Hurt by a police officer in Michigan? A force claim is judged on the whole encounter, and who answers for the harm depends on the officer, the department and the facts
I am Mitchell Bisson, a Grand Rapids civil rights lawyer. I have litigated for over 15 years. Big-Firm Power. Street-Level Grit. Body camera and dash camera footage, dispatch audio and each officer’s report are the main evidence in a police force case, and I move to preserve them early.

The court looks at the whole encounter, not just the final seconds. In Barnes v Felix, a unanimous Supreme Court rejected the moment-of-threat rule and held that a use-of-force claim is judged on the totality of the circumstances, including events that came before the moment force was used. Deadly force is reasonable only when the officer has probable cause to believe the person poses an immediate threat of serious physical harm to the officer or others. Having a weapon is one factor, and an officer need not wait for the weapon to be pointed.
An officer who stands by can also be liable. In the Sixth Circuit, an officer who fails to stop excessive force can be liable when the officer observed or had reason to know that excessive force would be or was being used and had both the opportunity and the means to prevent the harm. If the force was over in seconds, these claims often fail. A tight-handcuff claim needs three things to reach a jury: you complained, the officer ignored the complaint, and you suffered some physical injury from the handcuffing, though the injury need not be severe.
Who pays is a separate question. MCL 691.1408(1) says a governmental agency may indemnify an officer or pay, settle or compromise a judgment, and subsection (4) says the section does not impose liability on the agency. Whether the city or county actually pays depends on a source outside that statute, such as a local policy, ordinance or contract, so I ask for it early. Qualified immunity is a separate question from the merits of the force claim.
Common questions about Michigan police misconduct claims
Can the court look at what the officer did earlier in the encounter, or only at the last few seconds before the force?
The court looks at the whole encounter, not just the final seconds. In Barnes v Felix, a unanimous Supreme Court rejected the "moment-of-threat" rule and held that a use-of-force claim is judged on the totality of the circumstances, including events that came before the moment force was used. The Sixth Circuit, which covers Michigan, has since held that its old habit of judging each segment of an encounter on its own was abrogated to that extent.
When can a Michigan police officer lawfully shoot someone, and is having a gun enough?
Deadly force is reasonable only when the officer has probable cause to believe the person poses an immediate threat of serious physical harm to the officer or others. In the Sixth Circuit that question is dispositive. Having a weapon is just one factor, and the court requires additional signs that someone's safety was at risk, though an officer need not wait for the weapon to be pointed.
Can I sue an officer who stood by and did nothing while another officer used force on me?
Possibly. In the Sixth Circuit an officer who fails to stop excessive force can be liable when the officer observed or had reason to know that excessive force would be or was being used and had both the opportunity and the means to prevent the harm. If the force was over in seconds, there may have been no realistic chance to step in, and that is where these claims often fail.
Can I sue over handcuffs that were too tight, and do I need a serious injury?
Possibly. The Sixth Circuit requires three things for a tight-handcuff claim to reach a jury: you complained the handcuffs were too tight, the officer ignored the complaint, and you suffered some physical injury from the handcuffing. The injury need not be severe. Bruising, skin marks, and lasting pain were enough to create a fact question in Morrison.
If I win a judgment against the individual officer, will the city or county pay it?
Not automatically under the Michigan statute. MCL 691.1408(1) says a governmental agency "may" indemnify an officer or pay, settle, or compromise a judgment, and subsection (4) says the section does not impose liability on the agency. Whether the employer actually pays depends on a source outside that statute, such as a local policy, ordinance, or contract, so ask for it early.
Short answers, with the statute or court rule behind each one, are in the Michigan FAQs on police misconduct (6 answers).
Talk to me about a Michigan police misconduct claim
Law Offices of Mitchell S. Bisson, 2828 Kraft Ave SE, Suite 295, Grand Rapids, MI 49512, serving Kent County and West Michigan. Your Rights, My Fight!
Contact me 24/7 by text on WhatsApp. Hurt by a police officer in Kent County or West Michigan? Call for a free initial consultation: (616) 213-3327 | MBisson@BissonLegal.com
Related Michigan pages
- Michigan civil rights attorney
- Michigan Section 1983 lawyer
- Michigan jail and prison claims lawyer
- Grand Rapids civil litigation attorney
- Michigan appeals lawyer
- Michigan legal FAQs
- Michigan government claim notice rules
My practice also includes personal injury and real estate.
This page provides general information about Michigan law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every case turns on its own facts. Consult a licensed attorney about your specific situation.