bar further proceedings against the defendant (MCL 770.12(1)(a)). The court rules route prosecution appeals through that statute (MCR 7.203(E)). When the dismissal comes from a district court, the appeal of right goes to the circuit court (MCR 7.103(A)(1)), and the circuit judge who hears it must be someone other than the judge who conducted the trial (MCR 7.103(C)).
The double jeopardy limit decides most of these appeals. Jeopardy attaches when a jury is selected and sworn (People v Lett, 466 Mich 206, 215 (2002)), so a dismissal entered before then is not an acquittal. After a trial starts, the kind of ruling matters. The United States Supreme Court has held that a judge's midtrial ruling that the prosecution's evidence was insufficient is an acquittal that bars retrial, even when the ruling rests on a mistaken view of the law (Evans v Michigan, 568 US 313, 315-316, 318 (2013)). A ruling made after a guilty verdict is different. Because a reversal would simply reinstate the jury's verdict and no new trial would follow, the government may appeal (United States v Wilson, 420 US 332, 344-345 (1975)).
A claim of appeal from a final order of the circuit court is due within 42 days after entry of the order (MCR 7.204(A)(2)(c)). An appeal of right from a district court order goes to the circuit court within 21 days (MCR 7.104(A)(1)). The rules call both time limits jurisdictional (MCR 7.204(A); MCR 7.104(A)).
Can the prosecutor appeal when a judge suppresses evidence in Michigan?
Not as a matter of right. A suppression order does not end the case, so the prosecution has to ask for permission to appeal, called an application for leave to appeal, within 21 days. The appellate court decides whether to hear it, and the application has to show how the prosecution would suffer substantial harm by waiting for a final judgment. If the ruling leads to a dismissal of the case, that dismissal can be appealed as of right.
A ruling that suppresses evidence is an interlocutory order, one entered before final judgment. The people may appeal by leave from a judgment or order of the circuit court that is not a final judgment appealable of right, and from any other order appealable by law or rule, if double jeopardy would not bar further proceedings (MCL 770.12(2)(a), (c)). An appeal from an interlocutory order is taken by application for leave to appeal, in the manner provided by court rules, to the court that could hear an appeal of right from the final judgment (MCL 770.3(2)). The Court of Appeals may grant leave to appeal from an order of the circuit court that is not a final judgment appealable of right (MCR 7.203(B)(1)), so whether to hear the appeal is the court's decision.
The application is due within 21 days after entry of the order (MCR 7.205(A)(1)(a)). When the order is interlocutory, the application must set out facts showing how the appellant would suffer substantial harm by awaiting final judgment before taking an appeal (MCR 7.205(B)(1)). If the suppression ruling came from a district court, no appeal of right exists, so the application goes to the circuit court, which may grant leave (MCR 7.103(B)(1)(a)), and it is also due within 21 days (MCR 7.105(A)(1)).
A suppression ruling is made before trial, so jeopardy has not attached if a jury has not yet been selected and sworn (People v Lett, 466 Mich 206, 215 (2002)). If the ruling leaves the prosecution unable to proceed and the court dismisses the case, the dismissal is a final order in a criminal case (MCR 7.202(6)(b)(i)), and the people may appeal it of right under MCL 770.12(1)(a).
Can the prosecutor appeal if the judge refuses to bind my case over for trial after the preliminary examination?
Yes. The prosecution can ask the circuit court to review a refusal to bind a defendant over for trial, and it can also start over with a new complaint and more evidence. The reviewing court does not substitute its own view of the witnesses. It reviews the decision for abuse of discretion, and the magistrate is entitled to weigh credibility.
At a preliminary examination, if the court finds probable cause to believe an offense not cognizable by the district court was committed and that the defendant committed it, the court must bind the defendant over for trial. If it finds no probable cause, the court must discharge the defendant without prejudice to the prosecutor starting a new prosecution for the same offense, or reduce the charge to a non-felony (MCR 6.110(E), (F)).
