Skip to content

Last updated: October 27, 2026

When a Contract Dispute Is Worth Litigating and When It Is Not

A contract dispute is worth litigating when the written terms favor you, you can prove a dollar figure, the other side can pay a judgment, and the likely recovery is well above the cost of getting it. If one of those is weak, a demand letter or direct negotiation may do more for you than a lawsuit.

Read the contract first

Michigan courts enforce unambiguous contracts as written unless a provision violates law or public policy. Rory v Continental Ins Co, 473 Mich 457, 491 (2005). That cuts both ways. A clear term in your favor is strong, and a clear term against you is hard to get around. In Rory, an insurance case, the Court enforced an unambiguous provision shortening the limitations period as written. Id. at 470. Since then the Court has held that a shortened period in an adhesive boilerplate employment agreement must be examined for reasonableness. Rayford v American House Roseville I, LLC, Mich Supreme Court No. 163989 (July 31, 2025).

I look first for an arbitration, mediation or notice-and-cure clause, a fee-shifting clause, and any requirement that the agreement be in writing. Some agreements are void unless written and signed by the party to be charged, including an agreement that by its terms is not to be performed within one year. MCL 566.132(1)(a). An agreement outside the statute’s list may not need a writing at all, though an oral deal is harder to prove and the law on sales of goods has its own rules.

Damages you can prove

A breach is not a case until you can attach a number to it. I want a list of what the breach cost you, what you paid out, and the documents that show both. A money judgment in a civil action carries interest under MCL 600.6013, and the rate depends on when the complaint was filed and whether the judgment rests on a written instrument.

Whether you can collect

A judgment is paper until someone pays it. Before filing I want to know what the defendant owns, whether insurance might respond, and whether the money sits in a business or in a person. If the debtor’s main asset is an interest in an LLC, a charging order is the exclusive remedy against that interest, MCL 450.4507(6), and it reaches only distributions, MCL 450.4507(2). That helps only if the LLC makes any.

A judgment from a court of record can be renewed by an action on the judgment brought within 10 years of its rendition. MCL 600.5809(3). A defendant with nothing today may still be worth pursuing later.

Attorney fees and costs

Michigan follows the American rule: attorney fees are not ordinarily recoverable unless a statute, court rule or common-law exception provides otherwise. Smith v Khouri, 481 Mich 519, 526 (2008) (quotation marks and citation omitted). Court rules create some exceptions, including case-evaluation sanctions. Id. at 526-527. I answer other common contract questions in my Michigan legal FAQs.

A contract can supply the exception. Parties may agree that the breaching party pays the other side’s attorney fees, and those provisions are judicially enforceable, but recovery is limited to reasonable fees and the party asking must put on evidence that the fees are reasonable. Zeeland Farm Services, Inc v JBL Enterprises, Inc, 219 Mich App 190, 195-196 (1996). Without a fee clause, expect to carry your own legal expense even if you win. Taxable costs go to the prevailing party under MCR 2.625(A)(1), but they are a different item from attorney fees.

Deadlines and the right court

Most contract claims must be filed within six years, MCL 600.5807(9), and a claim on a contract for the sale of goods within four, MCL 440.2725(1). In a sale-of-goods contract the original agreement may reduce that period to not less than one year. MCL 440.2725(1). That cause of action accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party’s lack of knowledge of the breach, so waiting to see whether the other side performs on its own spends time you do not get back. MCL 440.2725(2). I cover accrual and tolling in my post on the breach of contract deadline in Michigan.

The amount in controversy also picks the court. The district court has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions up to $25,000, MCL 600.8301(1), and the small claims division is limited to $7,000. MCL 600.8401(e). If a business dispute is in circuit court in Kent County, it may be assigned to a special docket, which I describe in my post on the Kent County Business Court. Smaller disputes and claims against you fall under my civil litigation work in Grand Rapids.

The questions I ask

I handle these decisions in my business litigation practice in Grand Rapids, and I start with five questions:

  • Terms: does the contract clearly say what the other side owed, and when?
  • Proof: can the breach and the loss be shown with documents rather than memory?
  • Damages: is the number large enough to justify the expense, after any fee clause is counted?
  • Collection: does the defendant have assets or insurance a judgment could reach?
  • Timing: are you inside the limitations period and any deadline in the contract?

Questions about contract disputes in Michigan

Can I recover my attorney fees if I win a contract case?

Only if a statute, court rule, common-law exception or the contract itself provides for it. Smith, 481 Mich at 526. Michigan courts enforce a contractual fee clause, limited to reasonable fees. Zeeland, 219 Mich App at 195-196.

Authority: Smith v. Khouri, 481 Mich 519 (2008); Zeeland Farm Services, Inc. v. JBL Enterprises, Inc., 219 Mich App 190 (1996). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Does a contract have to be in writing to be enforced?

Not always, but some must be. Among others, MCL 566.132(1) makes an agreement void unless it is written and signed by the party to be charged if by its terms it is not to be performed within one year, if it is a promise to answer for another person’s debt, or if it is a commission on the sale of an interest in real estate.

Authority: MCL 566.132(1). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

Where do I file a $20,000 contract claim?

In district court. It has exclusive jurisdiction in civil actions when the amount in controversy does not exceed $25,000. MCL 600.8301(1). Small claims is limited to $7,000. MCL 600.8401(e).

Authority: MCL 600.8301(1); MCL 600.8401(e). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

How long do I have to sue?

Six years for most contract claims, MCL 600.5807(9), and four for a contract for the sale of goods, MCL 440.2725(1). A contract can set a shorter deadline, so read yours first. In an insurance case, the Michigan Supreme Court enforced a shortened period as written, Rory, 473 Mich at 470, but in 2025 it held that a shortened period in an adhesive boilerplate employment agreement must be examined for reasonableness. Rayford v American House Roseville I, LLC, Mich Supreme Court No. 163989 (July 31, 2025).

Authority: MCL 600.5807(9); MCL 440.2725(1); Rory v. Continental Insurance Co., 473 Mich 457 (2005); Rayford v. American House Roseville I, LLC, Mich Supreme Court No. 163989 (2025). Reviewed Oct. 2026.

If you are deciding whether to file or settle a contract dispute, call my Grand Rapids office at (616) 213-3327 or use the contact page. This post is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not make me your lawyer.

Have a question about your case?

The sooner I am involved, the more I can do. I keep what you tell me private. Please share only the basics until we have spoken.