Skip to content

Tort claims, the tort threshold and UM/UIM coverage in Michigan

Michigan law: Tort claims, the tort threshold and UM/UIM coverage. Short and full answers with the statutes, court rules and cases behind them, by attorney Mitchell S. Bisson.

These are general answers about Michigan law, not advice about your situation. Each answer links to the statute, court rule or case it rests on. Last reviewed October 2026.

By Mitchell S. Bisson, Michigan attorney (P79807). Reviewed October 2026.

Quick answers

The short version

What does serious impairment of body function mean in a Michigan car accident case?

Under MCL 500.3135(5), a serious impairment of body function is an impairment that is objectively manifested, affects an important body function, and affects your general ability to lead your normal life. The statute says there is no temporal requirement for how long the impairment must last. You need it, or death or permanent serious disfigurement, to recover noneconomic damages from the at-fault driver.

Does a judge or a jury decide whether my injury meets the Michigan threshold?

Usually the judge, but the jury if there is a factual dispute about the injuries that is material to the threshold. Under MCL 500.3135(2)(a), the judge decides serious impairment and permanent serious disfigurement as questions of law if there is no factual dispute about the nature and extent of the injuries, or if a dispute exists but is not material to whether the threshold is met. For a closed-head injury, a question of fact for the jury is created if a licensed allopathic or osteopathic physician who regularly diagnoses or treats closed-head injuries testifies under oath that there may be a serious neurological injury.

What can I recover from the at-fault driver beyond my no-fault benefits?

If you meet the threshold, you can recover noneconomic damages such as pain, suffering and loss of enjoyment of life. Regardless of the threshold analysis for noneconomic loss, MCL 500.3135(3)(c) preserves a claim for allowable expenses, work loss and survivor's loss above the applicable PIP limit or the daily, monthly and three-year limits, and MCL 500.3135(3)(e) preserves a claim for up to $3,000 of vehicle damage for accidents after July 1, 2020, to the extent not covered by insurance.

Michigan law, reviewed October 2026. General information, not advice about your situation. Select a question for the full answer and the authority behind it.

What does serious impairment of body function mean in a Michigan car accident case?

Under MCL 500.3135(5), a serious impairment of body function is an impairment that is objectively manifested, affects an important body function, and affects your general ability to lead your normal life. The statute says there is no temporal requirement for how long the impairment must last. You need it, or death or permanent serious disfigurement, to recover noneconomic damages from the at-fault driver.

The three parts of MCL 500.3135(5) are: (a) the impairment is objectively manifested, meaning observable or perceivable from actual symptoms or conditions by someone other than the injured person; (b) it is an impairment of an important body function, one of great value, significance, or consequence to you; and (c) it affects your general ability to lead your normal life, meaning it has influenced some of your capacity to live in your normal manner of living. The analysis is fact specific and compares your life before and after. In McCormick v Carrier, 487 Mich 180 (2010), the Michigan Supreme Court held that Kreiner v Fischer was wrongly decided and applied that three-part reading, and the 2019 amendments say they intend to codify McCormick. That means older cases decided under Kreiner are suspect. Medical records, imaging, work restrictions and witness testimony from people who know you do most of the work. The threshold does not limit PIP benefits, only your claim against the other driver.

Authority: MCL 500.3135; McCormick v Carrier, 487 Mich 180 (2010). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Does a judge or a jury decide whether my injury meets the Michigan threshold?

Usually the judge, but the jury if there is a factual dispute about the injuries that is material to the threshold. Under MCL 500.3135(2)(a), the judge decides serious impairment and permanent serious disfigurement as questions of law if there is no factual dispute about the nature and extent of the injuries, or if a dispute exists but is not material to whether the threshold is met. For a closed-head injury, a question of fact for the jury is created if a licensed allopathic or osteopathic physician who regularly diagnoses or treats closed-head injuries testifies under oath that there may be a serious neurological injury.