The Michigan Supreme Court addressed a prosecution challenge to a refusal to bind over in People v Anderson, 501 Mich 175 (2018). The complainant testified that the defendant pointed a gun at him, and the magistrate found the testimony not credible and declined to bind the defendant over. The prosecutor sought review in the circuit court, which denied relief, and the Court of Appeals affirmed. The Supreme Court held that a magistrate's duty at a preliminary examination is to consider all the evidence, including the credibility of witnesses, and to decide on that basis whether there is probable cause (Anderson, 501 Mich at 178). A bindover decision is reviewed for abuse of discretion, and absent one a reviewing court should not disturb it (Anderson, 501 Mich at 181-182). The Court added that a reviewing court must remember that the judge who hears the testimony has a distinct advantage over an appellate judge who has only the printed words (Anderson, 501 Mich at 189). It affirmed the dismissal.
The other path is a new complaint. After a discharge, the second preliminary examination must be held before the same judicial officer, and the prosecutor must present additional evidence to support the charge (MCR 6.110(F)).
Can the prosecutor appeal a sentence below the Michigan sentencing guidelines?
Yes. A sentence is a final judgment, so the prosecution can appeal it, as of right after a trial and by leave after a plea. Since Lockridge made the guidelines advisory, a departure from the range, including one below it, is reviewed on appeal for reasonableness, and the Court of Appeals has decided prosecution appeals of below-guidelines sentences.
The original sentence imposed following conviction is a final judgment in a criminal case (MCR 7.202(6)(b)(ii)). The people may appeal of right from a final judgment of the circuit court if double jeopardy would not bar further proceedings (MCL 770.12(1)(a)). A final judgment based on a plea of guilty or nolo contendere is appealable only by leave (MCL 770.12(2)(e); MCR 7.203(A)(1)(b)). A claim of appeal of right is due within 42 days after entry of the judgment (MCR 7.204(A)(2)(c)).
In People v Lockridge, 498 Mich 358 (2015), the Michigan Supreme Court made the sentencing guidelines range advisory and held that sentences that depart from the range are reviewed by appellate courts for reasonableness (Lockridge, 498 Mich at 391-392). In People v Lydic, 335 Mich App 486 (2021), the prosecution appealed an out-of-guidelines sentence below the advisory range. The Court of Appeals considered whether the trial court justified the sentence as more proportionate to the offense and the offender than a guidelines sentence would have been, found that it did, and affirmed.
A sentence within the range is treated differently. If a minimum sentence is within the appropriate guidelines range, the Court of Appeals is directed to affirm it and not remand for resentencing, absent an error in scoring the guidelines or inaccurate information relied on in sentencing, and a scoring challenge generally must have been raised at sentencing, in a proper motion for resentencing, or in a proper motion to remand (MCL 769.34(10)).
Can the prosecutor appeal a not guilty verdict or a judge's directed verdict of acquittal in Michigan?
Generally no. A jury's not guilty verdict cannot be reviewed, and a judge's directed verdict of acquittal is treated the same way, even when the judge got the law wrong. The Michigan Supreme Court applied that rule in a first-degree criminal sexual conduct case, and the United States Supreme Court did so in a Michigan arson case.
The Michigan Constitution says no person shall be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy (Const 1963, art 1, § 15), and the statute allowing prosecution appeals applies only where double jeopardy would not bar further proceedings (MCL 770.12(1), (2)). The United States Supreme Court has said that a mistaken acquittal is an acquittal nonetheless, and that a verdict of acquittal could not be reviewed without putting the defendant twice in jeopardy (Evans v Michigan, 568 US 313, 318 (2013)). That rule applies whether the judge directs the jury to acquit or enters a judgment of acquittal alone (Evans, 568 US at 318).
Evans came from Michigan. At an arson trial the court directed a verdict of acquittal midtrial because it believed the prosecution had to prove that the burned building was not a dwelling. That was not an element of the charged offense. The Michigan Supreme Court held that retrial was allowed, and the United States Supreme Court reversed, holding that a midtrial acquittal that rests on an erroneously added element is still an acquittal for double jeopardy purposes (Evans, 568 US at 315-316). In People v Szalma, 487 Mich 708 (2010), a first-degree criminal sexual conduct case, the trial court directed a verdict of acquittal because it wrongly treated sexual purpose as an element. The Michigan Supreme Court held that the legal error did not undo the acquittal and reinstated the directed verdict (Szalma, 487 Mich at 710, 717-718).
