A Michigan felony case begins with an arraignment in district court, then a probable cause conference and a preliminary examination. With probable cause, the case is bound over to circuit court for a second arraignment, pretrial proceedings and, absent a plea, a jury trial. In Kent County the first steps usually happen in the district court for the place where the offense occurred.
Arraignment in district court
An arrested person must be taken before a court without unnecessary delay, and a person arrested without a warrant goes to a court in the judicial district where the offense allegedly occurred. MCR 6.104(A), (B). Kent County has five district courts, and the 61st District Court covers Grand Rapids. MCL 600.8128a, 600.8130. At the arraignment the court must tell you the offense, its maximum prison sentence and any mandatory minimum, advise you of your right to a lawyer at all proceedings, and, if you do not have a lawyer, tell you that the local indigent criminal defense system will appoint one if you cannot afford one. It sets the dates for the probable cause conference and the preliminary examination and decides pretrial release. It may not question you about the offense or ask for a plea. MCR 6.104(E).
Release is governed by MCR 6.106. Outside the narrow grounds for denying release in subrule (B), the court must order release on personal recognizance or an unsecured appearance bond, unless it finds that will not reasonably ensure your appearance or public safety, in which case it may set conditions, with or without money bail. MCR 6.106(C), (D). A defendant held 180 days or more on a felony must be released on personal recognizance unless the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant is likely to flee or is a danger, after excluding listed periods of delay. MCR 6.004(C).
The probable cause conference and preliminary examination
The magistrate must set the probable cause conference 7 to 14 days after the arraignment and the preliminary examination 5 to 7 days after the conference. MCL 766.4(1). At the conference the prosecutor, you and your lawyer discuss a possible plea, bail, stipulations and procedure, and the parties can waive it by agreement. MCL 766.4(1), (2). A district judge can take a felony plea, but a circuit judge sentences. MCL 766.4(3).
Without a plea or a waiver, the preliminary examination goes forward. Its purpose is dual: to determine whether a felony was committed and whether there is probable cause to believe the defendant committed it. People v Yost, 468 Mich 122, 125-126; 659 NW2d 604 (2003). A verbatim record is made, both sides may subpoena and call witnesses, offer proofs and cross-examine, and the court follows the Michigan Rules of Evidence. MCR 6.110(C). If a party objects, the court may adjourn only on a finding of good cause on the record. MCR 6.110(B)(1).
If the court finds probable cause, it must bind you over for trial. If it does not, it must discharge you without prejudice to a later prosecution or reduce the charge to a non-felony, and a later examination requires additional evidence. MCR 6.110(E), (F). You can waive the examination only with the prosecutor’s consent, and a waiver means bindover on the charge in the complaint. MCR 6.110(A).
Bindover and the circuit court arraignment
On a bindover the magistrate sets your appearance for circuit court arraignment within 14 days, or may conduct that arraignment as court rule provides. MCL 766.13. The district court sends the case file to the circuit court. MCR 6.110(G). The prosecution must proceed on an information, which cannot be filed until the examination is held or waived, and which must state the offense, statute and penalty and attach a witness list. MCR 6.112(B), (D). If the prosecutor intends to seek an enhanced sentence based on prior convictions, the notice must be filed within 21 days after the arraignment on the information. MCR 6.112(F).
At the circuit court arraignment you receive a copy of the information, the court states or reads the charge, and a not guilty plea is entered unless you offer another. MCR 6.113(B). A represented defendant can waive arraignment in writing, and a circuit court can eliminate arraignments for represented defendants by local administrative order. MCR 6.113(C), (E). If the bindover was defective, the circuit court can dismiss the information or remand on a proper motion. MCR 6.110(H).
Pretrial, plea and sentencing
Discovery runs through MCR 6.201. On request each side must provide witness lists, witness statements, reports of opinion witnesses and a description of the tangible evidence it may use at trial. The prosecutor must also provide exculpatory information, police reports, statements and search warrant materials, and any agreement for testimony. MCR 6.201(A), (C). A party has 21 days to comply unless the court orders otherwise. MCR 6.201(G). You are also entitled to a speedy trial. MCR 6.004(A).
Most of this stage is motions, plea discussions and trial preparation. If a plea is reached, the court must find it understanding, voluntary and accurate, advise you of the maximum and any mandatory minimum sentence and the trial rights you give up, and tell you that an appeal would be by application for leave. MCR 6.302. At sentencing the court must consult the applicable guidelines range and take it into account, People v Lockridge, 498 Mich 358, 392; 870 NW2d 502 (2015), and the presentence report must reach you and your lawyer at least two business days before. MCR 6.425(B).
Trial
You have the right to a jury, which you can waive only with the prosecutor’s consent and the court’s approval. MCR 6.401. A jury has 12 jurors unless the parties stipulate to fewer with the court’s consent, after the court personally advises you of your right to 12, and the verdict must be unanimous. MCR 6.410.
Where I put my time
The preliminary examination is one of the few pretrial chances to question witnesses under oath, so I decide early whether to hold it. I also read the charge against its maximum penalty and any mandatory minimum, since the court states both at the first appearance, and I check whether a prior record could lead to an enhanced-sentence notice. I cannot say how a case will turn out. My approach is on my Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer page. If a case ends in probation, see what happens at a probation violation hearing, and for clearing a record later, whether a felony can be expunged. If a case ends in a conviction, the next step is covered by my Michigan appeals practice.
Questions about felony charges in Kent County
How soon is the preliminary examination?
The probable cause conference is set 7 to 14 days after arraignment and the examination 5 to 7 days after the conference, unless it is adjourned or waived. MCL 766.4(1), (4); MCR 6.110(B).
Can I be released before trial?
Usually the court must order release on personal recognizance or an unsecured bond unless it finds that will not reasonably ensure your appearance or public safety, and a few charges allow denial of release. MCR 6.106(B) to (D).
What happens if the prosecutor cannot show probable cause?
The court must discharge you without prejudice or reduce the charge to a non-felony. The prosecutor can start again, but a new examination requires additional evidence. MCR 6.110(F).
Can a felony case be resolved in district court?
A plea can be taken there. A district judge has authority to accept a felony plea, but sentencing for a felony is by a circuit judge. MCL 766.4(3). There are more short answers on criminal cases in my Michigan legal FAQs.
If you are facing a felony charge in Kent County or anywhere in West Michigan, call my Grand Rapids office at (616) 213-3327 or use the contact page. This post is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not make me your lawyer.