This rule matters because defendants often move for summary disposition on the threshold. MCL 500.3135(2)(a) gives the court the question when there is no factual dispute about the nature and extent of the injuries, or the dispute is not material to the threshold. The closed-head exception requires testimony under oath from a licensed allopathic or osteopathic physician who regularly diagnoses or treats closed-head injuries that there may be a serious neurological injury, which then sends the issue to the jury. In McCormick v Carrier, 487 Mich 180 (2010), the Supreme Court explained that the court should first ask whether there is a factual dispute about the nature and extent of the injuries and whether it is material. If the facts are disputed in a way that matters, the question goes to the jury. The medical proof should be built early, with treating providers, so a motion can be answered with specific evidence about the injury and about how daily life changed.

Authority: MCL 500.3135; McCormick v Carrier, 487 Mich 180 (2010). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

What can I recover from the at-fault driver beyond my no-fault benefits?

If you meet the threshold, you can recover noneconomic damages such as pain, suffering and loss of enjoyment of life. Regardless of the threshold analysis for noneconomic loss, MCL 500.3135(3)(c) preserves a claim for allowable expenses, work loss and survivor's loss above the applicable PIP limit or the daily, monthly and three-year limits, and MCL 500.3135(3)(e) preserves a claim for up to $3,000 of vehicle damage for accidents after July 1, 2020, to the extent not covered by insurance.

MCL 500.3135(3) abolishes tort liability arising from the use of an insured motor vehicle except for a list of items. Intentionally caused harm is preserved. Noneconomic damages are preserved as provided and limited in subsections (1) and (2). Subsection (3)(c) preserves damages for allowable expenses, work loss and survivor's loss in excess of any applicable limit under MCL 500.3107c or the daily, monthly and 3-year limits in the PIP sections, and without limit for allowable expenses if the injured person elected not to maintain PIP medical coverage or an exclusion applies. The party liable gets a reduction for the taxes that would have been payable on income the injured person would have received. A plaintiff who opted out of PIP medical coverage because of Medicare must mitigate by seeking payment from Medicare for treatment from Medicare-participating providers, and the MCL 500.3157 limits do not apply to a tort claim under subsection (3)(c). Canty v Mason, No. 167772 (Mich July 27, 2026). Subsection (3)(d) covers economic loss by a nonresident, who must meet the threshold, and subsection (3)(e) covers vehicle damage. In practice, a person who chose a lower PIP limit and is later badly hurt may have an excess economic claim against the other driver, which makes the coverage level on your own policy important.

Authority: MCL 500.3135; MCL 500.3107c; Canty v Mason, No. 167772 (Mich July 27, 2026); MCL 500.3157. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

What if I was partly at fault for the crash? Does that bar my claim?

Not usually. Michigan reduces your damages by your percentage of fault under MCL 600.2959. But if your fault is greater than the aggregate fault of the other persons involved, noneconomic damages are not awarded, and economic damages are still reduced by your percentage. In motor vehicle cases MCL 500.3135(2)(b) also bars noneconomic damages for a party more than 50% at fault.

Two statutes work together. MCL 600.2959 requires the court to reduce damages by the percentage of comparative fault of the person injured, and if that person's fault is greater than the aggregate fault of the other persons, whether or not parties, noneconomic damages are not awarded. For claims for noneconomic loss arising from the use of a motor vehicle, MCL 500.3135(2)(b) says damages must be assessed on the basis of comparative fault, except that damages must not be assessed in favor of a party who is more than 50% at fault. Fault is allocated among everyone, including nonparties, under MCL 600.2957. Your fault does not reduce your PIP benefits, which are paid without regard to fault under MCL 500.3105. Common disputes are speed, distraction, lane changes and alcohol. Failing to wear a seat belt can reduce a recovery by no more than 5% under MCL 257.710e(8). The jury allocates the percentages, so evidence from the scene, vehicle data and witnesses can change the outcome. Do not give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurer before knowing how fault is likely to be argued.

Authority: MCL 600.2959; MCL 500.3135; MCL 600.2957; MCL 500.3105; MCL 257.710e. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can I recover my deductible or car repair costs from the other driver in Michigan?