What the prosecution can appeal are rulings that are not acquittals. A ruling after a guilty verdict is one example. Because a reversal would reinstate the verdict without a new trial, the double jeopardy clause does not stand in the way (United States v Wilson, 420 US 332, 344-345 (1975)).
What is double jeopardy in Michigan, and when can I be tried twice for the same conduct?
Double jeopardy protects against a second prosecution for the same offense after an acquittal or a conviction, and against multiple punishments for the same offense. It does not stop a second trial after a hung jury, a prosecution by a different government for the same conduct, or separate charges that each require proof of a fact the other does not. Under a July 2026 Michigan Supreme Court decision, retrial can also be barred after a mistrial caused by intentional prosecutorial misconduct.
Both constitutions prohibit placing a person twice in jeopardy for the same offense (Const 1963, art 1, § 15; US Const, Am V). The Michigan Supreme Court describes three related protections: against a second prosecution for the same offense after acquittal, against a second prosecution for the same offense after conviction, and against multiple punishments for the same offense (People v Nutt, 469 Mich 565, 574 (2004); People v Smith, 478 Mich 292, 299 (2007)). Jeopardy attaches when a jury is selected and sworn (People v Lett, 466 Mich 206, 215 (2002)).
The protection applies to the same offense, not the same event. Offenses are not the same for the successive prosecutions strand if each requires proof of a fact that the other does not (Smith, 478 Mich at 304). A single incident can therefore support more than one charge. Retrial after a mistrial caused by a deadlocked jury does not violate either constitution (Lett, 466 Mich at 217). The United States Supreme Court has also held that a state and the federal government are separate sovereigns, so a prosecution by one does not bar a prosecution by the other for the same conduct (Gamble v United States, 587 US 678 (2019)).
In People v Jennings, decided July 24, 2026, the Michigan Supreme Court addressed a mistrial that the defense requested because of the prosecutor's conduct. It rejected the narrow federal rule of Oregon v Kennedy, under which retrial is barred only when the prosecutor intended to provoke a mistrial request, and adopted a test under Const 1963, art 1, § 15. Retrial is barred when the mistrial was granted because of the prosecutor's improper conduct, the conduct was not merely legal error, negligence, mistake or insignificant impropriety but intentional conduct the prosecutor knew to be improper and prejudicial and pursued for an improper purpose with indifference to a significant danger of mistrial or reversal, and the prejudice could not be cured by means short of a mistrial. The Court stressed that a defendant bears a heavy burden under this test.
What happens to my bond and my case while a prosecutor's appeal is pending in Michigan?
When the prosecution appeals from a court of record, the defendant is permitted to post bail on his or her own recognizance during the appeal unless the trial court determines and certifies that a bond requirement is advisable. An appeal does not by itself stay the order being appealed, and the trial court generally cannot set aside or amend that order while the appeal is pending. A court can order a stay on motion.
If an appeal is taken by or on behalf of the people from a court of record, the defendant is to be permitted to post bail on his or her own recognizance pending the prosecution and determination of the appeal, unless the trial court determines and certifies that the character of the offense, the respondent, and the questions involved in the appeal make it advisable that bail be required (MCL 765.7). The statute that allows prosecution appeals says a defendant's right to bail on appeal is governed by MCL 770.9a and MCL 765.7 (MCL 770.12(3)). MCL 770.9a sets a stricter detention rule for defendants convicted of the assaultive crimes it lists.
As to the case itself, an appeal does not stay the effect or enforceability of a trial court order unless the trial court or the Court of Appeals orders otherwise (MCR 7.209(A)(1)). The Court of Appeals may, on its own initiative or on a party's motion, stay proceedings in the trial court or stay the effect of an order on the terms it deems just (MCR 7.209(D)). A motion for bond or a stay may not be filed in the Court of Appeals unless the trial court decided that motion first (MCR 7.209(A)(2)), and the trial court keeps authority over stay and bond matters unless the Court of Appeals orders otherwise (MCR 7.208(G)).
