Skip to content

PIP claim disputes, exclusions and health insurance in Michigan

Michigan law: PIP claim disputes, exclusions and health insurance. Short and full answers with the statutes, court rules and cases behind them, by attorney Mitchell S. Bisson.

These are general answers about Michigan law, not advice about your situation. Each answer links to the statute, court rule or case it rests on. Last reviewed October 2026.

By Mitchell S. Bisson, Michigan attorney (P79807). Reviewed October 2026.

Quick answers

The short version

My no-fault insurer denied my claim and said I committed fraud. What does that mean?

It usually means the insurer says wrong information was given, either on the policy application or in the claim, and it is refusing to pay because of that. If the problem is the application, the insurer may try to rescind the policy, which means treating it as if it had never been issued, even for an accident that already happened. That can happen when the mistake was honest, though a judge decides whether rescission is fair and can protect people who did not make the misstatement. Separately, knowingly false statements made to deceive an insurer can be a felony under MCL 500.4511, but a denial letter is not a criminal charge.

Do I have to go to the insurance company's doctor for a medical exam?

Yes, if your mental or physical condition is material to the PIP claim, MCL 500.3151 says you must submit to a mental or physical examination by physicians at the insurer's request. The examining doctor must be licensed, must have spent most of the prior year in active clinical practice or teaching, and, if a specialist is treating you, must be in the same specialty, so the exam is not open to just any physician the insurer picks.

Will my health insurance or my auto insurance pay first for car accident medical bills?

It depends on how your auto policy was written. Unless you chose a coordinated, exclusion or opt-out option, your auto insurer's PIP medical coverage generally pays first. MCL 500.3109a lets an insurer offer a policy coordinated with other health and accident coverage at a reduced premium, and requires insurers to offer a qualified-health-coverage exclusion to those who select the $250,000 level. A person with Medicare may also have chosen under MCL 500.3107d not to carry PIP medical coverage. Which policy pays first depends on those choices, so the declarations page and the coverage selection form are the first documents to read.

Michigan law, reviewed October 2026. General information, not advice about your situation. Select a question for the full answer and the authority behind it.

My no-fault insurer denied my claim and said I committed fraud. What does that mean?

It usually means the insurer says wrong information was given, either on the policy application or in the claim, and it is refusing to pay because of that. If the problem is the application, the insurer may try to rescind the policy, which means treating it as if it had never been issued, even for an accident that already happened. That can happen when the mistake was honest, though a judge decides whether rescission is fair and can protect people who did not make the misstatement. Separately, knowingly false statements made to deceive an insurer can be a felony under MCL 500.4511, but a denial letter is not a criminal charge.

A fraud accusation is serious and should be answered carefully. The criminal statutes require a knowing false statement made with intent to deceive, so an honest mistake is a different thing under them. Rescission of a policy does not require that intent. In Meemic Ins Co v Fortson, 506 Mich 287 (2020), the Court held that contractual fraud provisions are valid when based on a defense to mandatory coverage in the no-fault act itself or on a common-law defense the act has not abrogated, and it held the insurer's anti-fraud provision there invalid and unenforceable because it rested on neither. So the exact wording of the policy and the nature of the statement matter. Many fraud denials turn on the application rather than the claim. If the insurer says the application misstated something it relied on, such as who lives in the household, who drives the car, or where the car is kept, it may declare the policy rescinded. Rescission treats the policy as if it never existed, and the insurer usually refunds the premiums and denies claims under it, including claims for an accident that already happened. Michigan courts have held that the no-fault act does not take this remedy away from insurers (Bazzi v Sentinel Ins Co, 502 Mich 390 (2018)), and in April 2026 the Michigan Supreme Court confirmed that a material misstatement the insurer relied on can support rescission even when the person did not mean to deceive anyone (Sherman v Progressive Michigan Ins Co, Docket No. 167826 (2026)). Rescission is not automatic. It is an equitable remedy, and a judge weighs the circumstances before granting it. That weighing matters most for people who did not make the misstatement, such as a passenger, a relative in the household, or a medical provider seeking payment directly, because a court must balance the equities before applying a rescission to them (Bazzi; Mota-Peguero v Falls Lake Nat'l Ins Co, 350 Mich App 692 (2024)). A rescission can still cost someone coverage. If you receive a rescission letter, keep it, and talk with a lawyer before you cash a premium refund check, because insurers sometimes argue that keeping the refund means you agreed to the rescission. Under MCL 500.3148(2), a court can also award an insurer attorney fees against a claimant for a claim that was in some respect fraudulent or so excessive as to have no reasonable foundation. If you receive a denial, keep the letter and its stated reasons. Under MCL 500.3145(3) a formal denial ends the tolling that began with your specific claim. Talk with a lawyer before giving a recorded statement or examination under oath about the accusation.