Yes, up to a limit. MCL 500.3135(3)(e) preserves a claim for up to $3,000 of damage to a motor vehicle, for accidents after July 1, 2020, to the extent not covered by insurance. It is called the mini-tort. The action is brought in the small claims division of the district court whenever legally possible, and damages are assessed by comparative fault.

For accidents occurring after July 1, 2020, the cap in MCL 500.3135(3)(e) is $3,000, up from $1,000 before that. The rules in subsection (4) are: damages are assessed on comparative fault, with nothing awarded to a party more than 50% at fault; liability is not a component of residual liability insurance; the action must be commenced whenever legally possible in the small claims division of the district court or the municipal court, and costs may be assessed if a party removes the case to a higher court and does not prevail; a decision is not res judicata for other claims from the same facts; and damages are not assessed if the damaged vehicle was being operated without the required security. The claim covers the part not covered by insurance, which commonly is the collision deductible. The deadlines deserve attention, because the three-year period in MCL 600.5805(2) is the usual limit for property damage suits. Estimates and photos should be kept.

Authority: MCL 500.3135; MCL 600.5805. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

I was driving my own car without insurance and I was hit. Can I still sue?

Not for pain and suffering, and what economic claims remain depends on the facts. Under MCL 500.3135(2)(c), noneconomic damages must not be assessed in favor of a party who was operating his or her own vehicle without the required security in effect. You are also excluded from PIP benefits as the owner or registrant of an uninsured vehicle under MCL 500.3113(b).

Michigan penalizes driving an uninsured vehicle in both the benefits system and the tort system. MCL 500.3113(b) says an owner or registrant of a motor vehicle or motorcycle involved in the accident for which required security was not in effect is not entitled to PIP. MCL 500.3135(2)(c) bars noneconomic damages for a party who was operating his or her own vehicle at the time of injury and did not have the required security in effect, and subsection (4)(e) bars the $3,000 vehicle damage claim if the damaged vehicle was operated without the required security. That leaves limited remaining claims, which depend on the facts. Whether coverage was really absent is sometimes disputed, for example when a policy lapse notice was defective or the vehicle belonged to someone else. A passenger in an uninsured car who does not own it has different rights than the owner, so ownership and registration need to be checked. Ownership is broader than title: a person who has the use of a vehicle, under a lease or otherwise, for more than 30 days is an owner, even if a company he solely owns holds the title. Abdulla v Progressive Se Ins Co, Nos. 167532 and 167533 (Mich July 7, 2026). The policy history and registration records should be obtained before reaching any conclusion.

Authority: MCL 500.3135; MCL 500.3113; Abdulla v Progressive Se Ins Co, Nos. 167532 and 167533 (Mich July 7, 2026). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

How do uninsured and underinsured motorist claims work in Michigan, and how long do I have?

Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is contractual, so your policy decides who is covered, what counts as uninsured or underinsured, and how fast you must give notice or sue. The default limitations period for a contract claim is six years under MCL 600.5807(9), but the Michigan Supreme Court has enforced unambiguous shortened policy periods as written, although it has since criticized the reasoning of that decision.

UM and UIM benefits come from the terms of the policy rather than from the no-fault statutes. In Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457 (2005), a UM claim was barred by a one-year contractual limitations period, and the Court held that an unambiguous shortened period is enforced unless it violates law or public policy, without a judicial reasonableness review. MCL 600.5807(9) provides six years for contract claims that are not covered by another subsection, so a policy that says nothing on timing can leave longer. In Rayford v American House Roseville I, LLC, No. 163989 (Mich July 31, 2025), the Court held that Rory's language reaching beyond insurance contracts was nonbinding dicta and that shortened periods in adhesive employment agreements get a reasonableness review, so Rory still governs a shortened period in an insurance policy. The Court in Rayford also described Rory as a break from earlier precedent, so the law here may continue to develop, and whether Rory's approach applies to other kinds of contracts is unsettled. The policy and the law as it stands should be checked before anyone treats the deadline as safe. Policies may also require notice of the claim, cooperation, consent before settling with the at-fault driver, and sometimes arbitration. A complete certified copy of the policy, including all endorsements, is worth requesting early in the case.