After a claim of appeal is filed or leave to appeal is granted, the trial court may not set aside or amend the judgment or order appealed from except by order of the Court of Appeals, by stipulation of the parties, or as otherwise provided by law (MCR 7.208(A)).
How long does the prosecutor have to appeal in Michigan, and is it an appeal of right or by leave?
A claim of appeal of right from a circuit court final order is due within 42 days of entry, and an application for leave to appeal is due within 21 days. Whether the appeal is of right or by leave depends on the order. Final judgments and orders of the circuit court are appealable of right, while non-final orders, appeals from a circuit court's own appellate decision, and judgments based on a plea go by leave. The time limits are jurisdictional.
Under MCL 770.12(1), the people may appeal of right, if double jeopardy would not bar further proceedings, from a final judgment or final order of the circuit court, other than one entered on appeal from another court. The people may appeal by leave from an order that is not a final judgment appealable of right, from a final judgment entered by the circuit court on appeal from any other court, from any other judgment or order appealable by law or rule, from an order when an appeal of right could have been taken but was not timely filed, and from a final order or judgment based on a guilty or nolo contendere plea (MCL 770.12(2)). The court rules say prosecution appeals are governed by MCL 770.12, except as provided by MCL 770.3 (MCR 7.203(E)).
A claim of appeal of right in a criminal case must be taken within 42 days after entry of the judgment or order appealed from (MCR 7.204(A)(2)(c)). An application for leave to appeal must be filed within 21 days after entry of the judgment or order (MCR 7.205(A)(1)(a)). The rules call both limits jurisdictional (MCR 7.204(A); MCR 7.205(A)). For an appeal from a district court, the claim of appeal and the application for leave to the circuit court are each due within 21 days (MCR 7.104(A)(1); MCR 7.105(A)(1)).
If the leave deadline is missed, a delayed application may be filed within 6 months of the entry of the judgment or order (MCR 7.205(A)(4)(a)). Further review of a matter the circuit court decided on appeal from a lower court is only by application for leave granted by the Court of Appeals (MCL 770.3(4)).
Can the prosecutor appeal a ruling that keeps out a witness or key evidence before trial in Michigan?
Usually only by permission. A ruling that excludes a witness or evidence before trial is interlocutory, so the prosecution applies for leave to appeal within 21 days and has to show substantial harm from waiting. Timing matters. If the trial goes forward and the judge then directs a verdict of acquittal because the proof is insufficient, that acquittal cannot be appealed even if the exclusion was wrong.
An order excluding a witness or evidence is not on the list of final orders in a criminal case, which is limited to an order dismissing the case, the original sentence, a sentence after resentencing, a sentence or order after remand in a prior appeal of right, and a sentence after probation revocation (MCR 7.202(6)(b)). The prosecution therefore proceeds by application for leave to appeal (MCL 770.12(2)(a), (c); MCL 770.3(2)). The application is due within 21 days, and it must set out facts showing how the appellant would suffer substantial harm by awaiting final judgment (MCR 7.205(A)(1)(a), (B)(1)). The Court of Appeals may grant leave (MCR 7.203(B)(1)). If it does, the case proceeds as an appeal of right (MCR 7.205(E)(3)).
The risk comes once trial starts. Jeopardy attaches when a jury is selected and sworn (People v Lett, 466 Mich 206, 215 (2002)). The United States Supreme Court has said that an acquittal precludes retrial even if it is premised on an erroneous decision to exclude evidence (Evans v Michigan, 568 US 313, 318 (2013)). A prosecution that loses a key witness midtrial and sees the case end in a directed verdict of acquittal has no appeal from that result.
Related
More questions and pages
- Appeals in Michigan: all topics
- Criminal appeals, plea withdrawal and MCR 6.500 motions
- Appeal deadlines and starting an appeal
- Leave applications, district court, agency and Supreme Court appeals
- Stays, bonds, costs and timing of an appeal
- Trial, sentencing and habitual offender
- Michigan appeals lawyer
- Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer
- Michigan criminal court process questions
- Michigan civil litigation questions
Questions about a Michigan matter?
Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.