Authority: MCL 500.4503; MCL 500.3173a; MCL 500.4511; Meemic Ins Co v Fortson, 506 Mich 287 (2020); MCL 500.3148; MCL 500.3145; Titan Ins Co v Hyten, 491 Mich 547 (2012); Bazzi v Sentinel Ins Co, 502 Mich 390 (2018); Sherman v Progressive Michigan Ins Co, Docket No. 167826 (Mich, April 20, 2026); Mota-Peguero v Falls Lake Nat'l Ins Co, 350 Mich App 692 (2024). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Do I have to go to the insurance company's doctor for a medical exam?

Yes, if your mental or physical condition is material to the PIP claim, MCL 500.3151 says you must submit to a mental or physical examination by physicians at the insurer's request. The examining doctor must be licensed, must have spent most of the prior year in active clinical practice or teaching, and, if a specialist is treating you, must be in the same specialty, so the exam is not open to just any physician the insurer picks.

MCL 500.3151(1) makes the examination a duty of a PIP claimant when the condition is material to a claim for past or future benefits, and lets an insurer include reasonable examination provisions in the policy. Subsection (2) adds limits since the 2019 amendments. The examining physician must be licensed in this state or another state. If a physician in a particular specialty is providing your care, the examiner must practice in the same specialty and, if the treating physician is board certified, the examiner must be board certified in it. During the prior year the examiner must have devoted a majority of professional time to active clinical practice, or to instruction in an accredited program, in the relevant specialty where applicable. If an examiner does not meet the criteria, object in writing before the exam. Missing a scheduled exam can lead to a suspension or denial, depending on the policy and the claim, so attend, bring a list of medications and treatment, and keep notes about how long the exam lasted.

Authority: MCL 500.3151. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Will my health insurance or my auto insurance pay first for car accident medical bills?

It depends on how your auto policy was written. Unless you chose a coordinated, exclusion or opt-out option, your auto insurer's PIP medical coverage generally pays first. MCL 500.3109a lets an insurer offer a policy coordinated with other health and accident coverage at a reduced premium, and requires insurers to offer a qualified-health-coverage exclusion to those who select the $250,000 level. A person with Medicare may also have chosen under MCL 500.3107d not to carry PIP medical coverage. Which policy pays first depends on those choices, so the declarations page and the coverage selection form are the first documents to read.

Under MCL 500.3109a(1), an insurer may offer deductibles and exclusions reasonably related to other health and accident coverage, but any it offers must carry a reduced premium, need prior approval by the director, and apply only to the person named in the policy, the spouse, and relatives domiciled in the household. Subsection (2) requires an offer of an exclusion related to qualified health coverage to those who select the $250,000 limit, with premium reductions, and if a person subject to that exclusion loses the health coverage, the named insured has 30 days to obtain insurance that includes the excluded coverage, with assigned claims access during the gap. A named insured who has Medicare Parts A and B can also elect under MCL 500.3107d not to maintain PIP medical coverage, if the spouse and any resident relatives have qualified health coverage or PIP coverage; the election applies to those household members, and Medicare and the health plan then pay the medical bills instead of the auto policy. If qualified health coverage ends, the named insured has 30 days to obtain PIP coverage. Your declarations page and the coverage selection form show whether you chose a coordinated, exclusion or opt-out option. Health plans, Medicare and Medicaid have their own rules, and they can claim reimbursement, so every payer should be identified early. Providers sometimes bill the health plan and the auto insurer both, which makes it important to track who paid what.

Authority: MCL 500.3109a; MCL 500.3107d. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can my doctor or hospital sue the no-fault insurer directly for unpaid bills?

Since the 2019 amendments, yes. MCL 500.3112 says a health care provider listed in MCL 500.3157 may make a claim and assert a direct cause of action against the insurer, or under the assigned claims plan, to recover overdue benefits for charges for products, services or accommodations provided to the injured person. The amended provision applies to services provided after June 11, 2019.