Authority: Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457 (2005); MCL 600.5807; Rayford v American House Roseville I, LLC, No. 163989 (Mich July 31, 2025). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

What is the difference between uninsured motorist and underinsured motorist coverage, and how do I know if I have either on my Michigan policy?

Both are optional coverages bought from your own insurer, and the policy wording, not a statute, sets the terms. Uninsured motorist coverage is for injuries caused by a driver with no insurance, and many policies also treat an unidentified hit-and-run vehicle as uninsured. Underinsured motorist coverage is for when the at-fault driver has insurance that is not enough. The declarations page and the endorsements show whether you have either and in what amounts.

Michigan does not require either coverage. The Michigan Supreme Court has said that uninsured motorist coverage is optional, that it is not compulsory coverage mandated by the no-fault act, and that the rights and limitations of the coverage are purely contractual (Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 465-466 (2005)). The Court of Appeals has applied the same rule to underinsured motorist coverage: like uninsured motorist benefits, it is not required by Michigan law, and the terms of coverage are controlled by the language of the contract itself, not by statute (Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 568 (2011)). Personal protection insurance is different, because those benefits are mandated by the no-fault act and the statute governs them (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 568).

Uninsured motorist coverage lets an injured person collect from his or her own insurer to the extent that a claim would be permitted against the uninsured at-fault driver (Rory, 473 Mich at 465). In the policy in one reported case, the insurer agreed to pay damages an insured is legally entitled to collect from the owner or driver of an uninsured motor vehicle, and the policy defined a hit-and-run vehicle whose owner or driver remains unknown as an uninsured motor vehicle if it strikes the insured or the vehicle the insured is occupying (Berry v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co, 219 Mich App 340, 342 (1996)). Whether a given policy treats a hit-and-run vehicle that way is a matter of its definitions.

Underinsured motorist coverage comes into play when the at-fault driver does have liability insurance but not enough. In Dawson, the at-fault driver's liability limit was $20,000 and the injured passenger's damages were stipulated at $100,000, so he looked to the underinsured motorist provision of his own policy (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 565-566). In Andreson v Progressive Marathon Ins Co, 322 Mich App 76, 80-81, 85 (2017), the at-fault driver's insurer paid its $100,000 policy limit, and the parties agreed that the injured plaintiffs' own underinsured motorist limit of $250,000 each was reduced by the $50,000 each received. How the underinsured limit interacts with what the other driver's insurer paid depends on the policy, so the exact wording matters.

To find out what you have, the declarations page lists the coverages and limits, and the endorsements hold the definitions of who is insured and what counts as an uninsured or underinsured vehicle. A certified copy of the complete policy, including every endorsement, is the surest way to confirm. Because courts read these terms as written, the answer to almost every question about these coverages is in the document.

Authority: Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 461, 465-466 (2005); Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 565-570 (2011); Andreson v Progressive Marathon Ins Co, 322 Mich App 76, 80-81, 84-87 (2017); Berry v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co, 219 Mich App 340, 342 (1996). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

If the at-fault driver's policy limits are too low to cover my injuries, how does underinsured motorist coverage work in Michigan?

It is a contract claim against your own insurer, so the policy controls. Policies reported in Michigan cases required the injured person to exhaust the at-fault driver's limits first, credited what that insurer paid against the underinsured limit, and capped the claim at the underinsured limit. The claim still has to be proved: fault, the tort threshold and damages. An insurer that was not part of the earlier lawsuit may not be bound by the result if the policy says so.

An underinsured motorist claim is a claim on a contract. Because the coverage is not required by statute, the scope, coverage and limits are governed by the insurance contract and the law of contracts (Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 568 (2011)), and unambiguous provisions are applied as written unless they violate law or a traditional defense to enforcing a contract applies (Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 461 (2005)).

