A Michigan probation violation case starts with written notice and an arraignment, followed by a hearing where the prosecution must prove the violation by a preponderance of the evidence. You have the right to a lawyer. If the court finds a violation, it can continue, change, extend or revoke probation. MCR 6.445.
How a probation violation case starts
A case usually begins with a report from your probation agent. For a nontechnical violation, MCR 6.445(A) lets the court issue a summons or a bench warrant on probable cause. For a technical violation the court must issue a summons unless it states on the record a specific reason to suspect that you present an immediate danger, left court-ordered inpatient treatment without permission, or failed to appear on a summons for the same violation. MCL 771.4b(7) sets the same presumption against a warrant. In Kent County the hearing is often before the court that placed you on probation.
The label matters. Under MCL 771.4b(9)(b), a technical violation is any violation of your probation order not on a short exclusion list, and missing or failing a drug test is technical. The exclusions are a violation of a no-contact order, a violation of any law whether or not a new offense is charged, drinking alcohol while on probation for a felony violation of MCL 257.625, and absconding, which means failing to report or to give your whereabouts for 60 days in a row.
The arraignment on the violation
An arrested probationer must promptly be brought before the court. At the arraignment, MCR 6.445(B) requires the court to make sure you have written notice of the alleged violation, tell you whether it is charged as technical or nontechnical and the maximum possible jail or prison sentence, and advise you of your right to contest the charge at a hearing. It must also advise you that you are entitled to a lawyer at the hearing and at every proceeding, with one appointed at public expense if you want one and cannot afford one. The court then decides on release and sets a hearing date. MCL 771.4(4) separately entitles you to a written copy of the charges and a revocation hearing.
If you are held in custody, the hearing must take place within the permissible jail sentence for the violation and no later than 14 days after arrest, or the court must release you pending the hearing. If the alleged violation is also a crime being prosecuted separately, the court may postpone the hearing until that case is resolved. MCR 6.445(C).
What happens at the hearing
The evidence against you must be disclosed to you. You have the right to be present, to present evidence, and to examine and cross-examine witnesses. MCR 6.445(E)(1). The court may consider only evidence relevant to the violation alleged, and it does not have to apply the rules of evidence except those on privileges. By statute the hearing is summary and informal and is not subject to the rules of evidence or pleadings that apply in criminal trials. MCL 771.4(2). The state’s burden is a preponderance of the evidence, lower than the beyond a reasonable doubt standard at trial, and the court must make findings, including whether any violation is technical or nontechnical. MCR 6.445(E).
You can plead guilty to the violation, and the court must first advise you that you give up a contested hearing and confirm the plea is understanding, voluntary and accurate. MCR 6.445(F). For a technical violation, MCL 771.4b(2) lets you acknowledge it in writing without a hearing. Read what you are acknowledging before you sign, because the number of technical violations you have been sanctioned for sets what the court can do next. MCL 771.4b(1), (4).
What the court can do if it finds a violation
Under MCR 6.445(G), the court may continue probation, modify its conditions, extend the probation period, or revoke probation and impose a sentence of incarceration. If probation is revoked, the court may sentence you in the same manner and to the same penalty as it could have if probation had never been ordered. MCL 771.4(5). The statute says revocation and incarceration should be imposed only for repeated technical violations, new criminal behavior, other grounds allowed in MCL 771.4b, or on the probationer’s request. MCL 771.4(2).
For technical violations, MCL 771.4b(1) caps the jail time. On a misdemeanor probation the caps are 5 days for a first violation, 10 for a second and 15 for a third. On a felony probation they are 15, 30 and 45 days. A fourth or later violation can bring any number of days up to the remaining eligible sentence. The court cannot revoke probation for a technical violation unless you have already been sanctioned for three or more technical violations and commit a new one. MCL 771.4b(4). Technical violations arising from the same transaction count as one. MCL 771.4b(5). These limits do not apply to probation for domestic violence under MCL 750.81 or 750.81a, for any offense involving domestic violence as defined in MCL 400.1501, or for stalking under MCL 750.411h or 750.411i. MCL 771.4b(6).
A prison sentence requires a current presentence report, and any prison or jail sentence, including one for unpaid fines, costs or restitution, must comply with MCR 6.425(B) and (D). MCR 6.445(G). Extension has its own ceiling. Probation generally cannot exceed 2 years for a non-felony or 3 years for a felony, and a felony term can be extended up to two times for up to one year each on specific findings. MCL 771.2(1). The statute makes exceptions, including for offenses covered by MCL 771.2a.
Where I start
I start with which condition is alleged, whether the court has charged it as technical or nontechnical, and how many technical sanctions are already on the record, because those answers set the ceiling on jail time. Then I look at what the prosecution can prove by a preponderance and at the custody clock under MCR 6.445(C). If the violation is also a new charge, the two cases affect each other and I plan them together. If your probation came out of an OWI case, see what happens after a first OWI arrest in Michigan. My approach to these cases is on my Grand Rapids criminal defense lawyer page. I cannot tell you how a hearing will turn out, because the judge decides.
Questions about probation violations in Michigan
Can I be jailed for a technical violation?
Yes, within limits: 5 days for a first technical violation on a misdemeanor probation and 15 on a felony probation, rising with each later violation. MCL 771.4b(1). The caps do not apply to probation for domestic violence offenses. MCL 771.4b(6). I answer other criminal case questions in my Michigan legal FAQs.
Do I get a lawyer at a probation violation hearing?
Yes. The court must advise you of that right, and of appointment at public expense if you cannot afford a lawyer. MCR 6.445(B)(3). If you go without one, the court must repeat the advice at each later proceeding. MCR 6.445(D). The right to counsel in a new misdemeanor case is covered in a separate post.
What does the prosecution have to prove?
A violation, by a preponderance of the evidence. The court need not apply the rules of evidence except those on privileges. MCR 6.445(E)(1).
What if the violation is a new arrest?
A violation of any law is not a technical violation, whether or not a new offense is charged, so the technical-violation limits do not apply. MCL 771.4b(9)(b). The court may postpone the hearing until the new case is decided. MCR 6.445(C). If the new arrest is a felony, see how a felony case moves from arraignment to trial in Kent County.
If you are facing a probation violation in Kent County or anywhere in West Michigan, call my Grand Rapids office at (616) 213-3327 or use the contact page. This post is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not make me your lawyer.