MCL 500.3112 now gives a provider a statutory route to the insurer for overdue PIP benefits. The enacting section says the amended text applies to products, services, or accommodations provided after the effective date of the amendatory act, which was June 11, 2019. That helps patients because the provider can pursue payment itself, but it does not take the patient out of the picture. An insurer may raise defenses against a provider's claim such as priority, coverage level, the fee schedule in MCL 500.3157, and fraud. The patient's own claim for benefits and the provider's claim can both be pending, and a good-faith payment by the insurer to the person it believes entitled discharges its liability to that extent unless the insurer has been notified in writing of the claim of some other person, which is why a provider's written notice matters. A ledger of who billed what helps, and every provider letter and bill should be sent promptly to the lawyer handling the claim so nothing is missed. An assignment of the right to benefits can change who is the real party in interest to sue for a bill, so any assignment should be checked before suit. C-Spine Orthopedics, PLLC v Progressive Mich Ins Co, Nos. 165537, 165538 and 165964 (Mich July 3, 2025).

Authority: MCL 500.3112; MCL 500.3157; C-Spine Orthopedics, PLLC v Progressive Mich Ins Co, Nos. 165537, 165538 and 165964 (Mich July 3, 2025). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can I be denied no-fault benefits even if I was hurt in a crash that was not my fault?

Yes, in limited situations. MCL 500.3113 excludes a person who willingly used a vehicle that was taken unlawfully and knew or should have known it, an owner or registrant of an uninsured motor vehicle or motorcycle involved in the accident, a nonresident who did not own a vehicle registered and insured in Michigan, and certain excluded operators and owners.

Fault is not the test for PIP, but status is. MCL 500.3113 lists the exclusions: (a) willingly operating or using a vehicle that was taken unlawfully, when the person knew or should have known; (b) being the owner or registrant of a motor vehicle or motorcycle involved in the accident for which required security was not in effect; (c) not being a Michigan resident, unless the person owned a vehicle registered and insured in this state; (d) operating a vehicle as to which the person was a named excluded operator; and (e) being the owner or operator of a vehicle for which coverage was excluded under certain policy exclusions. The uninsured-owner exclusion is the one that surprises people, and it can apply even when the owner was not driving. An owner includes a person who has the use of a vehicle, under a lease or otherwise, for more than 30 days, even if a company he solely owns holds the title. Abdulla v Progressive Se Ins Co, Nos. 167532 and 167533 (Mich July 7, 2026). A lapse in coverage, a policy cancelled for nonpayment, or a vehicle you sold but had not transferred can all be factual disputes. Subsection (b) also affects tort recovery, since MCL 500.3135(2)(c) bars noneconomic damages for an uninsured owner-operator.

Authority: MCL 500.3113; MCL 500.3135; Abdulla v Progressive Se Ins Co, Nos. 167532 and 167533 (Mich July 7, 2026). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

What is property protection insurance and what does it cover?

Property protection insurance (PPI) pays for accidental damage to tangible property arising from the use of a motor vehicle as a motor vehicle, without regard to fault, up to $1,000,000 under one policy for one accident. The claim goes to the insurer of the owner or registrant of the vehicle involved, then the insurer of its operator. Vehicles and their contents are generally excluded unless the vehicle was parked in a way that did not cause an unreasonable risk of the damage (MCL 500.3123(1)(a)), and PPI is not payable for accidents outside Michigan.

MCL 500.3121 defines PPI. Damage to tangible property means physical injury or destruction and loss of use, and damage is accidental unless the claimant suffered or caused it intentionally. Benefits are due without regard to fault. Under MCL 500.3125, the claim goes to the insurer of the owner or registrant of the vehicle involved in the accident, then the insurer of its operator. A person who knows damage is substantially certain does not cause it intentionally if acting to avert injury or damage. The statute excludes property damage that occurs in the course of a business of repairing, servicing, or maintaining motor vehicles, other than the insured vehicle. Because vehicles are excluded unless properly parked, collision coverage and the $3,000 claim described below are usually the routes for vehicle damage, while PPI fits fences, buildings and properly parked cars. There is also a separate claim against an at-fault person for up to $3,000 of vehicle damage not covered by insurance for accidents after July 1, 2020, under MCL 500.3135(3)(e). An action for PPI benefits must be commenced within one year of the accident under MCL 500.3145(5), so the deadline is short.

Authority: MCL 500.3121; MCL 500.3145; MCL 500.3135; MCL 500.3123; MCL 500.3125. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Questions about a Michigan matter?

Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.

Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com

This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.

Have a question about your case?

The sooner I am involved, the more I can do. I keep what you tell me private. Please share only the basics until we have spoken.