The policy in Andreson v Progressive Marathon Ins Co, 322 Mich App 76 (2017), is a useful example. It had an underinsured motorist limit of $250,000 per person. It required the injured people to pursue recovery from the at-fault driver and obtain payment of the maximum limits from the at-fault driver's insurer before they could collect, and to get the underinsured insurer's permission before settling with the at-fault driver or that driver's insurer (Andreson, 322 Mich App at 80-81). The at-fault driver's insurer paid its $100,000 policy limit, and the parties agreed that the $50,000 each plaintiff received reduced the underinsured insurer's liability to $200,000 per person (Andreson, 322 Mich App at 81, 85). A jury verdict above that figure could not stand: the court ruled that the trial court could not enter an award exceeding the maximum liability agreed in the contract, and it sent the case back for judgment at the policy-limit figure (Andreson, 322 Mich App at 85-87). Other policies are worded differently, so a policy's own credit and limit language has to be read.

The injured person still has to prove the underlying claim. In Andreson the central issues at trial were whether the plaintiffs suffered serious impairments of body function because of the at-fault driver's negligence and whether one plaintiff's back injury was caused by the crash (Andreson, 322 Mich App at 81). The serious impairment requirement comes from MCL 500.3135(1), under which a person remains subject to tort liability for noneconomic loss caused by use of a motor vehicle only if the injured person has suffered death, serious impairment of body function, or permanent serious disfigurement.

The earlier lawsuit against the at-fault driver may not settle the issue. In Dawson the underinsured insurer had declined to approve a settlement, the case against the driver went to a 29-minute trial with stipulated damages, and the court held that the insurer was not bound by that judgment because the policy said it would not be bound by any judgment or settlement made without its written consent (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 565-569). The court explained that such provisions are intended to ensure that the insurer is not embroiled in litigation before there has been a determination that the responsible driver is actually underinsured and to preserve its right to litigate liability and damages (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 569-570). In that policy, the insurer could not be sued for underinsured benefits unless and until other payments or judgments were exhausted (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 569). Notice and suit deadlines in the policy are also contract terms and are enforced as written when unambiguous (Rory, 473 Mich at 461).

Authority: Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 565-570 (2011); Andreson v Progressive Marathon Ins Co, 322 Mich App 76, 80-81, 84-87 (2017); Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 461, 465-466 (2005); MCL 500.3135(1). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Do I need my own insurer's permission before I settle with the at-fault driver, or can I lose my UM or UIM coverage?

Check the policy before signing anything. Underinsured motorist policies reported in Michigan cases required the insurer's written consent before the injured person settled with the at-fault driver, and Michigan courts apply unambiguous policy terms as written. The cases did not decide what happens to the claim when a person settles without consent, so that turns on the exact wording and facts. A written request for consent, made before any release is signed, avoids the question.

Neither UM nor UIM coverage is created by statute in Michigan, so the policy decides what the insured must do, and courts enforce unambiguous provisions as written unless they violate law or a traditional contract defense applies (Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 461, 465-466 (2005); Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 568-569 (2011)).

Two published Court of Appeals cases show how consent terms appear. In Dawson, the at-fault driver's insurer wanted to settle for its $20,000 policy limit, but the injured passenger's own policy required that his underinsured insurer approve any settlement, and it declined to approve (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 565-566). The case against the driver went to trial instead. The court enforced the policy language that the insurer would not be bound by any judgment or settlement made without its written consent, so the passenger could not use the judgment against the driver to collect from his own insurer, and the insurer was free to raise its defenses (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 567-570). In Andreson v Progressive Marathon Ins Co, 322 Mich App 76 (2017), the policy required the injured people to get the insurer's permission before settling with the at-fault driver or that driver's insurer; the insurer first declined, the injured people sued, the insurer later granted permission, and they settled for the at-fault driver's policy limit (Andreson, 322 Mich App at 80-81).

Neither case decided whether a person who settles without the required consent loses the claim. That question depends on the wording of the consent clause, any exhaustion requirement, what the insurer knew and when, and what rights the settlement gave up. The reasons the Dawson court gave for such terms are to keep the underinsured insurer out of litigation before it is determined that the driver is underinsured and to preserve its right to contest liability and damages (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 569-570).

The practical sequence is to read the UM and UIM sections of the complete policy first, send the insurer a written request for consent that states the proposed settlement amount and the at-fault driver's limits, keep the response, and sign a release only after the consent question is answered in writing. A release signed first can end the claim against the driver and cannot be undone afterward.

Authority: Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 461, 465-466 (2005); Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 565-570 (2011); Andreson v Progressive Marathon Ins Co, 322 Mich App 76, 80-81, 84-87 (2017). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Can I use my own UM or UIM coverage if I was a passenger, a pedestrian or on a bicycle or motorcycle in Michigan?

Often, but the policy's definition of who is insured and its exclusions decide. A passenger in one reported Michigan case claimed underinsured benefits under his own policy. The Supreme Court described the standard endorsement in 1980 as covering insureds in another vehicle, on foot or on a bicycle, but that rested on a former statute. For motorcycles, exclusions for other owned vehicles have been enforced against riders whose motorcycle had no UM coverage of its own.

Because uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is contractual, who counts as an insured, and in what circumstances, comes from the policy (Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 465-466 (2005); Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 568 (2011)). A term that can reasonably be read two ways is construed against the insurer that drafted it, while a term that fairly admits of only one reading is enforced as it is written (Bianchi v Auto Club of Mich, 437 Mich 65, 70 (1991)).

Passengers. In Dawson the injured person was a passenger in the back seat of a car driven by someone else, and he claimed underinsured benefits under his own policy after the driver's insurer paid its limit (Dawson, 293 Mich App at 565-566). The policy decides whether a given passenger is covered under it.

Pedestrians and cyclists. In 1980 the Michigan Supreme Court described the standard uninsured motorist endorsement of that period as covering the insured and family members when they are in the covered vehicle, in another automobile, on foot, or on a bicycle (Bradley v Mid-Century Ins Co, 409 Mich 1, 24 (1980)). That decision applied a state statute that required uninsured motorist coverage, and the Court noted that the statute had been repealed effective October 1, 1973, so that for policies effective on or after that date other-insurance clauses were enforceable (Bradley, 409 Mich at 22-23, 46-48). Today the answer comes from the wording of the particular policy and its definition of an insured.

Motorcycles. In Bianchi, a man was riding his wife's motorcycle when an uninsured automobile collided with it. The motorcycle policy had no uninsured motorist coverage, and he claimed under the uninsured motorist coverage of his wife's automobile policy. The policy excluded injuries sustained while occupying a motor vehicle owned by the insured or a relative other than the vehicle named in the policy, and the Supreme Court held that a motorcycle was a motor vehicle under that policy's definition, so the exclusion applied (Bianchi, 437 Mich at 67-73). The Court stressed that its decision rested on the language of the policy before it (Bianchi, 437 Mich at 73). The Court of Appeals reached the same result for a rider whose motorcycle was uninsured and who claimed under his automobile policy (Heath v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co, 255 Mich App 217, 219-220 (2003)).

A rider or cyclist should therefore look at every policy that might apply, including the vehicle's own policy and any household policy, and at the definitions and exclusions in each. Personal protection benefits under the no-fault act follow separate rules.

Authority: Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 461, 465-466 (2005); Dawson v Farm Bureau Mut Ins Co of Mich, 293 Mich App 563, 565-570 (2011); Bianchi v Auto Club of Mich, 437 Mich 65, 67-73 (1991); Heath v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co, 255 Mich App 217, 219-220 (2003); Bradley v Mid-Century Ins Co, 409 Mich 1, 22-24, 46-48 (1980). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

A hit-and-run driver never touched my car. Does my uninsured motorist coverage still apply in Michigan?

It depends on the policy's wording. Michigan courts enforce a physical contact requirement for hit-and-run claims. Under a policy that says only physical contact, indirect contact can count, such as an object thrown or dropped by the unidentified vehicle, if a substantial physical nexus is shown. Under a policy that requires direct physical contact, an object that flew off the other vehicle did not qualify. Swerving to avoid a vehicle was held not to satisfy the requirement.

Uninsured motorist coverage is contractual, and the policy's definition of an uninsured motor vehicle controls (Berry v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co, 219 Mich App 340, 346-347 (1996); Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 465-466 (2005)). For hit-and-run vehicles, the Court of Appeals has held that a policy's requirement of physical contact between the hit-and-run vehicle and the insured or the insured's vehicle is enforceable in Michigan, and has described its purpose as reducing the possibility of fraudulent phantom vehicle claims (Berry, 219 Mich App at 347).

The result turns on how the policy words the contact requirement. The Court of Appeals has described three kinds of wording (McJimpson v Auto Club Group Ins Co, 315 Mich App 353, 359-361 (2016)). Some policies are broad, such as one requiring that the unidentified vehicle hit, or cause an object to hit, an insured or a vehicle the insured is occupying. Some require physical contact without the word direct; for those, either direct or indirect contact can trigger coverage, and contact with a propelled object is indirect contact if there is a substantial physical nexus between the object and the unidentified vehicle. Others require direct physical contact, which limits coverage to cases where the unidentified vehicle itself strikes an insured person or vehicle. In McJimpson a piece of metal flew off an unidentified semitruck and struck the plaintiff's car, and because the policy required direct physical contact the court held that the requirement was not met (McJimpson, 315 Mich App at 354-355, 361-362).

Under the physical contact wording, Berry found a substantial nexus where a witness saw a truck hauling scrap metal stopped about a half mile away roughly fifteen minutes before the insured's car struck a piece of metal in the road, and the court stressed that there was objective evidence linking the metal to the truck (Berry, 219 Mich App at 342-344, 350-351). A continuous force from the other vehicle is a significant but not dispositive factor (Berry, 219 Mich App at 351). The Court of Appeals also pointed to an earlier decision holding that swerving to avoid a hit-and-run vehicle does not satisfy the physical contact requirement (Berry, 219 Mich App at 347, citing Said v Auto Club Ins Ass'n, 152 Mich App 240 (1986)).

In 2021 the Michigan Supreme Court denied leave to appeal in a case applying the substantial nexus test. One justice, dissenting from the denial, would have granted leave to consider whether to overrule the cases using that test (Tankanow v Citizens Ins Co of America, Docket No. 162180 (Mich, Mar. 19, 2021) (Zahra, J., dissenting)). Because the law in this area is contested, the exact wording of the policy, and prompt collection of police reports, witness names and video, matter.

Authority: Berry v State Farm Mut Auto Ins Co, 219 Mich App 340, 342-351 (1996); McJimpson v Auto Club Group Ins Co, 315 Mich App 353, 354-362 (2016); Tankanow v Citizens Ins Co of America, Docket No. 162180 (Mich, Mar. 19, 2021) (Zahra, J., dissenting from denial of leave); Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 461, 465-466 (2005). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

If I settle with the at-fault driver, does my no-fault insurer get paid back out of my settlement?

Usually not. MCL 500.3116(1) bars subtracting PIP benefits because of the value of a tort claim for the same injury, and subsection (2) allows subtraction or reimbursement only for a recovery on an out-of-state accident, a claim against an owner or operator who lacked the required security, or a claim based on intentionally caused harm. Even then it is limited to the recovery less fees and expenses.

MCL 500.3116(2) says a subtraction from or reimbursement for PIP paid or payable may be made only if recovery is realized on a tort claim from an accident outside Michigan, a tort claim in this state against the owner or operator of a vehicle that lacked the required security, or a tort claim based on intentionally caused harm, and only to the extent the recovery is for damages for which PIP was or would be payable. A subtraction can be made only to the extent of the recovery, exclusive of reasonable attorney fees and other reasonable expenses incurred in effecting the recovery, and the insurer has a lien on the recovery to that extent. Subsection (4) says no subtraction or reimbursement is due from the part of any recovery for noneconomic loss or for economic loss in excess of what the insurer paid. Other payers such as health plans, Medicare or Medicaid have their own rights, which should be identified before any settlement is finalized. A settlement paid without protecting the insurer's interest can expose the payer under subsection (3).

Authority: MCL 500.3116. Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Questions about a Michigan matter?

Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Your Rights, My Fight! Call for a free initial consultation.

Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295 Grand Rapids, MI 49512 (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com

This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.

Have a question about your case?

The sooner I am involved, the more I can do. I keep what you tell me private. Please share only the basics until we have spoken.